Would we be any worse off...
#51
(04-20-2019, 08:24 AM)11amstart Wrote: If we go up, it will be more by luck than judgement! I have little faith in Shan!

What a load of old cock.
Reply
#52
(04-19-2019, 10:52 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 09:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Whichever division we’re in next season, there is a huge overhaul of the squad required. Giving that job to an inexperienced head coach, most likely under the conditions of promotion/safety being a necessity, would seem like madness to me.

Correct. If we go up, we will need a manager with Premier League experience. Surviving in the PL is a completely different task to thriving in the Championship. Sanchez Flores is currently unemployed, I can see us getting him in.

Likewise, if we stay in the Championship, there will be a big turnover of players and that will require a lot iof experience to oversee. McInnes would be the appointment there.

Shan is suited for neither job but I can see him in a management role elsewhere v soon.

And this is the kind of thinking that keeps dinosaurs like Pulis in work. Survival is always the first priority unless you are one of the golden few clubs who have enough resources to (almost) guarantee perpetual Premier League status. But coaches who think their job is finished when they hit 40 points are the ones who stifle clubs' development and ultimately ensure that no-one breaks through into the "top four". Pulis probably thinks he did a good job at the Albion. I think he dropped us right in the shit. Shades of opinion.
Reply
#53
(04-20-2019, 10:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 10:52 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 09:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Whichever division we’re in next season, there is a huge overhaul of the squad required. Giving that job to an inexperienced head coach, most likely under the conditions of promotion/safety being a necessity, would seem like madness to me.

Correct. If we go up, we will need a manager with Premier League experience. Surviving in the PL is a completely different task to thriving in the Championship. Sanchez Flores is currently unemployed, I can see us getting him in.

Likewise, if we stay in the Championship, there will be a big turnover of players and that will require a lot iof experience to oversee. McInnes would be the appointment there.

Shan is suited for neither job but I can see him in a management role elsewhere v soon.

And this is the kind of thinking that keeps dinosaurs like Pulis in work. Survival is always the first priority unless you are one of the golden few clubs who have enough resources to (almost) guarantee perpetual Premier League status. But coaches who think their job is finished when they hit 40 points are the ones who stifle clubs' development and ultimately ensure that no-one breaks through into the "top four". Pulis probably thinks he did a good job at the Albion. I think he dropped us right in the shit. Shades of opinion.

Pulis did the job that Peace asked of him, which of course differed from what the fans wanted, or at least the method of achieving it.

It isn’t the “40-point barrier” managers which stop more clubs breathing into the top 4 or top 6 - it’s the FFP rules which actively prevent other clubs from spending, regardless of how rich their owners are. 

Much as I’d hate to see it, if Wolves and Villa (if they go up) were allowed to be funded with whatever capital (not debt) their owners want to risk of their own money, but why should they be stopped?  It’s a  barrier to other clubs being taken over by wealthy owners because the upside is so limited.
Reply
#54
(04-20-2019, 10:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 10:52 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 09:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Whichever division we’re in next season, there is a huge overhaul of the squad required. Giving that job to an inexperienced head coach, most likely under the conditions of promotion/safety being a necessity, would seem like madness to me.

Correct. If we go up, we will need a manager with Premier League experience. Surviving in the PL is a completely different task to thriving in the Championship. Sanchez Flores is currently unemployed, I can see us getting him in.

Likewise, if we stay in the Championship, there will be a big turnover of players and that will require a lot iof experience to oversee. McInnes would be the appointment there.

Shan is suited for neither job but I can see him in a management role elsewhere v soon.

And this is the kind of thinking that keeps dinosaurs like Pulis in work. Survival is always the first priority unless you are one of the golden few clubs who have enough resources to (almost) guarantee perpetual Premier League status. But coaches who think their job is finished when they hit 40 points are the ones who stifle clubs' development and ultimately ensure that no-one breaks through into the "top four". Pulis probably thinks he did a good job at the Albion. I think he dropped us right in the shit. Shades of opinion.

Agree with this.

If we get promoted, the most important thing is that we invest in the infrastructure and get back to where we were under Ashworth. Regardless of where we finish up this year Dowling’s role is the most important position in the club, and that’s where all our focus should be.

I’m happy with Shan so far, and should we get promoted he’ll have earned his chance. People say he’s too inexperienced to oversee the rebuild, but that shouldn’t be his role. Dowling is the man who should be working with the scouting department to ensure we whoever is in the dugout has the tools needed to perform. As soon as we let managers control recruitment we end up in the same shit Pulis and Pardew left us in.
Reply
#55
(04-20-2019, 10:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-20-2019, 10:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 10:52 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 09:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Whichever division we’re in next season, there is a huge overhaul of the squad required. Giving that job to an inexperienced head coach, most likely under the conditions of promotion/safety being a necessity, would seem like madness to me.

Correct. If we go up, we will need a manager with Premier League experience. Surviving in the PL is a completely different task to thriving in the Championship. Sanchez Flores is currently unemployed, I can see us getting him in.

Likewise, if we stay in the Championship, there will be a big turnover of players and that will require a lot iof experience to oversee. McInnes would be the appointment there.

Shan is suited for neither job but I can see him in a management role elsewhere v soon.

And this is the kind of thinking that keeps dinosaurs like Pulis in work. Survival is always the first priority unless you are one of the golden few clubs who have enough resources to (almost) guarantee perpetual Premier League status. But coaches who think their job is finished when they hit 40 points are the ones who stifle clubs' development and ultimately ensure that no-one breaks through into the "top four". Pulis probably thinks he did a good job at the Albion. I think he dropped us right in the shit. Shades of opinion.

Agree with this.

If we get promoted, the most important thing is that we invest in the infrastructure and get back to where we were under Ashworth. Regardless of where we finish up this year Dowling’s role is the most important position in the club, and that’s where all our focus should be.

I’m happy with Shan so far, and should we get promoted he’ll have earned his chance. People say he’s too inexperienced to oversee the rebuild, but that shouldn’t be his role. Dowling is the man who should be working with the scouting department to ensure we whoever is in the dugout has the tools needed to perform. As soon as we let managers control recruitment we end up in the same shit Pulis and Pardew left us in.

We were in the shit before they arrived! The only way to ensure success is getting the best possible people into the key positions. Be that the traditional managerial model or the more modern DoF model. 

Both models have succeeded and failed at the club in the last 20yrs.
Reply
#56
Bang on.
Reply
#57
(04-20-2019, 12:08 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 09:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Whichever division we’re in next season, there is a huge overhaul of the squad required. Giving that job to an inexperienced head coach, most likely under the conditions of promotion/safety being a necessity, would seem like madness to me.

You are probably right re the squad and experience I fear.

Shan has done well but if the gamble was to get top 2 or a top experienced coach in quick it didn't pay off - but he has in effect done as well as DM and maintained the play off spot (whether he keeps us in 4th or drops to 5th or up to 3rd is on the balance but I think top 2 has definitely gone - though would love to be wrong). 

His microcosm of a season has almost mirrored DM - some wins in less than convincing style, some poor losses, and some good wins - with home and away form swapped. Hopefully the next away game will be better.

We will never know where we would be if DM was not sacked but I suspect in a similar spot - we had bad runs before and he turned it around and got performance like away at Villa out of us. I also agree that Shan's achievements are maybe underrated, but then so must Moore's have been. 

Re the squad most on here  were right with play offs predicted. Unfortunately if top two was only deemed good enough it led to OTT criticism every time a point was dropped in some quarters, and the sack for Moore.

Shan perhaps getting more understanding now the problems with that squad are more widely recognised and a bit of realism has sinked in. Having said that, we are good enough to win the playoffs and I hope I'm not being unrealistic in expecting us to - though it will be tough.

I wouldn't agree with a lot of this... We certainly didn't get rid of Moore because only top 2 was good enough, had that been the case I think we'd have acted more quickly. The Moore sacking was down to the fact we'd been completely outplayed by Leeds and Sheff Utd and the destabilising influence of Jones meant there were concerns that at best we'd have limped into the playoffs and at worst we'd have dropped out the top 6 picture altogether. From the managers we targeted, it was clear we were hoping for some kind of short term bounce now, or a longer term push at promotion next season, however with Shan giving us as good a bounce as anyone it seems a sensible delay.

Had Moore not been sacked I imagine we'd probably be 5-6 points worse off and looking over our shoulders, though I think it's fair to predict we'd have still made the top 6 one way or another. 

Moore deserves a lot of thanks and praise for how he turned round the sinking ship last season and pulled us together in the summer, however a lot of the criticism he received was down to his own decisions... Playing Gayle out wide, persevering with the playing out from the back, the tactical inflexibility at home, and his in game management/use of subs. These are all things Shan is rightly being praised for, though I imagine had he been appointed in the summer we'd have seen more senior pros leave and none of the loan signings we secured coming in. 

They both have their strengths and weaknesses, but I wouldnt swap Moore for Shan now in the same way I wouldn't have swapped Shan for Moore in the summer.
Reply
#58
I wouldn't be giving Dowling any credit for players he has got in so far. His contribution has been carp.
Darren got Gayle - Barnes (our best 2 loans) before dowling arrived.
All the youngsters Leko - Harper - Edwards - Tulloch - Field are nothing to do with him.
He may have had some influence with the Jan loans, as for an actual purchase he ain't got a single player in.
Considering the task ahead - he should give his salary back IMO.
Reply
#59
(04-20-2019, 03:42 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I wouldn't be giving Dowling any credit for players he has got in so far. His contribution has been carp.
Darren got Gayle - Barnes (our best 2 loans) before dowling arrived.
All the youngsters Leko - Harper - Edwards - Tulloch - Field are nothing to do with him.
He may have had some influence with the Jan loans, as for an actual purchase he ain't got a single player in.
Considering the task ahead - he should give his salary back IMO.

He's only been here for a few months and his only transfer window with us was January where we had a budget of 5p given to him by Jenkins. What exactly has he done wrong? The bigger mess from player recruitment came from the Dolmio man who isn't here anymore.
Reply
#60
(04-20-2019, 04:07 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(04-20-2019, 03:42 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I wouldn't be giving Dowling any credit for players he has got in so far. His contribution has been carp.
Darren got Gayle - Barnes (our best 2 loans) before dowling arrived.
All the youngsters Leko - Harper - Edwards - Tulloch - Field are nothing to do with him.
He may have had some influence with the Jan loans, as for an actual purchase he ain't got a single player in.
Considering the task ahead - he should give his salary back IMO.

He's only been here for a few months and his only transfer window with us was January where we had a budget of 5p given to him by Jenkins. What exactly has he done wrong? The bigger mess from player recruitment came from the Dolmio man who isn't here anymore.

Ah I forgot about the Jenkins spending limits, I was expecting Dowling to at least bring one player with potential in. Do you think that was too much to expect? Dolmio man was a figment of Lai's imagination, all he did was get rid of Foster and a few others.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: