The posh old lady and the black charity boss
#51
(12-02-2022, 05:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I've only just caught up on this story - and I think there are two variables in play.

As a proud member of the Wokerati, I think it has to go down as a racist act, but not necessarily an intentional, hate-fuelled one. The old bat is 83, and has spent the last 6 decades in service to the Queen, she is as far-removed from British society as possible and probably has no "black friends" except that nice chap she met who is now president of one of our former colonies, or a splendid fellow who helped her whilst hunting on state visits to the likes of Rhodesia and Swaziland.

For me, there are two distinct things; the first question around where the lady is from was a poor choice of words, and is most likely the result of years of royal small talk. I don't think any malice was meant by it. Unfortunately the second thing was the persistent questioning of the lady as if failing to believe she can be British due to her name, appearance, dress and ultimately, colour. The belief that this person can't be British isn't clumsy, and the persistent questioning takes away any defence of it just being lazy language. These people are coached by media professionals and etiquette professionals to behave in a fitting manner, and the fact she was still able to behave in this way is ill-fitting of somebody of her status.

Onto the issue of press coverage - this is not a non-story. This is evidence of the systemic racism within our aristocratic classes and deserves attention. There are too many people from the elite classes who feel they can behave however they wish without consequence - let's not open the can of worms that is Boris and his cronies. The only way these kinds of views can be changed are with frank and open dialogue and one of the positives of social media is that it ensures these incidents can be made public without the right wing media moguls deciding what does and doesn't constitute news.

Whilst I sympathise with the comments that the victim in question has previous for calling racism, and I've posted previously that I think there is a need for both sides to learn what does and doesn't constitute racism, as just being spoken to or being treated in a way you don't like does not constitute racism, and the immediate reaction of calling it damages the chance of genuine change, in this instance, she is well within her rights to call out the behaviour.
This ... in spades. Also being dressed in non western clothes does not identify you as non British, moreso if you are also born here. My wife was born in Delhi but has been in this country for 43 years. She is British. If she were attending a similar function dressed in a saree I would not accept the line of interrogation that Lady Hussey pursued relentlessly and would say it bordered on racism. To suggest she is of age and from a certain type of upbringing only enforces the racist theory. I am sure she is well educated and would know wrong from right. 
I fear that in her circles others would see nothing wrong with the way the chat played out and that is, perhaps, at the heart of the matter. Maybe being married to good old Marmaduke has a bearing on her behaviour. Worryingly but unsurprisingly so.

Agree though that in the world that we are in, it should be nowhere near the top of the agenda. Dread to see what will transpire when Harry, Meghan & Co reveal all.
Reply
#52
It's ignorant but not racist for me. The old dear was probably trying to start a conversation with someone who she has zero in common with and thought that this would be a way in, based on the woman's attire. Got it completely wrong based on her ignorance. Says more about the class divide IMO.

For all the royals and politicians claim to "understand" the people, they just don't, and that has never been highlighted more than during this current crisis.
Reply
#53
(12-02-2022, 08:53 AM)George Stagefright Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 10:41 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 10:26 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 09:43 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 09:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Being old doesn't give you a pass to be racist.

That word ‘racist’. Racism used to be stuff like skinheads going P*** bashing or monkey chants. Now it’s this Ted really?
Is it not a misunderstanding between two people with absolutely nothing in common?

She refused to believe the person was from Britain because she was black. How much more racist would you like her to be. 

Racism isn't just petrol bombing mosques you know?

If a few on here spent as much time and effort educating themselves on these issues as they did making excuses for old (and young) racists then it'd be a much better place.

There’s ignorance and there’s racism and there’s misunderstandings too. The old girl probably meant where’s your heritage from. 
Racism is a highly charged word and I think this story does no favours at all to society. 
Your view I completely disagree with on this. It smacks entirely of the same mindset/agenda that made this the most important story in the country right now in the BBCs eyes.
There’s a story about classism in this too, but it hasn’t the same buzz as racism.

No she didn't.  You would realise this if you took the advice on the 2nd reply to this thread and read the full story.  You would also then realise that it's not "the story coming from one person" as the exchange was witnessed.  It appears you work in the media but wont read it, preferring instead to bend over backwards to make out that what happened was not racism when it clearly was.  It may not have been "p**** bashing' or bombing of a mosque, but it was racism that she "decided to take offence to".

Should nowhere near the top news story though, given what is going on in the world.
Well we agree and disagree then. Your entry level of the term racism overlaps with what many would see as naive ignorance. 
I’ll take the fact that you said it should be nowhere near the top of the news agenda as the major bit. 
As I said, WTF is going on when a weak story like this gets such a profile at a time of major issues affecting our lives on a daily basis. There’s some strange stuff going on for us to have got to this place.
Reply
#54
Surprised so many on here are excusing this racism (not the worst case but still racist).
Reply
#55
(12-02-2022, 09:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Well we agree and disagree then. Your entry level of the term racism overlaps with what many would see as naive ignorance. 
I’ll take the fact that you said it should be nowhere near the top of the news agenda as the major bit. 
As I said, WTF is going on when a weak story like this gets such a profile at a time of major issues affecting our lives on a daily basis.

Naive ignorance could perhaps be the excuse if this was a short exchange, it wasn't.

It goes from where are you from, assuming the woman is from Africa, where are your people (you can just say parents) from, criticising her for not knowing where she's from, asking again what nationality she was (born and bred in Britain LOL), assuming she arrived here from somewhere (she didn't), then assuming she was from the Caribbean, all before being completely confused by her own stupidity when she arrives at the answer she wanted.

That's not ignorance. It's arrogant, invasive, rude, prejudiced and yes, it's absolutely racist too.
Reply
#56
(12-02-2022, 09:03 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It's ignorant but not racist for me. The old dear was probably trying to start a conversation with someone who she has zero in common with and thought that this would be a way in, based on the woman's attire. Got it completely wrong based on her ignorance. Says more about the class divide IMO.

For all the royals and politicians claim to "understand" the people, they just don't, and that has never been highlighted more than during this current crisis.

Close the thread - job done.
Reply
#57
(12-02-2022, 09:11 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-02-2022, 09:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Well we agree and disagree then. Your entry level of the term racism overlaps with what many would see as naive ignorance. 
I’ll take the fact that you said it should be nowhere near the top of the news agenda as the major bit. 
As I said, WTF is going on when a weak story like this gets such a profile at a time of major issues affecting our lives on a daily basis.

Naive ignorance could perhaps be the excuse if this was a short exchange, it wasn't.

It goes from where are you from, assuming the woman is from Africa, where are your people (you can just say parents) from, criticising her for not knowing where she's from, asking again what nationality she was (born and bred in Britain LOL), assuming she arrived here from somewhere (she didn't), then assuming she was from the Caribbean, all before being completely confused by her own stupidity when she arrives at the answer she wanted.

That's not ignorance. It's arrogant, invasive, rude, prejudiced and yes, it's absolutely racist too.

Close the thread - job done.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#58
(12-02-2022, 09:04 AM)bradesbaggie Wrote: Surprised so many on here are excusing this racism (not the worst case but still racist).

Racists tend to be unapologetic. Pretty sure she has apologised and would know better next time, therefore has learned from it. That's why it suggests ignorance to me.
Reply
#59
Headline could have been "Stuffy old cnut who still lives in 1953 offends charity boss". Would have headed most questions off at the pass.
Reply
#60
(12-02-2022, 09:33 AM)Fido Wrote: Headline could have been "Stuffy old cnut who still lives in 1953 offends charity boss". Would have headed most questions off at the pass.

True enough. 
I feel the posh English aristocracy are from a different planet to me so this meeting was never going to see kindred spirits bond.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)