Cov - Ratings and Onions
#1
I thought we got it largely wrong last night and the players on the pitch didn't do enough to overcome the challenges posed by Cov. These things happen and there's no reason to get too carried away. Both in terms of the players and managers short comings on one night

We didn't have our usual tight, compact shape off the ball and we were a little passive in the tackle and press which caused us issues in defense. They had too much space to shoot from distance which made it look like shots in when in reality there were very few CCC's for Cov. The peno also come from poor challenges and a lack of aggression. Again this happens at times but we need to learn from it. 

Tactically, thought we never got it right either. We never got enough pace into wide areas where the space was and we didn't manage the ball well enough in CM which is a shame as on paper we had good ball players in there. We should have had Grady on earlier and played BTA close to Dike, and had more bite in CM. 

The above sounds horrific, but in reality it was small things that wasn't quite right and I have no doubt CC will get it right v Brizzle City.

Ratings:

Palmer - 8 - Good showing and showing improvements in terms of his distribution.

Furlong - 6 - Defending well at present, but shocking in possession and offensively. 
O'Shea - 6 - Missed some stuff defensively and was unusually passive in his challenges. Good distribution though and moved into midfield well on occasions.
Pieter's - 7 - Going about his business very quietly yet efficiently at the moment, very competent.
Townsend - 5 - really poor again. Should be dropped.

Okay - 8 (MOTM) - Fantastic. Covered the ground, won the ball time and time again and passed well. Pick of the bunch.
Swift - 6 - Game passed him by at times, but shows moments of real quality and tends to be at the centre of anything good we go.   

Wallace - 6 - Same graft as always, but poor on the ball and final product was off. Symptomatic of the game in general.
Rogic - 5 - Poor but it happens. No worries about him in the long run.
Phillips - 6 - See Wallace, was better when he moved to the right.

BTA - 7 - Never stopped, but tried to do everything at 100mph and he needs to learn that sometimes "less is more". Still learning and still think he's better from the bench atm. That being said he caused trouble and makes bad balls look good sometimes.  

Subs:

TGH - 5 - poor again when he came on 
Molumby - 6 - No impact, didn't add the steel that we needed and the change unbalanced us even more. 
Dike - 6 - No impact above what BTA offered, but showed his power on occasions. 
Grady - Not long enough to judge.

Carlos - 4 - Got it all wrong for the first time since he's been here. But we can defo let him off.

File it under "crap, horrible, winter, Championship game", forget it, and go again on Boxing Day.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Agree with everything except 2 points. Firstly, I don’t think TGH was poor when he come on. Either he or Molumby should have started instead of Rogic/Swift.

Also, I don’t think Pieters has been great in his run at CB. I know we’ve not been conceding goals but not sure how much of that is down to him. I’m itching for Ajai or Bartley to come in now. I wouldn’t be against trying EP at LB, however. Although that’s more a case of how bad Townsend is rather than wanting Pieters to play.
Reply
#3
(12-22-2022, 10:22 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Agree with everything except 2 points. Firstly, I don’t think TGH was poor when he come on. Either he or Molumby should have started instead of Rogic/Swift.

Also, I don’t think Pieters has been great in his run at CB. I know we’ve not been conceding goals but not sure how much of that is down to him. I’m itching for Ajai or Bartley to come in now. I wouldn’t be against trying EP at LB, however. Although that’s more a case of how bad Townsend is rather than wanting Pieters to play.

Think CC is still trying to understand how to use TGH ... the fact he's now getting our more experienced MCs to perform means we aren't as desperate for him to provide enthusiasm and energy to liven up otherwise turgid selections.

Agree on Pieters, I think he's been a liability in most games. He's trying but his body just isn't up to it... I'm not sure what Reach has done to get bombed out by CC - he really ought to be given a go ahead of Townsend, especially if we're going to use Dike up top.
Reply
#4
Agree with pretty much all of the OP, probably wouldn't have Yokuslu as an 8 but he was the pick of the bunch in midfield for sure. I thought CC was going to revert back to having Molumby or TGH in midfield as Cov are a much better side than Rotherham, hopefully he's learnt from this as Rogic/Swift leaves us exposed. Rogic changed the game against Sunderland, and would have been ideal to bring on last night when we gained some control
Reply
#5
I don't think many of us would have picked Rogic and Swift for last night, even though we might have wanted to see if it worked and how it played out

Cov were very good and some sides won't be as good against us so I wouldn't banish the idea to the bin but I thought going TGH for Rogic or most likely Molumby would have been the call, surprised he did what he did but in reality we were never really at the races last night

One thing it should highlight is we're far from the finished article and if we look at the market properly RB, LB, CM, LW are all areas we can improve in

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#6
Good post. Definitely agree that tactically it was off and the players couldn't match what was in front of them. I think having Rogic + Swift to start is very luxurious and Mowbray-esque - Cov as it turned out were super fit, loved pressing and happy to put their foot in - which never allowed us to really get a grip in the middle until they had a bit of a rest for a while in the second half.

Palmer MOTM.
Reply
#7
Palmer man of the match, with Okay just behind him.

Carlos still in massive credit, but I think we need a home and away set up. When teams are sitting deep at the Hawthorns, picking both Rogic and Swift makes sense. Away from home think it's either or, not both.

I'd also like to see Grady get a chance ahead of Phillips. He offers more going forwards, and has definitely improved defensively this season.

The full backs have been the weakness most of the season, but Carlos keeps picking them, so obviously isn't overly impressed by the alternatives.

It will be interesting if there is any scope for improving the squad in January. It will be minor tweaks, and we'll need to balance the books.
Reply
#8
Given the amount of chat there has been for some time concerning Townsend's poor performances, I wonder whether CC will be tempted to throw Ashworth in for a couple of games. In all the clamour for youngsters to get game time, he's one that often seems a bit overlooked and for me has looked arguably our most assured prospect when he's been on the pitch. He's certainly never let us down and if - and it's looking quite likely - we've not got a pot to piss in come January then perhaps it's an option we'll have to explore.
Reply
#9
(12-22-2022, 02:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Given the amount of chat there has been for some time concerning Townsend's poor performances, I wonder whether CC will be tempted to throw Ashworth in for a couple of games. In all the clamour for youngsters to get game time, he's one that often seems a bit overlooked and for me has looked arguably our most assured prospect when he's been on the pitch. He's certainly never let us down and if - and it's looking quite likely - we've not got a pot to piss in come January then perhaps it's an option we'll have to explore.

You would think Pieters would be next cab off the rank in his natural position

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#10
(12-22-2022, 03:02 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-22-2022, 02:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Given the amount of chat there has been for some time concerning Townsend's poor performances, I wonder whether CC will be tempted to throw Ashworth in for a couple of games. In all the clamour for youngsters to get game time, he's one that often seems a bit overlooked and for me has looked arguably our most assured prospect when he's been on the pitch. He's certainly never let us down and if - and it's looking quite likely - we've not got a pot to piss in come January then perhaps it's an option we'll have to explore.

You would think Pieters would be next cab off the rank in his natural position

Cuzer

Fair shout. Just think we're in a good position now to be able to bed in some of these kids and Ashworth is one to me who has always looked capable of making the step up.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: