Will never get this.
#21
(11-20-2022, 12:29 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: A lot of it is faux, of course, witness Clinton "the Irish lads all hate West Brom" Morrison (despite us having Irish players on the roster at the time). But for a lot of lads, depending on where they grew up, it's not.

No different, notwithstanding on a lesser scale, than that berk James McClean. Even though his methods of demonstrating it may be questionable given who it is that puts food on his table, given the outrages he's caused few can doubt the weight of his sentiments over the issue. So why should anyone doubt anyone's, when it's a territorial grievance.

I can picture a day coming soon where we're forced no longer to have those. In fact, agreeable or not, it's what half of the world is currently doing to another half.

The Royal British Legion puts food on McLean's table?
Reply
#22
Countries are artificial constructs and nobody gets to choose the place of his/her birth.
Reply
#23
(11-20-2022, 12:55 PM)Sotv Wrote: I suppose this question is one of identity for  people who may live here but have ties to another place through their ethnicity / parents place of birth etc.
As others have mentioned, it's not as simple as where you are born.
I should imagine many people have a dual identity which combines being British with some other place. What I really like is when these identities mix to the point where it creates something new.
I've got mates of Indian heritage who have lived here all their lives. On the one hand they are British but also have some elements of how they live that is rooted in their Asian heritage and thats a great example of integrating into Britain whilst maintaining your ethnic roots.
I remember having a laugh with one mate explaining about the Tebbit test. When. I said to him when England are playing India at cricket, if pushed who would you say you support? His reply was "whoever is winning" Big Grin
When. I said to him when England are playing India at cricket, if pushed who would you say you support? His reply was "whoever is winning" Big Grin

I once asked the Great John Kaye who he supports when Hull (where he ended his career) play the Albion.
He said whoever needs the points most!

That's us then...
Reply
#24
Churchill epitomised being British.  His mother was born in New York.  We're a mongrel nation.
Reply
#25
(11-20-2022, 02:34 PM)SophLad Wrote:
(11-20-2022, 12:29 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: A lot of it is faux, of course, witness Clinton "the Irish lads all hate West Brom" Morrison (despite us having Irish players on the roster at the time). But for a lot of lads, depending on where they grew up, it's not.

No different, notwithstanding on a lesser scale, than that berk James McClean. Even though his methods of demonstrating it may be questionable given who it is that puts food on his table, given the outrages he's caused few can doubt the weight of his sentiments over the issue. So why should anyone doubt anyone's, when it's a territorial grievance.

I can picture a day coming soon where we're forced no longer to have those. In fact, agreeable or not, it's what half of the world is currently doing to another half.

The Royal British Legion puts food on McLean's table?
Yea but he takes the poppy seeds off the bread.
Reply
#26
As a long established nation we are so integrated it is never clear cut. Most of my Indian (1st and 2nd gen), mates support India at cricket and England at football. They are Baggies first and foremost though and I am tell them I am more concerned with their parents who seem to think football is purely about Liverpool or Man Utd! Lads of West Indian origin also used to follow the West Indies at cricket but England at football. It helps if one country is quite good. My schools were both RC with most (me included) having a strong Irish connection. We nearly all supported England although in later years -maybe under Big Jack when Ireland were good- there would probably be a good few supporting Ireland. I don't think it is anything to get worked up about.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)