Damning inditement on Bruce
#31
(11-03-2022, 04:54 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The difference for me is if we fail under Corberan it’ll be plainly evident it’s down to the players either attitude, application or ability. The way he has set up his teams, the coaching and the analytics all give the players the best possible empowerment to succeed.

So this has to be a longer term project. This includes enabling a data driven recruitment policy, not an old pals act, you can literally buy this capability in and the invest is easily repaid. Even Blues have done this and they are reaping the rewards.

Certain posters will get cross at the mention of the word project, but the fact is, we can't keep sacking managers at our current rate.

I would have loved to have been wrong about Bruce*, it brought me no joy whatsoever to watch us get turned over by the likes of Blues and Swansea, (twice by the latter). That Guardian article from 2011 when he was sacked from Sunderland was sickening, because it exactly mirrored the issues we had.

I'm really liking the cut of Corberán's jib thus far. It's about time we had a successful managerial appointment lasting longer than one season.


*Worse than Pardew, btw who at least gave us beating Liverpool in the cup. The best Bruce produced was a draw at home with Watford.
Reply
#32
(11-03-2022, 05:13 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-03-2022, 04:54 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The difference for me is if we fail under Corberan it’ll be plainly evident it’s down to the players either attitude, application or ability. The way he has set up his teams, the coaching and the analytics all give the players the best possible empowerment to succeed.

So this has to be a longer term project. This includes enabling a data driven recruitment policy, not an old pals act, you can literally buy this capability in and the invest is easily repaid. Even Blues have done this and they are reaping the rewards.

Certain posters will get cross at the mention of the word project, but the fact is, we can't keep sacking managers at our current rate.

I would have loved to have been wrong about Bruce, it brought me no joy whatsoever to watch us get turned over by the likes of Blues and Swansea, (twice by the latter). That Guardian article from 2011 when he was sacked from Sunderland was sickening, because it exactly mirrored the issues we had.

I'm really liking the cut of Corberán's jib thus far. It's about time we had a successful managerial appointment lasting longer than one season.

Good post Squid and agree with all of what you've said.

I would say surely Corberan will be given time as issues have become abundantly clear. It is revolution over evolution time now. Sadly for Val he was too early for the change of mindset.
Reply
#33
(11-03-2022, 04:48 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Sooner rather than later we've got to give a manager time and not the usual few months. Watford sometimes get away with it because they're relatively loaded. We're not.
We should have given several the time to develop the squad, most recently Val.
But fans turned against him, and the Board have no bollocks.
A few bad results and will the same happen to Corberan?

I really, really hope not, but it's too early to say. Boos at the end of his first game weren't really an encouraging sign, but hopefully fans could see more sign in the Blackpool game of what Carlos is going to bring to the club, so maybe the vast majority will quickly come onboard to back him all the way. The first airing of a song for him in Tuesday's game was good to hear.

Tough if a few players' feathers get ruffled along the way, a seismic shift in approach is what's needed now and it's overdue. Val tried, but too many fans weren't on his side. Hopefully the same won't be true for Carlos and we'll be on the way to getting disruptive and/or unreceptive players out of the club, to be replaced by players who will buy into his strategy and be good at imnplementing it.
Reply
#34
(11-03-2022, 02:10 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-03-2022, 01:34 PM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: bruce was a fucking disaster, and anyone who didn't see that at the start has a screw loose.

I'll admit to having a screw loose then, I didn't think he was a bad choice at the time. Not going to get into an argument though and offer any "yeah, but, Val" arguments, I was wrong, very, very wrong.

Me too I'm afraid.
Reply
#35
Now that we have a proper coach and I agree Corberan needs time ,but it is more vital that we get things sorted behind the scenes.We need a technical director desperately who Corberan can work with and at the same time try to force Gourlay out of the club.We can not let Gourlay have the influence he has on the club that he has at the moment.I have total faith in Corberan but if managers aren’t happy with what’s happening in the background then they will walk and that’s my only worry looking forward.
Reply
#36
Huggybear Wrote:Now that we have a proper coach and I agree Corberan needs time ,but it is more vital that we get things sorted behind the scenes.We need a technical director desperately who Corberan can work with and at the same time try to force Gourlay out of the club.We can not let Gourlay have the influence he has on the club that he has at the moment.I have total faith in Corberan but if managers aren’t happy with what’s happening in the background then they will walk and that’s my only worry looking forward.
Sadly I don't see that happening. But if the rumour is true about Gourlay wanting Morris and the club (whoever they are) over ruling him in favour of CC, then Gourlay's card is already marked.
Reply
#37
(11-03-2022, 05:48 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Huggybear Wrote:Now that we have a proper coach and I agree Corberan needs time ,but it is more vital that we get things sorted behind the scenes.We need a technical director desperately who Corberan can work with and at the same time try to force Gourlay out of the club.We can not let Gourlay have the influence he has on the club that he has at the moment.I have total faith in Corberan but if managers aren’t happy with what’s happening in the background then they will walk and that’s my only worry looking forward.
Sadly I don't see that happening. But if the rumour is true about Gourlay wanting Morris and the club (whoever they are) over ruling him in favour of CC, then Gourlay's card is already marked.

Eh?
Reply
#38
What I find weird about threads like this is the oneupmanship some have about saying Bruce would be crap and then drawing this imaginary Bruce fan club as if other supporters were somehow complicit in his appointment.

Most level headed fans give managers a chance and despite the vast number of us utterly underwhelmed by Bruce we thought let's give the guy a chance after all we change managers more often than some change their undies.

Bruce though surpassed his incompetence levels with us so it was a godsend his dismissal.

Reality though is most of the smug fuckers showing their bewildering football knowledge off are probably the same who will turn on Corberan the moment he has a bad run.
Reply
#39
(11-03-2022, 07:53 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: What I find weird about threads like this is the oneupmanship some have about saying Bruce would be crap and then drawing this imaginary Bruce fan club as if other supporters were somehow complicit in his appointment.

Most level headed fans give managers a chance and despite the vast number of us utterly underwhelmed by Bruce we thought let's give the guy a chance after all we change managers more often than some change their undies.

Bruce though surpassed his incompetence levels with us so it was a godsend his dismissal.

Reality though is most of the smug fuckers showing their bewildering football knowledge off are probably the same who will turn on Corberan the moment he has a bad run.

Agree with this. I actually thought Bruce was a good choice when we signed. There's nothing wrong with changing opinion.

What I find more baffling are those unwilling to change their opinion when presented with new evidence. In the end I think everyone turned, but there were still an alarmingly high number of posters making excuses when we were sat 18th in the table a few weeks ago.
Reply
#40
(11-03-2022, 07:53 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: What I find weird about threads like this is the oneupmanship some have about saying Bruce would be crap and then drawing this imaginary Bruce fan club as if other supporters were somehow complicit in his appointment.

Most level headed fans give managers a chance and despite the vast number of us utterly underwhelmed by Bruce we thought let's give the guy a chance after all we change managers more often than some change their undies.

Bruce though surpassed his incompetence levels with us so it was a godsend his dismissal.

Reality though is most of the smug fuckers showing their bewildering football knowledge off are probably the same who will turn on Corberan the moment he has a bad run.

We were warned about Bruce.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: