Messi
#11
(12-13-2022, 09:14 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: But could he do it on a cold wet Monday night in Sunderland?

Silly boy- He’s clearly no Jed Wallace.
Reply
#12
(12-13-2022, 08:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Dike is better than both. Be told.

You spelt “Jed Wallace” wrong
Reply
#13
Pointless comparing players from different eras. Who knows if the giants of the past could have adopted to today's game and I suppose vice versa...certainly in Maradonas day forwards were given less protection by the refs.

For those who are interested, good article on the Guardian online about Alexis Macallisters dad, who played with Maradona for Argentina , and now his son plays with Messi in the Argentina team.
Reply
#14
(12-13-2022, 09:54 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Pointless comparing players from different eras. Who knows if the giants of the past could have adopted to today's game and I suppose vice versa...certainly in Maradonas day forwards were given less protection by the refs.

For those who are interested, good article on the Guardian online about Alexis Macallisters dad, who played with Maradona for Argentina , and now his son plays with Messi in the Argentina team.

Agreed, but it doesn’t stop many doing it. 
Even those that recall older times must admit football as a sport is better now. Getting rid of back passes to the keeper, getting away with time wasting and feigning injury, extra added time, better pitches and players who are fitter all add to the modern spectacle. 
Maradona and Pele didn’t have these advantages then.
if you could stop a handful of clubs from monopolising their leagues then it’s be perfect.
Reply
#15
(12-13-2022, 09:06 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: For me, Diego is still the best ever whatever happens.

It's subjective of course but what do you actually base that on? 

Messi's playing record far exceeds that of Maradona in every respect bar one - a World Cup Winner's medal (Maradona cheated didn't he?).   Hopefully Messi will achieve that fairly on Sunday.  

Messi was playing for Barca at 17 -  five yrs younger than Maradona and played over 500 games scoring nearly 500 goals.   Maradona played 36 times for Barca scoring 22 times.   

Messi has played nearly 200 games for Argentina, scoring around 100 goals  - twice as many as Maradona.  

Look at how many La Ligas and CL Messi won at Barca.  

Don't get me wrong,  Maradona was an absolutely unbelievable player but in my view Messi is even better and has been at the very top for over a decade longer and will be if he wants for years to come.
Reply
#16
Messi has played for Barcelona almost all his career - invariably surrounded by players of the highest standard whose only real opposition in Spain were Real and Athletico Madrid. Maradona played for various teams but his achievements at Napoli - a club essentially sene as a joke by many in Italy - dragging the team to not one but two Italian titles was almost miraculous and near enough without precedent.

I think it’s difficult to compare them anyway but that success at Napoli is as remarkable as anything Messi has achieved given Maradoona had far fewer teammates of genuine class.
Reply
#17
Yeah but Maradona didn’t win any Champions Leagues.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#18
(12-14-2022, 08:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Messi has played for Barcelona almost all his career - invariably surrounded by players of the highest standard whose only real opposition in Spain were Real and Athletico Madrid.  Maradona played for various teams but his achievements at Napoli - a club essentially sene as a joke by many in Italy - dragging the team to not one but two Italian titles was almost miraculous and near enough without precedent.

I think it’s difficult to compare them anyway but that success at Napoli is as remarkable as anything Messi has achieved given Maradoona had far fewer teammates of genuine class.

Maradona is before my time, so I can't add to the discussion. However, can a player really single handedly drag a team to a league win? Individual games, yes. And even tournaments over a handful of games. But a league campaign over 38 games? That seems a stretch to me. Surely the Napoli squad would have had more quality than just Diego?
Reply
#19
(12-14-2022, 08:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Messi has played for Barcelona almost all his career - invariably surrounded by players of the highest standard whose only real opposition in Spain were Real and Athletico Madrid.  Maradona played for various teams but his achievements at Napoli - a club essentially sene as a joke by many in Italy - dragging the team to not one but two Italian titles was almost miraculous and near enough without precedent.

I think it’s difficult to compare them anyway but that success at Napoli is as remarkable as anything Messi has achieved given Maradoona had far fewer teammates of genuine class.

Napoli paid a world record fee for Maradona so he was already established as one of the best in the world by that time. That's not to denigrate his achievements there but it was a time of heavy investment for them.
Reply
#20
(12-13-2022, 11:39 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-13-2022, 09:06 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: For me, Diego is still the best ever whatever happens.

It's subjective of course but what do you actually base that on? 

Messi's playing record far exceeds that of Maradona in every respect bar one - a World Cup Winner's medal (Maradona cheated didn't he?).   Hopefully Messi will achieve that fairly on Sunday.  

Messi was playing for Barca at 17 -  five yrs younger than Maradona and played over 500 games scoring nearly 500 goals.   Maradona played 36 times for Barca scoring 22 times.   

Messi has played nearly 200 games for Argentina, scoring around 100 goals  - twice as many as Maradona.  

Look at how many La Ligas and CL Messi won at Barca.  

Don't get me wrong,  Maradona was an absolutely unbelievable player but in my view Messi is even better and has been at the very top for over a decade longer and will be if he wants for years to come.
Being born in this era helped Messi. I'll take all you said point by point.

In Maradona's time he wouldn't have been scouted by a top European club. They didn't have that infrastructure then.

There were less international games in Maradona's times and he suffered injuries as it was a more physical game then.

The big clubs monopolise their leagues now. Messi was in a team of world stars. This wasn't the case before Sky etc. It's like arguing Take That are one of the greatest bands all time as they've had a dozen no 1s. In other words it means nothing as you can't compare it to the past.

Messi is unquestionably the best player of this modern era, with Ronaldo's poor behaviour of late illustrating the quality of character too.

When there's so many aspects of the game different to 40 years ago trying to put him above a dead man who was the star of his time is impossible.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: