The who do you want as boss thread?
(10-12-2022, 02:37 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve mentioned Russell Martin before and I give full credit to Swansea that they are not diverting from there principles.They have had Graham Potter and Steve Cooper before Russell Martin ,so they have stuck to the same principles which helps all the players and there doesn’t have to be a big upheaval of players and transfers.The budget is tight at Swansea but at least there is a long term plan.

Have you seen the football Cooper plays? It’s miles from Martin and Potter. The reason Swansea fans wanted him out was that he won games instead of playing pretty sideways passes. 

I do respect that Swansea make a lot of very sensible decisions given their financial situation.
Reply
(10-12-2022, 02:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 02:37 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve mentioned Russell Martin before and I give full credit to Swansea that they are not diverting from there principles.They have had Graham Potter and Steve Cooper before Russell Martin ,so they have stuck to the same principles which helps all the players and there doesn’t have to be a big upheaval of players and transfers.The budget is tight at Swansea but at least there is a long term plan.

Have you seen the football Cooper plays? It’s miles from Martin and Potter. The reason Swansea fans wanted him out was that he won games instead of playing pretty sideways passes. 

I do respect that Swansea make a lot of very sensible decisions given their financial situation.

There's a few on here like that.
Reply
Dyche now evens! Stop lumping ypou fools! Big Grin
Reply
(10-12-2022, 02:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 12:26 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 11:44 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:55 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: The Athletic are reporting that Russell Martin has been added to the shortlist, another manager that's outfoxed Steve.
Question is, are we goona be prepared to pay compo?

I like what Russell Martin did at MKDons and at Swansea but we are not the fan base to give him the time he needs. I’m also not looking forward to seeing the likes of O’Shea and Bartley passing out from the back time and time again.  He’s also still a little “performances over results” hoping that one will naturally lead to the other whereas sometimes you need to mix it up a tad.

Rowett the antithesis of Martin… it’s good we are at least considering multiple options and approaches but I imagine this is more a scattergun approach to recruitment rather than considered analysis of all candidates to find the best fit. Whilst Rowett is a very uninspiring appointment - and his football worse than Val’s - he does know how to not lose games at this level, and with the quality we have, I think I’d be confident he could turn the 1-1s into 2-1s and 1-0s. It would be binary Pulisball at its worst again mind.
Agree re Martin - the football doesn't seem to gain the results it merits. However, that's a bit harsh on Rowatt. It's certainly more pragmatic football but it's nowhere near as bad as your hero Ismael.

Sorry but that’s just not the case. What’s being forgotten is how many chances we created under Val and how much time we spent in the opposition’s half.

Rowett is cut from the same cloth as Pulis. Keep it tight, spoil the game against better sides, get big blokes in the box and swing the ball in and take no risks. 

My concern is he did the same job/approach with Derby, Millwall and Stoke with very different budgets and I worry he’s the kind of manager that will take 2 1-1s instead of a 1-0 and a 0-1.
Oh yes lots of time in the opposition half rushing around, miscontrolling it, huffing and puffing and hoofing it into the box with the odd half chance on the end of it. Great watch wasn't it? Give me a Pulis type with a plan that works and gets results over that garbage any day. Better still, give me a manager like Roy or Clarke who can produce decent enough football AND keep things tight.
Reply
(10-12-2022, 04:13 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 02:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 12:26 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 11:44 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:55 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: The Athletic are reporting that Russell Martin has been added to the shortlist, another manager that's outfoxed Steve.
Question is, are we goona be prepared to pay compo?

I like what Russell Martin did at MKDons and at Swansea but we are not the fan base to give him the time he needs. I’m also not looking forward to seeing the likes of O’Shea and Bartley passing out from the back time and time again.  He’s also still a little “performances over results” hoping that one will naturally lead to the other whereas sometimes you need to mix it up a tad.

Rowett the antithesis of Martin… it’s good we are at least considering multiple options and approaches but I imagine this is more a scattergun approach to recruitment rather than considered analysis of all candidates to find the best fit. Whilst Rowett is a very uninspiring appointment - and his football worse than Val’s - he does know how to not lose games at this level, and with the quality we have, I think I’d be confident he could turn the 1-1s into 2-1s and 1-0s. It would be binary Pulisball at its worst again mind.
Agree re Martin - the football doesn't seem to gain the results it merits. However, that's a bit harsh on Rowatt. It's certainly more pragmatic football but it's nowhere near as bad as your hero Ismael.

Sorry but that’s just not the case. What’s being forgotten is how many chances we created under Val and how much time we spent in the opposition’s half.

Rowett is cut from the same cloth as Pulis. Keep it tight, spoil the game against better sides, get big blokes in the box and swing the ball in and take no risks. 

My concern is he did the same job/approach with Derby, Millwall and Stoke with very different budgets and I worry he’s the kind of manager that will take 2 1-1s instead of a 1-0 and a 0-1.
Oh yes lots of time in the opposition half rushing around, miscontrolling it, huffing and puffing and hoofing it into the box with the odd half chance on the end of it. Great watch wasn't it? Give me a Pulis type with a plan that works and gets results over that garbage any day. Better still, give me a manager like Roy or Clarke who can produce decent enough football AND keep things tight.

If you’d rather watch Pulis over Val there’s clearly no point debating with you Smile 

Roy’s football at home was worse than Val’s to watch, just the expectation was lower.

Give Val a better striker than Hugill and we wouldn’t even be having this debate. 

Clarke was fantastic until the wheels came off!
Reply
(10-12-2022, 04:15 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 04:13 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Oh yes lots of time in the opposition half rushing around, miscontrolling it, huffing and puffing and hoofing it into the box with the odd half chance on the end of it. Great watch wasn't it? Give me a Pulis type with a plan that works and gets results over that garbage any day. Better still, give me a manager like Roy or Clarke who can produce decent enough football AND keep things tight.

If you’d rather watch Pulis over Val there’s clearly no point debating with you Smile

I have to say that Pulis is the manager I hate most of all, even more so than Warnock!

Pulis's approach to football just made me want to stick pins in my eyes. I'm sure almost all of us hated watching his teams play against us, so having him at The Hawthorns just meant we had to suffer it constantly. I don't care where we finished during the seasons he was here, the way he set up to play was anathema to how I think football should be played and I simply can't forgive it. Sadly I've not been able to forget it so far either! Big Grin
Reply
(10-12-2022, 04:51 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 04:15 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 04:13 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Oh yes lots of time in the opposition half rushing around, miscontrolling it, huffing and puffing and hoofing it into the box with the odd half chance on the end of it. Great watch wasn't it? Give me a Pulis type with a plan that works and gets results over that garbage any day. Better still, give me a manager like Roy or Clarke who can produce decent enough football AND keep things tight.

If you’d rather watch Pulis over Val there’s clearly no point debating with you Smile

I have to say that Pulis is the manager I hate most of all, even more so than Warnock!

Pulis's approach to football just made me want to stick pins in my eyes. I'm sure almost all of us hated watching his teams play against us, so having him at The Hawthorns just meant we had to suffer it constantly. I don't care where we finished during the seasons he was here, the way he set up to play was anathema to how I think football should be played and I simply can't forgive it. Sadly I've not been able to forget it so far either! Big Grin

My thoughts on Valball exactly.
Reply
WorcsWBA Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:
Stillclem4england Wrote:Oh yes lots of time in the opposition half rushing around, miscontrolling it, huffing and puffing and hoofing it into the box with the odd half chance on the end of it. Great watch wasn't it? Give me a Pulis type with a plan that works and gets results over that garbage any day. Better still, give me a manager like Roy or Clarke who can produce decent enough football AND keep things tight.

If you’d rather watch Pulis over Val there’s clearly no point debating with you Smile

I have to say that Pulis is the manager I hate most of all, even more so than Warnock!

Pulis's approach to football just made me want to stick pins in my eyes. I'm sure almost all of us hated watching his teams play against us, so having him at The Hawthorns just meant we had to suffer it constantly. I don't care where we finished during the seasons he was here, the way he set up to play was anathema to how I think football should be played and I simply can't forgive it. Sadly I've not been able to forget it so far either! Big Grin

Just to add to the Pulis slagging. The dwindling fans, even those with season tickets (I know of a good many that simply never came back). The embarrassing no. of away fans we started taking. The televised games when the entire panel looked like they were at JLR on the Monday morning shift. The media love in. The phoney "never been relegated" tag. The temptation to stay in the pub at 2 on matchday. The regret of not staying in the pub on matchday.
Oh, and the joy when seeing the team at Man City had 5 centre backs picked, and then conceded a penalty and went down to 10 men in 3 minutes.
Reply
you can cross Nuno off the list - on his way back to the Custard Bowl apparently
Reply
(10-14-2022, 11:23 AM)Offside Wrote: you can cross Nuno off the list - on his way back to the Custard Bowl apparently

Wow pride can be purchased now
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)