Karlan Grant
#21
(11-02-2022, 10:22 AM)Squid Wrote:
(11-02-2022, 09:50 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He played thorough minor niggles earlier in the season, only to get booed and moaned about, so no shock his confidence is shot.

We all know his limitations, he knows them, he can't help his price tag or when he's picked and where he's asked to play. He isn't a lazy trainer, he tries to improve, it just isn't there, what's he supposed to do?

Never get the abuse of him.

I agree with this. They are only human and the fan reaction towards him is unnecessary and unhelpful.

There were even idiots on Twitter (and elsewhere), castigating CC for picking him, but why on earth would any new manager not try to get a tune out of their most expensive player and most prolific goalscorer?!

If that was the case he would play zahore.........the bloke trots around like a show pony at the NEC........
Reply
#22
(11-02-2022, 10:17 AM)garryowensneck Wrote: He doesn't have a footballing brain, there was 1 quick attack last night where Wallace picked up the ball and instead off making  space for him Grant just blocked his run off.

Yep, but I think that's endemic of our attacking play in general and players knowing where to go.
Reply
#23
(11-02-2022, 11:11 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(11-02-2022, 10:22 AM)Squid Wrote:
(11-02-2022, 09:50 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He played thorough minor niggles earlier in the season, only to get booed and moaned about, so no shock his confidence is shot.

We all know his limitations, he knows them, he can't help his price tag or when he's picked and where he's asked to play. He isn't a lazy trainer, he tries to improve, it just isn't there, what's he supposed to do?

Never get the abuse of him.

I agree with this. They are only human and the fan reaction towards him is unnecessary and unhelpful.

There were even idiots on Twitter (and elsewhere), castigating CC for picking him, but why on earth would any new manager not try to get a tune out of their most expensive player and most prolific goalscorer?!

If that was the case he would play zahore.........the bloke trots around like a show pony at the NEC........

Zohore is many things. A prolific goalscorer is not one of them.
Reply
#24
Whatever the reason for his poor form, it beggars belief that Cleary is not even making the bench.
Confidence is a massive factor for strikers and Grant's is clearly shot, whereas, Cleary is riding high.
Reply
#25
It hasn't worked for him at West Brom. Yes I know he scored 18 last season, but he doesn't fit our system.

He needs moving on, for everyone's sake, including his own. The problem is that due to the dynamics of his contract (i.e. 4 years left on good money) and the payment structure to Hudds, we are stuck with each other for a few years yet. It's a horrible situation for everyone.
Reply
#26
I dont think it's a footballing brain issue, its mostly a coaching issue. someone needs to really drum it into him about what he needs to do in a specific position. or not play him there if he cannot do it.
Reply
#27
Maybe, just maybe, if his name was sung, his contribrution was appreciated, the fact that he is doing a job (badly) that he plainl;y cannot do was taken into account, he may gain a little confidence. Wallace was substituted last night and got applause and he was dreadful, grant was OK, and had the piss taken
Reply
#28
Anyone who thinks for a second Phillips is a better goal scorer than Grant needs to just stop talking about football. 
Grant plays through injuries and Phillips takes 6 months off. 
Play Grant properly and he will score. No need to mention Phillips scoring record.
Reply
#29
(11-02-2022, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Anyone who thinks for a second Phillips is a better goal scorer than Grant needs to just stop talking about football. 
Grant plays through injuries and Phillips takes 6 months off. 
Play Grant properly and he will score. No need to mention Phillips scoring record.

A bit like hoping for liquidation to get rid of the current owner and all our woes, you mean?
Reply
#30
(11-02-2022, 11:18 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Whatever the reason for his poor form, it beggars belief that Cleary is not even making the bench.
Confidence is a massive factor for strikers and Grant's is clearly shot, whereas, Cleary is riding high.

This is a different issue.

I would have Cleary on the bench

With Grant  it is very clear, at the moment because of injury to Dike, he is being asked to do a job he is not really up to.

When Dike returns from injury, a decision will have to be made , do you play Grant out wide and drop one of the wingers, or keep the wingers.

On the one hand Grant has a decent scoring record from that position, but never looks like a good footballer and gives the impression scoring goals  is his only contribution.

On the other you have Wallace and Diangana, who are both good footballers, but don't have the end product that Grant as...this applies more to Diangana than Wallace.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: