Posts: 1,764
Threads: 45
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation:
3
Palmer - 4 Not convicted he’s the answer
Townsend - 2 gash Play Ashworth on Tuesday
Pieters - 3 No Thank you bye bye
O'Shea - 3 Going backwards quickly needs to shape up
Furlong - 0 He’s up there with the worst players we have ever had and I’ve been watching since 72
Livermore - 1 Times up
TGH - 5 Best of a bad bunch
Phillips - 4 Squad player at best should not start
Grady - 3 needs proper coaching
Wallace - 3 A bad game today played out of position managers fault
Grant - 0 Halesowen awaits
Molumby - 5 At least he can run
Swift - 3 There is a player in there needs a run now to show it
Reach - 3 Another to move on
BTA - 3 Good energy but not good enough for this level
Carlos- 3 Team selection wrong if he has watched us and I doubt he has that’s got to be a big wake up call
Must realise that a lot of the above players have seen off other coaches/ managers
Need a big wake up on Tuesday or he won’t be here long either.
Posts: 295
Threads: 73
Joined: Jun 2022
The only ratings that matter;
Palmer 4
Furlong 4
O’Shea 3
Pieters 3
Townsend 2
Phillips 2
Livermore 2
TGH 4
Wallace 4
Grady 5
Grant 1
Subs;
Swift 6
BTA 6
Reach 5
Molumby 6
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Palmer 6 No fault for either goal, no mistakes
Furlong 0 Lazy, scared and ineffective. When I saw the replay of the goal it made me sick
OShea 2 Useless without someone better alongside
Pieters 2 No leadership despite his years
Townsend 0 Nothing to redeem him
Phillips 4 Best game for ages but still can't beat the first man 9 times out of 10
TGH 6 Quiet 1st half but showed a range of passing 2nd that we haven't seen in years
Livermore 2 Offered nothing either defensively or offensively
Wallace 3 Anonymous bar a couple of flashes but his confidence wanes with every game
Grady 4 Looks good at times but no end product
Grant 0 Hides in plain sight always makes sure he's wrong side then pretends to look like hes trying to win the ball / find space.
Molumby 6 Energy and endeavour but most importantly, looked like he cared
BTA 5 Too raw to be 1st choice but needs to be
Reach 3 One footed and one dimensional. Offers nothing
Swift 4 So frustrating. Clearly has talent but lacks bottle.
Corberan 3 Shot himself in the foot by stating hed watched all our games, then picked a side that no fan would have picked. Every old codger available got on the pitch. Poor start.
Phillips really wasn't that bad. He wasn't good either but I think people have made their mind up and can't see any good in him.
Posts: 741
Threads: 1
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
2
Need to give Carlos a few weeks before we pass too much judgement, but it was a display that we've seen quite a lot in recent weeks.
Offer nothing in attack and look like we're going to concede every time the opposition attack us. Really worrying times, as our confidence is shot to pieces, and there's no leadership in the squad. I can't believe how bad we've become.
Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Overall awful. Some of the defensive play especially the goals were shocking. I actually thought Livermore and Philips were our best players though appreciate many have lost patience with them. TGH did OK bar one shocking pass away that could gave led to a goal. Mulumby improved things.
How many corners and crosses to no one?
Carlos has a lot to do.
One thing that stuck in my mind was the kick off. The Sheff Utd players were positioned like they were about to run a 100m, ours relaxed.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
The fucking testimonial last month was played at greater intensity.
Posts: 932
Threads: 58
Joined: Mar 2020
Reputation:
9
Palmer - 4 - Marginally better than Button but could’ve done better
Townsend - 0 - Shite. Their first goal was his third cock up of the match and it was only 11 minutes in.
Pieters - 3 - looks like an elderly full back trying to have a go at centre half, because that’s what he is.
O'Shea - 2 - Awful. Think he’s going to be a league 1 player, sadly with us
Furlong - 0 - Main contribution was aimlessly lobbing throw ins at Sheffield United players. Actually turned his back on their bloke for the second in a show of cowardice that should’ve seen him hooked immediately
Livermore - 0 - Just keep paying him but fuck him off immediately. Shit.
TGH - 5 - at least gives a toss.
Phillips - 3 - Embarrassing for all concerned
Grady - 4 - no end product.
Wallace - 4 - Dragged down to the level of the dross around him
Grant - 0 - The bloke is a coward and a disgrace. An insult to the shirt.
Molumby - 5 - At least tried
Swift - 4 - See Molumby
Reach - 4 - Should probably replace Townsend on Tuesday, that’s how bad this squad is.
BTA - 4 - Run about a bit. Better than Grant by the fact he actually moved.
Carlos- At least we didn’t jam a result and he’s got to see the shit he’s inherited.