Rogic
#41
(12-14-2022, 09:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 08:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 05:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 04:17 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m well aware the players will have received a signing on fee. 

If you read the directors report on going concern from the last set of accounts (dated June 2021) it will tell you all you need to know about where the finances of the club are heading. 

To save you the trouble of searching companies house for them, the accounts stated that if we don’t secure promotion this season, then the wage bill will need to be reduced by the sale of players.  The accounts also stated that as a result of offloading players they did not believe we would need external funding. 

When the club tidied up the paperwork at Companies House, to remove details of charges no longer held against the assets, it was pretty obvious the club would be looking for external funding and use these assets again as security for a  future loan.  

A few months later, there is talk of the £25m loan and rumours of possible administration. 

The above does not point to a club in great financial health and they know if we don’t get promoted then the value of the club will fall, meaning Lai will be looking at an even lower price to sell the club.

We all know how the Chinese like to gamble, so don’t be surprised if the dice are rolled and we do bring in funds to go shit or bust, trying to aim for promotion.

Which part of this demonstrates Bruce was working with a tiny budget?

Molumby - compulsory purchase as it was a loan to buy agreement, so those funds weren’t available to Bruce

BTA 300k

All the others brought in, were out of contract players.  


Transfer Fees

In:  Robinson £1.75m. Was this al upfront and that’s why it was a low figure? I don’t know)

Potential loan fees for Mowatt & Kipre


Out : £300k BTA


The net of all the above cash flows together with wages offloaded / brought in and signing on fees will be small. 

Throughout the whole Summer, we were never reported to be after a player demanding a transfer fee other than BTA and Molumby.


Here’s a quote from Steve Bruce from May 2022

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“We have to try and generate some income as well, we won’t be awash with money that is for sure.[/font]

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“I have got to wheel and deal and beg, borrow and steal. If I have to sell one to make the squad bigger or better then I will do that.”[/font]

Oh so when you say budget, you mean spend.

Only 8 clubs in the Championship spent more money than they received this summer - we were classed as one of them. Whilst negligible, we spent money on Molumby and BTA allegedly amounting to £1.2m with the Robinson transfer valued at c.£1m. 10 teams made a profit in the market, with the 3 relegated clubs unsurprisingly generating the most.

Carroll, Johnstone, Mowatt and Kipre left

Courtesy of those dubious salary websites:

Johnstone - 32.5k/wk
Mowatt - 23k/wk
Kipre - 14k/wk
Carroll - 12k/wk
-----
So call it £85k/wk removed from the wage bill

With that £85k/wk saved we added:

Yokuslu - £29k/wk
Swift - £24k/wk
Wallace £23k/wk
Pieters £8k/wk
Kelly - £8k/wk
Rogic - £7k/wk (This feels low!)
Palmer - £4.5k/wk
BTA - £15k/wk (This feels high, but assume it offsets Rogic)
------
Call it £120k/wk

Now I am sure we haven't actually increased our wage bill vs. last year, as that would be very silly, but I very much doubt we will have seen a significant reduction.

So, back to my original point. Bruce was not working with a tiny budget... he was able to offer very big wages compared to other clubs to attract quality players for this level, and he deserves credit for convincing the likes of Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu etc to join us, and the board deserve credit for shuffling the cards around to give us wiggle room to utilise the budget better.

And Robinson’s salary off the books

And include the transfer fee for Robinson and deduct BTA fee

The net figure between ins and outs won’t be far apart.


Totally agree we did very well to bring in the players we did and Gourlay also deserves some credit for that.
Reply
#42
(12-14-2022, 10:06 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 09:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 08:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 05:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 04:17 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m well aware the players will have received a signing on fee. 

If you read the directors report on going concern from the last set of accounts (dated June 2021) it will tell you all you need to know about where the finances of the club are heading. 

To save you the trouble of searching companies house for them, the accounts stated that if we don’t secure promotion this season, then the wage bill will need to be reduced by the sale of players.  The accounts also stated that as a result of offloading players they did not believe we would need external funding. 

When the club tidied up the paperwork at Companies House, to remove details of charges no longer held against the assets, it was pretty obvious the club would be looking for external funding and use these assets again as security for a  future loan.  

A few months later, there is talk of the £25m loan and rumours of possible administration. 

The above does not point to a club in great financial health and they know if we don’t get promoted then the value of the club will fall, meaning Lai will be looking at an even lower price to sell the club.

We all know how the Chinese like to gamble, so don’t be surprised if the dice are rolled and we do bring in funds to go shit or bust, trying to aim for promotion.

Which part of this demonstrates Bruce was working with a tiny budget?

Molumby - compulsory purchase as it was a loan to buy agreement, so those funds weren’t available to Bruce

BTA 300k

All the others brought in, were out of contract players.  


Transfer Fees

In:  Robinson £1.75m. Was this al upfront and that’s why it was a low figure? I don’t know)

Potential loan fees for Mowatt & Kipre


Out : £300k BTA


The net of all the above cash flows together with wages offloaded / brought in and signing on fees will be small. 

Throughout the whole Summer, we were never reported to be after a player demanding a transfer fee other than BTA and Molumby.


Here’s a quote from Steve Bruce from May 2022

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“We have to try and generate some income as well, we won’t be awash with money that is for sure.[/font]

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“I have got to wheel and deal and beg, borrow and steal. If I have to sell one to make the squad bigger or better then I will do that.”[/font]

Oh so when you say budget, you mean spend.

Only 8 clubs in the Championship spent more money than they received this summer - we were classed as one of them. Whilst negligible, we spent money on Molumby and BTA allegedly amounting to £1.2m with the Robinson transfer valued at c.£1m. 10 teams made a profit in the market, with the 3 relegated clubs unsurprisingly generating the most.

Carroll, Johnstone, Mowatt and Kipre left

Courtesy of those dubious salary websites:

Johnstone - 32.5k/wk
Mowatt - 23k/wk
Kipre - 14k/wk
Carroll - 12k/wk
-----
So call it £85k/wk removed from the wage bill

With that £85k/wk saved we added:

Yokuslu - £29k/wk
Swift - £24k/wk
Wallace £23k/wk
Pieters £8k/wk
Kelly - £8k/wk
Rogic - £7k/wk (This feels low!)
Palmer - £4.5k/wk
BTA - £15k/wk (This feels high, but assume it offsets Rogic)
------
Call it £120k/wk

Now I am sure we haven't actually increased our wage bill vs. last year, as that would be very silly, but I very much doubt we will have seen a significant reduction.

So, back to my original point. Bruce was not working with a tiny budget... he was able to offer very big wages compared to other clubs to attract quality players for this level, and he deserves credit for convincing the likes of Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu etc to join us, and the board deserve credit for shuffling the cards around to give us wiggle room to utilise the budget better.

And Robinson’s salary off the books

And include the transfer fee for Robinson and deduct BTA fee

The net figure between ins and outs won’t be far apart.


Totally agree we did very well to bring in the players we did and Gourlay also deserves some credit for that.

Forgot the Robinson salary - this probably balances the two.

Robinson's fee offset Molumby/BTA - hence we actually had a net spend this year..........
Reply
#43
Next years turnover will be about £20-5 million per annum

BTA 15K per week or about 3/4 million per year

Salford's annual turnover is probably less than £2 million

How do these clubs survive without a benefactor?
Reply
#44
(12-14-2022, 10:29 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Next years turnover will be about £20-5 million per annum

BTA  15K per week or about 3/4 million per year

Salford's annual turnover is  probably less than £2 million

How do these clubs survive without a benefactor?

A little out of date now as Covid has meant a few teams have tightened their belts a little but ultimately if you don't  have a wealthy owner, you don't compete.

UEFA recommend clubs have a wages to turnover ratio of under 70%... 

Put another way, Reading were spending £2.11 on wages alone for every £1 the club earned in revenue... (it's best not to look at who was CEO at Reading during this period)

[Image: Ey_nDH5XEAAJhzy?format=jpg&name=small]
Reply
#45
(12-14-2022, 10:09 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 10:06 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 09:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 08:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 05:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Which part of this demonstrates Bruce was working with a tiny budget?

Molumby - compulsory purchase as it was a loan to buy agreement, so those funds weren’t available to Bruce

BTA 300k

All the others brought in, were out of contract players.  


Transfer Fees

In:  Robinson £1.75m. Was this al upfront and that’s why it was a low figure? I don’t know)

Potential loan fees for Mowatt & Kipre


Out : £300k BTA


The net of all the above cash flows together with wages offloaded / brought in and signing on fees will be small. 

Throughout the whole Summer, we were never reported to be after a player demanding a transfer fee other than BTA and Molumby.


Here’s a quote from Steve Bruce from May 2022

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“We have to try and generate some income as well, we won’t be awash with money that is for sure.[/font]

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“I have got to wheel and deal and beg, borrow and steal. If I have to sell one to make the squad bigger or better then I will do that.”[/font]

Oh so when you say budget, you mean spend.

Only 8 clubs in the Championship spent more money than they received this summer - we were classed as one of them. Whilst negligible, we spent money on Molumby and BTA allegedly amounting to £1.2m with the Robinson transfer valued at c.£1m. 10 teams made a profit in the market, with the 3 relegated clubs unsurprisingly generating the most.

Carroll, Johnstone, Mowatt and Kipre left

Courtesy of those dubious salary websites:

Johnstone - 32.5k/wk
Mowatt - 23k/wk
Kipre - 14k/wk
Carroll - 12k/wk
-----
So call it £85k/wk removed from the wage bill

With that £85k/wk saved we added:

Yokuslu - £29k/wk
Swift - £24k/wk
Wallace £23k/wk
Pieters £8k/wk
Kelly - £8k/wk
Rogic - £7k/wk (This feels low!)
Palmer - £4.5k/wk
BTA - £15k/wk (This feels high, but assume it offsets Rogic)
------
Call it £120k/wk

Now I am sure we haven't actually increased our wage bill vs. last year, as that would be very silly, but I very much doubt we will have seen a significant reduction.

So, back to my original point. Bruce was not working with a tiny budget... he was able to offer very big wages compared to other clubs to attract quality players for this level, and he deserves credit for convincing the likes of Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu etc to join us, and the board deserve credit for shuffling the cards around to give us wiggle room to utilise the budget better.

And Robinson’s salary off the books

And include the transfer fee for Robinson and deduct BTA fee

The net figure between ins and outs won’t be far apart.


Totally agree we did very well to bring in the players we did and Gourlay also deserves some credit for that.

Forgot the Robinson salary - this probably balances the two.

Robinson's fee offset Molumby/BTA - hence we actually had a net spend this year..........

I've just realised you also missed Sawyers’ salary. Plus £1m for his chewing gum, if the club paid for it. Big Grin 

Molumby £900k, BTA £300k= £1.2m

Robinson £1.75m


The last window really was about having to balance the books.
Reply
#46
(12-14-2022, 10:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 10:29 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Next years turnover will be about £20-5 million per annum

BTA  15K per week or about 3/4 million per year

Salford's annual turnover is  probably less than £2 million

How do these clubs survive without a benefactor?

A little out of date now as Covid has meant a few teams have tightened their belts a little but ultimately if you don't  have a wealthy owner, you don't compete.

UEFA recommend clubs have a wages to turnover ratio of under 70%... 

Put another way, Reading were spending £2.11 on wages alone for every £1 the club earned in revenue... (it's best not to look at who was CEO at Reading during this period)

[Image: Ey_nDH5XEAAJhzy?format=jpg&name=small]

Swiss Ramble is a solid follow on The Twatter when it comes to club finances. Be interesting to see if he's done a thread on the Albion.
Reply
#47
(12-14-2022, 11:30 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 10:09 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 10:06 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 09:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 08:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Molumby - compulsory purchase as it was a loan to buy agreement, so those funds weren’t available to Bruce

BTA 300k

All the others brought in, were out of contract players.  


Transfer Fees

In:  Robinson £1.75m. Was this al upfront and that’s why it was a low figure? I don’t know)

Potential loan fees for Mowatt & Kipre


Out : £300k BTA


The net of all the above cash flows together with wages offloaded / brought in and signing on fees will be small. 

Throughout the whole Summer, we were never reported to be after a player demanding a transfer fee other than BTA and Molumby.


Here’s a quote from Steve Bruce from May 2022

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“We have to try and generate some income as well, we won’t be awash with money that is for sure.[/font]

[font="PT Serif", sans-serif]“I have got to wheel and deal and beg, borrow and steal. If I have to sell one to make the squad bigger or better then I will do that.”[/font]

Oh so when you say budget, you mean spend.

Only 8 clubs in the Championship spent more money than they received this summer - we were classed as one of them. Whilst negligible, we spent money on Molumby and BTA allegedly amounting to £1.2m with the Robinson transfer valued at c.£1m. 10 teams made a profit in the market, with the 3 relegated clubs unsurprisingly generating the most.

Carroll, Johnstone, Mowatt and Kipre left

Courtesy of those dubious salary websites:

Johnstone - 32.5k/wk
Mowatt - 23k/wk
Kipre - 14k/wk
Carroll - 12k/wk
-----
So call it £85k/wk removed from the wage bill

With that £85k/wk saved we added:

Yokuslu - £29k/wk
Swift - £24k/wk
Wallace £23k/wk
Pieters £8k/wk
Kelly - £8k/wk
Rogic - £7k/wk (This feels low!)
Palmer - £4.5k/wk
BTA - £15k/wk (This feels high, but assume it offsets Rogic)
------
Call it £120k/wk

Now I am sure we haven't actually increased our wage bill vs. last year, as that would be very silly, but I very much doubt we will have seen a significant reduction.

So, back to my original point. Bruce was not working with a tiny budget... he was able to offer very big wages compared to other clubs to attract quality players for this level, and he deserves credit for convincing the likes of Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu etc to join us, and the board deserve credit for shuffling the cards around to give us wiggle room to utilise the budget better.

And Robinson’s salary off the books

And include the transfer fee for Robinson and deduct BTA fee

The net figure between ins and outs won’t be far apart.


Totally agree we did very well to bring in the players we did and Gourlay also deserves some credit for that.

Forgot the Robinson salary - this probably balances the two.

Robinson's fee offset Molumby/BTA - hence we actually had a net spend this year..........

I've just realised you also missed Sawyers’ salary. Plus £1m for his chewing gum, if the club paid for it. Big Grin 

Molumby £900k, BTA £300k= £1.2m

Robinson £1.75m


The last window really was about having to balance the books.

Sawyers was out on loan, so there was no saving Smile
Reply
#48
This is a hard read, my eyes are bleeding.
Reply
#49
(12-14-2022, 02:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This is a hard read, my eyes are bleeding.

Summary:  SW4 and myself agreed in the end, that we balanced the books, with fees and salaries over the summer window. Big Grin
Reply
#50
(12-14-2022, 03:02 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 02:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This is a hard read, my eyes are bleeding.

Summary:  SW4 and myself agreed in the end, that we balanced the books, with fees and salaries over the summer window. Big Grin

Ultimately FF agreed I was right Big Grin we don’t have a tiny budget.

Not sure if we agree that Bruce is a potato-headed moron - but he is Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: