Ratings.....
#11
(11-02-2022, 12:22 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-02-2022, 12:03 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-01-2022, 11:19 PM)Baggie in Valley Wrote: Palmer 6.5 - doesn’t communicate well enough
Furlong 5 - suffers a result of the above
Bartley 6.5 - got away with a few but much better than recently
O’Shea 6 - misses Ajayi
Townsend 6.5 - much improved

Okay 8 - getting back to what we know he can be
TGH 8.5 - need to build this team round him
Swift 7 - a nine if he could stay in the game
Wallace 6.5 - effort as always

Phillips 6.5 - great effort, but delivery and finishing average at best
Grant 3 - BTA has to start

Carlos 7 - not pretty, but the game plan worked
The love in for TGH is quite astounding. No way was he MoM. Phillips deserves that accolade but as per usual TGH always cut that extra bit of slack.

Eh?

Taylor was brilliant again. Has been since moved to central midfield. Always looking to drive us forward and move us up the pitch. Has got a cracking cross field ball on him too. Sometimes gets caught in possession…but that can be forgiven because he’s trying to have a go. 

Yokuslu looked like the Premier League version we had a few years back tonight. 

A partnership of those 2 in central midfield is definitely the way to go.

This, his first instinct is to drive forward rather than sideways and taking the safe option. He's still learning the game but has real potential.  Will help not having to do Jake's running. Deffo an eight.

Phillips put in a real shift and was warmly applauded when subbed. Can't do 90 minutes though, looks heavy and is getting an arse the size of Ruel Fox proportions. However, if he buys into CC's methods that contract extension might not seem quite so insane. As we know, on his day a fit Matty Phillips is a beast in this division.

Swift very good today, always looking to make something happen. Yokuslu some moments of real class, like Matty looks a bit heavy and blowing last 15. Some lovely touches in Rodic's cameo, promising. No coincidence that we played some good stuff at times with some proper footballers on the park.

Interestingly, our best player of the season so far looks very out of place in this set up; Jed instinctively wants to get wide and his game is based on crossing however it's clear they have been instructed to stop throwing the ball in the box (at last, thank you CC). I'm confident he has the ability and attitude to adapt, and if we EVER get Dike on the pitch those whipped in crosses might still be useful.

The rest. Defenders asked to defend and did a decent job, simple ain't it. Now being asked to bring the ball out and looked comfortable on the whole considering where there confidence must be.

Grant is not a CF but don't get the hate for him, made a couple of decent runs off the shoulder of the defender. Yes we overpaid but playing off or alongside a decent CF he could become an important part of our attacking options again.

CC. Early days but everything points to him being a proper coach. If he can get a team at the bottom of the table with zero confidence playing like we did in phases today imagine what they might do after a bit more time and a few results behind them. Let's give this fella ALL our support.

Crowd very good, the protest did seem to galvanise. However, there was a period in the second half where we kept possession for what felt like about 5 minutes without really going anywhere and people around me started getting twitchy.....I was almost waiting for the obligatory GET IT FORWARD shout. Some fans will need adjustment to a more possession based game.

I'd forgotten the difference a win makes, crowd literally buzzing on way home.
Reply
#12
I don’t think it was as good as some did, but a big improvement on the previous match which is all we can ask for currently. Without the scrappy goal, I think a lot of ratings would be lower. I’d still like to see a lot of changes to that starting 11, let’s not forget they have played well occasionally for Bruce, tricking us into thinking we’ve turned a corner, before reverting to their usual selves the next match. Hopefully the work CC and his team are doing in training can help build some momentum
Reply
#13
(11-02-2022, 12:53 AM)rickbaggie Wrote:
(11-02-2022, 12:02 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-01-2022, 10:49 PM)Peachy Wrote: Good solid performance tonight. Great work rate too right from the off. Blackpool offered little but we controlled the game very well. Our passing was noticeably quicker and we played higher up the park. Still lacking massively in the goal threat department mind.

On to the scores..... 

Palmer - 7 - Not much to do tonight but I thought his distribution was good tonight with some very calm passes at times.

Furlong - 6 - Steady. Not much else to say.

Townsend - 6 - like Furlong. A marked improvement on his last showing.

Dara - 7 - Solid game tonight. Looked calm and assured.

Shitbeard - 7- Remarkably calm and unflustered tonight apart from the lunge and yellow.

Okay - 8.5 MOM - Great shift. Calm under pressure and kept it simple. Nice balanced partnership with TGH imo.

TGH - 8 - Thought he was very good tonight. Never stopped buzzing around and showed a great range of passing. Good box to box performance. Compliments Okay very well.

Swift - 6 - Tried harder tonight but not much came off.

Wallace - 6. 5 - Looks a bit frustrated under Carlos imo. Usual good work ethic

Phillips - 8 - Wow. The old Matty was back tonight. Where did that effort and shift come from? Long may it continue.

Grant - 4 - Sorry but he's just not a striker. We know it. He knows it. Carlos obviously still doesn't know it although I'm sure its dawning on him. Poor runs. Poor touch. Shit finishing and no bottle.

Subs

Grady - Some nice touches
Rogic - Looked better
Molumby - Ran around
BTA - Has to start for me. The main reason being he's strong as an Ox and he holds the ball up. The amount of times he backed into their defenders and held on to the ball in the last 5 minutes was vital. If he starts he will bring more players around him into the game and actually occupy defenders.

Carlos - Tactics spot on tonight. Team looked more at ease with his methods and the workrate and intensity was very good.

Blackpool - Looked a poor side to me.

Pretty much spot on for those me

Okay is a Rolls Royce and the face he’s sat on the bench for as long as he has is basically criminal,Maas bang up for it from the off tonight

I’d say you’re a little kind on Wallace, he’s had a couple of poor games under CC

Really enjoyed our movement and attempt to pass forward and through the lines tonight, at times we lack a cutting edge and hopefully a fit Dike can give us that but a big difference between the intensity in a 4231 under CC and Bruce where sideways and backwards was just accepted

Positive signs I thought

Cuzer

Well Okay has certainly not been a Rolls Royce this season…more like a Lada Niva. To say he has deserved first team on the back of the past is “criminal”…I swear you watch a different team sometimes. He has been awful…having said that glad he’s given performance we know he is capable of. We need him off the pine playing his best.

Rickbaggie

Point your missing is an off color Okay is still better than those selected ahead of him

He needed games and we chopped and changed, we know the level of player he is

Games about levels Rick

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#14
Palmer 6 - default score as I don't think he actually touched the ball with his hands. Maintained concentration well.

Furlong 6.5 - steady performance, don't need to keep going into his lack of quality. Frustratingly caught offside a couple of times when he shouldn't have been second half.
Bartley 6.5 - all the basics of defending and moved the ball as per CC instruction. Considering he's 6'4 he must be one of the worst headers of a ball I've seen. Proved last night in a system/role he's comfortable with that he's a capable deputy for Ajayi.
O'Shea 7 - much better, carried the ball out from defence well which we haven't seen since the Val days and battled well against Madine who is a big lump. Whether or not is says more about us than him, he's still one of our best centre halves.
Townsend 6.5 - see Furlong.

TGH 7 - full of running, recovered possession countless times and looked to play forward. As has been said he looks twice the player when he isn't doing Livermore's running.
Yokuslu 7.5 - I've been critical since he rejoined but last night was back to the player we saw in the PL. There were occasions in the second half where he just ran through a couple of their players to recover the ball. A great partner for TGH to play alongside and learn from. Earned his slice of luck with the goal. MOTM

Wallace 6.5 - not his best game but can't fault his endeavour. Looks like he's suffering a little from being told not to sling the ball into the penalty area at any given opportunity. Looked frustrated by the time he came off as there were a couple of occasions he broke through midfield and Grant ran directly towards him. One who will really benefit from a fully fit Dike in the XI.
Swift 7 - I was impressed. Felt he got into pockets of space in and around the penalty area, deceptively strong and battled well too. We know he's got a good weight/range of pass but I was impressed by his ability to commit and beat a defender too. Yet another who will benefit from the return of Dike.
Phillips 7 - proving that those shouting him down for the past few weeks are wrong. It's the clubs fault he's still a regular starter for us when fit, but when he applies himself as he did last night he can be a read handful in this division. In the absence of Dike I still think he's our best option to play through the middle, the ball sticks to him far more than it does Grant.

Grant 5 - it's not his fault he's not a #9 but he doesn't help himself. Telling that the one time he actually chased and closed a defender down the crowd got behind him. It's not hard, we're not asking for much. Needs a break.

Subs
Molumby 6.5 - took up the running from TGH well, gets a bit of stick but never lets us down. I like him.
Diangana 7 - lots of chat on here the last week or so (myself included) that he's a luxury we can't afford and has zero end product. Well, it's not his fault that sometimes he's setting up our absolute donkeys, some brilliant skill second half to beat a couple of defenders before squaring to (I think) Swfit who smashed it into the stand.
Rogic 7 - battled well and I still think there's a player in there as he gets fitter. Hilarious assist.
BTA 6.5 - would be 7 but didn't really have enough time. Lots to learn still but he does everything Grant doesn't.

Blackpool 10 - hats off to them. The only team I've seen turn up for a game in November looking like it's May and they're already on the beach. We couldn't have wished for a better opponent. Thanks chaps.
Reply
#15
Nice to read positive reviews for once Smile

Amazing just how little faith Bruce had in TGH in the middle- we saw last season how he adds an energy that none of our other MCs have and how he always wants to move the ball forward. Swift looking like a number 10 last night was a massive plus too - I'm really glad CC has stopped the balls swung aimlessly in from wide positions and instead is using more balls through the middle.

Grant tried last night - thought there was more movement compared with what we saw on Saturday but he needs a lot of work to make him effective at this level. BTA and Cleary at least offer more of a physical presence.
Reply
#16
(11-02-2022, 12:03 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-01-2022, 11:19 PM)Baggie in Valley Wrote: Palmer 6.5 - doesn’t communicate well enough
Furlong 5 - suffers a result of the above
Bartley 6.5 - got away with a few but much better than recently
O’Shea 6 - misses Ajayi
Townsend 6.5 - much improved

Okay 8 - getting back to what we know he can be
TGH 8.5 - need to build this team round him
Swift 7 - a nine if he could stay in the game
Wallace 6.5 - effort as always

Phillips 6.5 - great effort, but delivery and finishing average at best
Grant 3 - BTA has to start

Carlos 7 - not pretty, but the game plan worked
The love in for TGH is quite astounding. No way was he MoM. Phillips deserves that accolade but as per usual TGH always cut that extra bit of slack.

?? 

TGH was superb last night. Always available for the ball, moved the ball quickly, great range of passes, not afraid to take players on and takes risk - yep, nearly costly mistake, but that’s sometimes the risk, especially for a young player. 

No doubt Phillips had a great game last night (we’ve been here before with a new manager, so let’s see if he keeps it up) but for me, Yokuslu shaded MOTM. But don’t underestimate TGH’s part on that. Yokuslu needs energy and mobility around him and TGH provided that in spades
Reply
#17
Good to see Phillips was back to his self. That's the most frustrating thing about him, he is capable of being one of the best players in this league, but his head drops too easily and he withdraws into himself.
Reply
#18
(11-02-2022, 09:03 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Good to see Phillips was back to his self. That's the most frustrating thing about him, he is capable of being one of the best players in this league, but his head drops too easily and he withdraws into himself.

If Phillips was always as good as he was capable of being, then we would never have kept him for so long. His good form won't last, it never does, but if we can make the most of this purple patch, it might help us collect some much needed points.
Reply
#19
(11-02-2022, 09:03 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Good to see Phillips was back to his self. That's the most frustrating thing about him, he is capable of being one of the best players in this league, but his head drops too easily and he withdraws into himself.

Phillips has set a benchmark for himself with last nights performance. He has it in his locker but he needs to graft and be more consistent. 

I was really more impressed with his work ethic last night. He never stopped running. If this is CCs fitness influence after a week then we will be in good shape going forwards.
Reply
#20
There was a lot of talk after the Sheff U game about there being an "agenda" against Phillips and "some fans had already decided he was going to be crap before kick off".

Hopefully that bollocks can be put to bed now. He's rightfully getting praise as I thought he was brilliant yesterday; just as quite a few thought he was crap against Sheff U.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: