Posts: 1,100
Threads: 123
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
3
Sam J
Holgate
Gibbs
Hegazi
Dawson
Bartley
Johansen
Brunt
Phillips
JRod
Gayle
But this leaves out Livermore, means Phillips is not wide, plays 5 at the back, relies on Gibbs and Holgate getting forward, No Harper or Field.
Would this team cause problems going forward, is the midfield too slow?
Posts: 581
Threads: 58
Joined: Apr 2019
(04-23-2019, 08:07 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: Sam J
Holgate
Gibbs
Hegazi
Dawson
Bartley
Johansen
Brunt
Phillips
JRod
Gayle
But this leaves out Livermore, means Phillips is not wide, plays 5 at the back, relies on Gibbs and Holgate getting forward, No Harper or Field.
Would this team cause problems going forward, is the midfield too slow?
I think it’s quite symptomatic that we are a few games left of the normal season and we still don’t know our best formation, players and set up.
It’s quite worrying at the same moment.
I’d have liked to have seen Shan trying to play Holgate in the back 3, with Phillips at RWB. An option v Rotherham or Derby?
Johnstone; Holgate, Dawson, Hegazi; Phillips, Livermore, Brunt, Johansen, Gibbs; Rodriguez, Gayle
Posts: 1,459
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(04-23-2019, 08:14 AM)Albion Wrote: (04-23-2019, 08:07 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: Sam J
Holgate
Gibbs
Hegazi
Dawson
Bartley
Johansen
Brunt
Phillips
JRod
Gayle
But this leaves out Livermore, means Phillips is not wide, plays 5 at the back, relies on Gibbs and Holgate getting forward, No Harper or Field.
Would this team cause problems going forward, is the midfield too slow?
I think it’s quite symptomatic that we are a few games left of the normal season and we still don’t know our best formation, players and set up.
It’s quite worrying at the same moment.
I’d have liked to have seen Shan trying to play Holgate in the back 3, with Phillips at RWB. An option v Rotherham or Derby?
Johnstone; Holgate, Dawson, Hegazi; Phillips, Livermore, Brunt, Johansen, Gibbs; Rodriguez, Gayle
Agreed. Nothing to lose in playing Holgate in the back 3. Onlydebate then would be Jake or Sam Field for CM.
Posts: 559
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Johnstone
Bartley
Dawson
Hegazi
Holgate
Gibbs
Brunt
Phillips
Johansen
Gayle
Rodriguez
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
04-23-2019, 08:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-23-2019, 08:52 AM by SW4Baggie.)
Surprised to see Holgate anywhere near our strongest line up...
Phillips best performances consistently this season were as a right wing back, bar one excellent game against Leeds in the middle.
Having him and Gibbs wide gets us up the pitch so quickly, and also keeps teams pressed back. Holgate doesn’t offer much of a threat going forward and as a result sides take the risk of leaving a wide man up. It’s no coincidence the game opened up when Holgate went off on Saturday IMO.
I’d definitely give MH a run out against Rotherham in the right CB role however, as he seems an upgrade on Tosin.
Posts: 1,100
Threads: 123
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
3
I think playing the 3 central defenders puts us in a position that we are shoe horning our better players into unorthodox positions, Phillips out wide attacking is where I like to see him, as Barnes did on the other flank, trying to hold him back by being wing back limits this, he can never offer the defensive cover of Holgate and as we have seen, we are vulnerable relying on the 3 CBs.
Another weakness is we do not have a natural left footed CB.
I guess this is why Shan is managing and not us...
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
Stunned anyone would think Holgate wouldn't be in our strongest 11, regardless of position
Posts: 559
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
We've consistently looked better going forward playing a back 3. Plus any formation that gets Gayle consistently through the middle close to another striker gets my thumbs up. He looks a different player when playing like that.
We conceded goals with a back 3 and a back 4 so neither helped in that respect.
Back 3 should definitely be our preferred formation for the rest of this season IMO
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-23-2019, 09:07 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I think playing the 3 central defenders puts us in a position that we are shoe horning our better players into unorthodox positions,
... such as who?
Phillips has never been a number 10, he's always been a wide player... playing him through the middle based on one good performance against Leeds is hardly saying it's his best position?
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(04-23-2019, 09:07 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I think playing the 3 central defenders puts us in a position that we are shoe horning our better players into unorthodox positions, Phillips out wide attacking is where I like to see him, as Barnes did on the other flank, trying to hold him back by being wing back limits this, he can never offer the defensive cover of Holgate and as we have seen, we are vulnerable relying on the 3 CBs.
Another weakness is we do not have a natural left footed CB.
I guess this is why Shan is managing and not us...
I'm with Stratford on the "back three" issue. If you're genuinely trying to use attacking wing backs, then Holgate isn't your man - but Phillips doesn't provide any defensive solidity, and the wing back role restricts the time he spends up the field. Reverting to the three has (maybe) stopped a bad run of conceding goals, but so much of that was down to a non-functioning midfield. On yesterday's evidence I would be starting with Field. He reads the game as well as Barry but is many years sprightlier than either him or Brunt. Dawson/Hegazi in a central pair with Holgate and Gibbs at fullback is still our best line-up, subject to fitness.
Holgate has joined Barry in being (allegedly) unbeatable in a back three. I guess neither of them will get much of an opportunity to show what world-beaters they are in that role.
|