Comparative Healthcare
#31
So who is insuring the disabled? Where there is profit and health there is a conflict of interest and profit will always be put first by companies.
Reply
#32
I note everyone is ignoring the principle of social insurance (as practised worldwide) again, whilst also scoffing at the idea that people don’t know how their public services are paid for.

I am quietly chuckling.

(11-02-2022, 02:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think the British public are too stupid to know how public services are funded?

Do you think the British public are more stupid than every other Beveridge model country?

If you ask the average Joe how much tax they pay then they wouldn’t know. If you then ask the average Joe how much of that tax goes to the NHS they wouldn’t have a scooby. Ignorance is bliss for the NHS.
Reply
#33
Again, as I've previously pointed out to you, even in countries like Germany where they pay healthcare contributions separate to general taxation to their Treasury most healthcare spending is covered by general taxation as statutory contributions aren't enough to cover it.

You're just arguing for putting a misleading number on a payslip, we can do that now. As I keep saying, the funding model is irrelevant and your position is ideologically driven and not grounded in the reality of what your "vision" entails.
Reply
#34
As I’ve previously pointed out to you, I don’t agree.
Reply
#35
How would you like us to pay for Defence ?  Individual policies, with a higher premium if you choose to insure against nuclear?
Reply
#36
You don't agree that the German Treasury funds German healthcare out of the general pool of taxation through subsidy?

You might want to take that up with the German government then, they publish the figures. The FDP have been campaigning for decades to reduce the subsidy, that's how I know this. If we copied the German model the same thing would happen except now an unrepresentative random number that doesn't cover healthcare funding would be put onto payslip deductions.
Reply
#37
(11-03-2022, 07:43 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Again, as I've previously pointed out to you, even in countries like Germany where they pay healthcare contributions separate to general taxation to their Treasury most healthcare spending is covered by general taxation as statutory contributions aren't enough to cover it.

You're just arguing for putting a misleading number on a payslip, we can do that now. As I keep saying, the funding model is irrelevant and your position is ideologically driven and not grounded in the reality of what your "vision" entails.

Wry smile, chuckling calm to moderate

All the argument he puts forward are ideologically driven and fall to pieces when confronted with reality. He’s an 18 stone Liz Truss
Reply
#38
(11-03-2022, 08:08 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You don't agree that the German Treasury funds German healthcare out of the general pool of taxation through subsidy?

You might want to take that up with the German government then, they publish the figures. The FDP have been campaigning for decades to reduce the subsidy, that's how I know this. If we copied the German model the same thing would happen except now an unrepresentative random number that doesn't cover healthcare funding would be put onto payslip deductions.

I'm not interested in your deviation from the principle I'm addressing and I'm not sure why you raised it anyway (apart from to serve your own ideological purposes).

Economics is basically about incentives. If you do not have the first idea what something costs you, what on Earth is your incentive to demand improvements? What on Earth is your incentive to want to pay more or less for a different level of service? What is the incentive of the supplying organisation to innovate or to be customer focused if its funding is guaranteed no matter how badly it performs its services?

Like I say, most people have no idea how much they and other taxpayers pay for the derisory healthcare system we have. Or how much they pay for the derisory social care system we have. It's perfectly feasible to have social insurance systems for both. It's perfectly feasible that shining a light onto the sheer scale of the contributions people make, will make them more demanding of service providers. It happens in every other aspect of personal services we all buy, so why not here?

FFS, I'm only motivated to improve the utterly failing shitshow system that we have. It might well cost us all more, but that would be a price worth paying. Just like the £220 for my foot.
Reply
#39
The principle your addressing is pointless ideological drivel that serves to completely avoid addressing the actual issues with the NHS. That's why I'm challenging it, I've read it all before (I literally own a copy of the Orange Book where one of the essays is exactly what you're arguing - in fact I used to agree with what you were saying except then the Tories came in, fucked shit up and now I know that it doesn't have anything to do with the actual issues). You're literally dismissing the reality of the Bismarck system in it's implementation everywhere by ignoring the fact that it's also funded out of general taxation and not just the statutory healthcare contributions making your point moot.

Nobody in Germany knows how much their individual contribution to their healthcare provisions are because it's masked in subsidy to uphold the principle of universal healthcare. Where's the incentive there?

The incentive here I would have thought would be obvious, it's the same as it was in 1880s Germany and 1900s Britain, it's the same as was written in the Beveridge report. That is to maximise the health of the public while ensuring value for the taxpayer as with literally every single public service. You don't run essential care like a private company where your primary goal is to extract value for shareholders - even Bismarck system countries which are subsidised to a majority extent from general taxation.

None of the issues with the NHS get solved by shifting the funding model. That doesn't emphasise preventative care, it doesn't employ more medical staff, it doesn't open up primary points of care for healthcare, it doesn't reopen A&E wards, it doesn't fund training for new doctors and nurses - the list goes on. Other Beveridge model countries have sorted out their shit without shifting the funding model, so can we. And, quite frankly, I'd rather not waste billions of taxpayer money on something that we all know doesn't address any of the actual issues.
Reply
#40
There will always be state funding of social insurance for those who cannot afford to pay for it. That's a given. However I simply don't agree that by providing more clarity on what taxpayers actually pay to fund the NHS won't lead them to further question the quality of the service they receive and demand improvements.

There is an inherent conflict between the best outcome for the individual and "ensuring value for the taxpayer". As a patient I care for only one end of that transaction. Unfortunately the way the NHS is structured (especially the way it is funded) is far too skewed toward the needs of the producer and the rationing of healthcare.

How would you propose to deal with that?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)