Karlan grant
#51
(10-29-2022, 03:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 02:39 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 02:13 PM)Squid Wrote: Not been the same since injuring his back in the cup match against Utd. Miles off it today and clearly devoid of confidence.

I think he looks exactly the same as he has since he joined us, absolutely shit.

Yup.

He's offered nothing in the 2 and a bit seasons he's been here. Absolute waste of time playing him, if he doesn't score he doesn't contribute and we can't afford to play with 10 men for most of a game.

What about the other 10 today then?

(10-29-2022, 05:35 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Whatever he is, he's the only one in the squad who can score goals regularly. So you better hope he starts playing in his favoured position soon or we are going down

BTA like Carroll tries hard but you can't rely on him to score often, how he missed both of those chances today
Wallace and Swift will chip in with a couple, Grady hasn't and won't

Ooooh Diangana now he is one of those F....s

(10-29-2022, 04:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm going to play a combination of an old contrarian and devil's advocate. 

Yes as a centre forward he is clearly not good enough,  particularly for a side that play with 2 wide men who put crosses into the box.

He needs balls to be played for him to run onto..something we seem incapable of doing. Even today Diangana had the opportunity to play a simple ball to put him in, but couldn't do it. The final ball leaves a lot to be desired.

And even if Grant was good in the air, I'm not sure what difference it would make, we are really poor at getting bodies into the box. It is easy for defenders to mark Grant aerially, even easier as he has very little support.

We really need Dike to get fit and be good.
If not we will need to change we play..sitting deep and counter attack.

Very insightful.
Reply
#52
Difficult to defend Grant, but the service he got yesterday was woeful.

Grady is fast becoming a bit like Grealish, with no end product.

Perhaps we should be trying Grant out wide, or play with two up top. We need to try something different, because it's not working at the moment.
Reply
#53
Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.
Reply
#54
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer
Reply
#55
(10-30-2022, 10:03 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer

You talk a lot of sense mate.
Reply
#56
(10-30-2022, 10:22 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 10:03 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer

You talk a lot of sense mate.

Posting here is cheaper than therapy!!
Reply
#57
(10-30-2022, 10:03 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer

Good post, I particularly agree with your point about Grady, for all his dribbling, step overs, & nut megs, there seems to me to be absolutely zero end product.
Reply
#58
(10-30-2022, 11:11 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 10:03 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer

Good post, I particularly agree with your point about Grady, for all his dribbling, step overs, & nut megs, there seems to me to be absolutely zero end product.

Grady actually tried to beat a man and looks interested that useless lump doesn't offer anything .
Reply
#59
(10-30-2022, 12:01 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 11:11 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 10:03 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 08:17 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Is Grant really the problem. Do we become even slightly better if he's not on the pitch.

Amongst the amusing, if somewhat derogatory, posts on this thread there are some good points.  

I remember going on the Hudds boards when we bought Grant, and the general consensus was that he was a wide forward who scored goals, who could not play CF and was probably not PL level. Not what I expected to read, but took it as a bit of sour grapes.  In hindsight, and my ever lengthening experience, fans like this are rarely wrong.

So, a 22 year old who has had made his name playing wide left is bought for a fee massively inflated to do a job he can't do, and probably doesn't like doing.  And despite all evidence each manager continue to pick him there.  He probably looks decent in training against our CD's ffs!!

Compare his treatment to everybody's favourite footballing love child Diang. A left sided forward bought for a similar inflated fee after looking a world beater for 6 months playing alongside the best AM in the division (good times by the way).  Injury prone and a confidence player he rarely seems targeted by our fan base.

However, despite playing in his preferred position, which is a primarily attacking role he averages a goal or assist once every four games....let that sink in.  A considerably worse return than Grant, and even worse than Phillips if the stats I saw are right.

As a humble fan, rather than extremely well paid footballing professional, the answer is obvious.  Play Grant in the position he enjoyed his greatest success in, and in the absence of Dike play TA\Cleary as CF until we get to the loan window.

As this is a frontline of comparative footballing munchkins make sure you FINE any player hauling hopefully crosses into the box.   Start to play to their strengths looking for through balls and byline cut backs, ensure you pick midfielders with legs who can join the forwards.

At least now, rather than the ball just being flung in from each wing for no obvious reason there is the chance that our left sided attacker may just cut in and let one fly.   If that leaves Diang as an expensive bench player, then so be it.

I'm really not happy with this team, but.......Grant wide left.   Willing runners in midfield, Swift told to support the forwards.   The big issue for me is that without AJ that back line is oil tanker slow but in playing Kelly at FB I'm trying to put some solidity and height in the team.   I don't know if the kids is good enough at LB, but if he's quick and mobile let's give him a go.  He's also 6ft plus.  Can it be much worse?

         TA/Cleary.  
 Grant
Swift TGH Molomby Wallace

Pieters/Ingram O'Shea Bartley Kelly

                 Palmer

Good post, I particularly agree with your point about Grady, for all his dribbling, step overs, & nut megs, there seems to me to be absolutely zero end product.

Grady actually tried to beat a man and looks interested that useless lump doesn't offer anything .

By game 50+ of tried but achieves nothing!! I find this even more infuriating.
Reply
#60
So after sIX!!!! pages what is the consensus? Is Karlan Grant shit? I think he most probably is.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: