Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
The looming demographic crisis, without making it worse, is absolutely threatening UK productivity over the medium term (20% of people in the UK are over the age of 65) and the market is destabilised by virtue of the rapid increase in interest rates (which requires low interest rates in the first place). 30 something's not being able to afford mortgages won't help them start families.
There won't be an equilibrium until more houses are built. The thing you're advocating for will make it harder for people like me to get a mortgage so even with lowered house prices we still won't be able to buy houses so you're just fertilising the ground for 2008-2012 to happen again where the wealthy with liquidity were able to buy up cheap houses to exploit the market.
And the central causes for our productivity problems are an aging population and failure to invest in infrastructure and emerging technology. Those are the two primary reasons.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
What "thing" am I advocating? The market returning to equilibrium?
Nothing in the last 14 years has helped people like you in the housing market. Low interest rates, demand side measures and Stamp Duty manipulation have all merely jacked up the price of housing to levels unaffordable to all but the most fortunate or already asset wealthy. Higher (though still minus 7%) interest rates will act as a brake on prices, and at some point we might have a government that recognises the absolute insanity of 50 years policy.
The instability you speak of is not the result of rising rates, but 14 years of lunacy. Those who do not own a home should be hoping rates rise much further, as then some of the 40% BTLs on interest-only mortgages will come back to the market in fire sales as rising rates kick-in.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
11-07-2022, 01:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2022, 01:09 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
The thing you're advocating is to turn back time 14 years and do it all over again by instigating a debt crisis that people with wealth and liquidity can exploit.
The instability to mortgage repayments right now is literally because interest rates are rising rapidly, much faster than wage growth can keep up with. 6% needed to be reached gradually over multiple years not one year. Any fallout from that will be detrimental to productivity.
The whole point of the proposed policy is that banks that were bailed out 14 years ago to insulate them from the risk be made to insulate people who's mortgage repayments would have risen a stupid amount over a short period of time with zero scope to address.
I know exactly what will help people like me to get onto the property ladder and it has absolutely nothing to do with banks covering some level of mortgage repayments for a small number of people.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
11-07-2022, 05:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2022, 05:21 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
You're unwilling to acknowledge the severe risks to the economy of a housing crisis and apparently I'm the deluded one. Do you think everything exists in a vacuum or something?
It's not just repossession. Access to credit, financing, other debts etc which will have repercussions on productivity especially given the facility to manage any price rises is extremely limited due to low wages that aren't rising and a lack of savings being built up as it's been spent on building an obscene deposit. That will impact the scope of people to have families as they won't be able to afford to start one, contributing to the ticking timebomb that is demographic crisis we're experiencing.
As for BTL, I'm pretty sure that the effect on that will be rents go up especially in areas where there's little slack in the private rental sector which is pretty much every major city in the UK at the very least.
Interest rates going up to historic norms doesn't mean shit when the rise is over a condensed period of time while wages aren't going up and savings are being eaten up, it isn't like the interest rate rise is being spread out over several years. That is dangerous and the risk of exposure needs to be mitigated against.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
My unqualified take. It has traditionally cost very similar per month to buy or rent, obviously there are other factors in the decision but this has often been the way. Not the last 15 years though. The recent years have seen large profits from buy to let incomes because the mortgage rates were lower than certainly I can ever remember. Also, traditionally the first to fold in a crisis were always those BTL L/Ls that had over-borrowed and were unable to service the loan. This was exacerbated by the boom bust cycle of property prices. One other difference now though is the tightening up of the initial amounts used for a deposit. Fortunately for most, because of the larger deposits required they will still have equity in the property (whether owner occupier or BTL L/L). If lenders take the long term view- and if owners look at their property as an investment and a home- not an instant cash cow
Further, much of the borrowing affected by interest rate rises will be business loans. a whole other issue.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
And which demographic are the ones with the greatest amount to pay off and at the greatest risk of exposure to higher interest rates? What's their likely savings and what's their salary position like? Who's most likely to be affected by repayments rising over 10% of their income?
It's not 50 year olds in the last couple of years of payments, is it?