Unlimited clean energy
#1
A step closer, according to boffins.  Rejoice!

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-63950962
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#2
Science journalism in this country is pathetic. This is a press release designed to secure research grant funding, not to demonstrate the viability of fusion.

The reactor is from the 80s and the style will never become commercially viable for fusion as it's not supposed to (ICF is the least viable technology and the NIF's main remit is nuclear weapons development, not power generation). Of the total 500MJ inputted only 2.1MJ was absorbed by the plasma so of the 2.5MJ outputted 497.5MJ was wasted.

Absolutely pathetic from the BBC and many other supposedly reputable outlets. As accurate as their reporting on Championship football. It's not difficult to find this information out and realise this wasn't from a tokamak or stellarator but an ICF and therefore that the extent of this "breakthrough" comes with a billion caveats.
Reply
#3
We don't need it - we have coal fired stations on standby.
Reply
#4
(12-13-2022, 03:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Science journalism in this country is pathetic. This is a press release designed to secure research grant funding, not to demonstrate the viability of fusion.

The reactor is from the 80s and the style will never become commercially viable for fusion as it's not supposed to (ICF is the least viable technology and the NIF's main remit is nuclear weapons development, not power generation). Of the total 500MJ inputted only 2.1MJ was absorbed by the plasma so of the 2.5MJ outputted 497.5MJ was wasted.

Absolutely pathetic from the BBC and many other supposedly reputable outlets. As accurate as their reporting on Championship football. It's not difficult to find this information out and realise this wasn't from a tokamak or stellarator but an ICF and therefore that the extent of this "breakthrough" comes with a billion caveats.

'Stellarator' sounds like a town centre pisshead's analysis of the brews they've sampled.
Reply
#5
(12-13-2022, 04:03 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(12-13-2022, 03:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Science journalism in this country is pathetic. This is a press release designed to secure research grant funding, not to demonstrate the viability of fusion.

The reactor is from the 80s and the style will never become commercially viable for fusion as it's not supposed to (ICF is the least viable technology and the NIF's main remit is nuclear weapons development, not power generation). Of the total 500MJ inputted only 2.1MJ was absorbed by the plasma so of the 2.5MJ outputted 497.5MJ was wasted.

Absolutely pathetic from the BBC and many other supposedly reputable outlets. As accurate as their reporting on Championship football. It's not difficult to find this information out and realise this wasn't from a tokamak or stellarator but an ICF and therefore that the extent of this "breakthrough" comes with a billion caveats.

'Stellarator' sounds like a town centre pisshead's analysis of the brews they've sampled.

More Belgian Stella than British Stella in sophistication
Reply
#6
(12-13-2022, 03:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Science journalism in this country is pathetic. This is a press release designed to secure research grant funding, not to demonstrate the viability of fusion.

The reactor is from the 80s and the style will never become commercially viable for fusion as it's not supposed to (ICF is the least viable technology and the NIF's main remit is nuclear weapons development, not power generation). Of the total 500MJ inputted only 2.1MJ was absorbed by the plasma so of the 2.5MJ outputted 497.5MJ was wasted.

Absolutely pathetic from the BBC and many other supposedly reputable outlets. As accurate as their reporting on Championship football. It's not difficult to find this information out and realise this wasn't from a tokamak or stellarator but an ICF and therefore that the extent of this "breakthrough" comes with a billion caveats.

Hard to disagree with any of that, particularly the first sentence. 

Tokomaks are certainly very interesting (been involved in a Tokomak project as it happens) but even those will be a stepping stone and not the final core design - its limitations are clear even to a non-quantum-bod like me. 

But yes - we are still decades away. If we weren’t, we wouldn’t be investing in imperfect French-built EPRs meanwhile, and would instead open a coal mine or improve the under-utilised capacity we have for onshore wind (oh, seems we’re doing both of those things too - although yes the coal isn’t for PowerGen… so they say now). 

The timing of this article is designed to be snappy at a time everyone is tetchy about energy prices. And as you say, nothing in particular to get excited about much at all.
Reply
#7
(12-13-2022, 04:19 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(12-13-2022, 03:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Science journalism in this country is pathetic. This is a press release designed to secure research grant funding, not to demonstrate the viability of fusion.

The reactor is from the 80s and the style will never become commercially viable for fusion as it's not supposed to (ICF is the least viable technology and the NIF's main remit is nuclear weapons development, not power generation). Of the total 500MJ inputted only 2.1MJ was absorbed by the plasma so of the 2.5MJ outputted 497.5MJ was wasted.

Absolutely pathetic from the BBC and many other supposedly reputable outlets. As accurate as their reporting on Championship football. It's not difficult to find this information out and realise this wasn't from a tokamak or stellarator but an ICF and therefore that the extent of this "breakthrough" comes with a billion caveats.

Hard to disagree with any of that, particularly the first sentence. 

Tokomaks are certainly very interesting (been involved in a Tokomak project as it happens) but even those will be a stepping stone and not the final core design - its limitations are clear even to a non-quantum-bod like me. 

But yes - we are still decades away. If we weren’t, we wouldn’t be investing in imperfect French-built EPRs meanwhile, and would instead open a coal mine or improve the under-utilised capacity we have for onshore wind (oh, seems we’re doing both of those things too - although yes the coal isn’t for PowerGen… so they say now). 

The timing of this article is designed to be snappy at a time everyone is tetchy about energy prices. And as you say, nothing in particular to get excited about much at all.

Yeah, Tokamaks are deeply flawed and if (hopefully when) fusion generation becomes viable it will likely be through a novel reactor design utilising a more advanced form of MCF but at least they're designed for research into fusion power generation so if a modest breakthrough from that type were to be reported then odds are it's actual progress, not from an ICF which is designed to model the physical reactions from a nuclear bomb explosion.
Reply
#8
Many of these projects have to get results second, and secure the next round of funding first!

The private sector will start wading way more into this soon. Propulsion opportunities (not practical for fission, and for fusion being totally overlooked in favour of powergen and weapons) could well make it so.
Reply
#9
News distraction story. It has no chance of becoming reality for many years to come.
If anyone got the thing to work, oil and gas would become worthless. Imagine the oil barons wealth disappearing. They would buy the design and burn it.
It really is a nonstarter.
Reply
#10
Looks like I'll have to keep gluing myself to trains then
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: