A different view on Bruce... [this thread contains xG and stats]
#11
Great post SW4, but, and no disrespect intended, if you can establish this, then so should the club. So, why the fuck did we:

Let Kipre and Taylor go?
Let Robinson go?
Not attempt to bring in a genuine goalscorer?

Not doing all of the above, may well have altered some of those stats, luck or no luck, and Bruce has to be, at least partly, culpable for that.
Reply
#12
We let Robinson go because he is a gutless wanker - in my opinion of course.
Reply
#13
Well done SW4. Genuinely excellent research and giving us some food for thought. I have thought we've been unlucky so far this season.

As to where we are now, maybe our luck will change and like you I'd persevere to see if it does as the chopping and changing of managers is so painful.

New guys plus Dike might change things. I'm twitchy, but not as impatient as most.
Reply
#14
Good work SW4.

The danger is, as we've seen last season, if you don't get the results your play probably deserves then confidence/belief in the manager goes and you end up with performances like we saw at the end of the Val reign.
Reply
#15
(09-22-2022, 11:50 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Great post SW4, but, and no disrespect intended, if you can establish this, then so should the club. So, why the fuck did we:

Let Kipre and Taylor go?
Let Robinson go?
Not attempt to bring in a genuine goalscorer?

Not doing all of the above, may well have altered some of those stats, luck or no luck, and Bruce has to be, at least partly, culpable for that.

No offense taken Bob - I've not done anything complex here, just the type of analysis any half decent Football department ought to have a work experience kid doing - it took about an hour last night.

Data shouldn't be making decisions for us, but ought to be giving context and informing those in positions making decisions to try and ensure they make the right choices more often than not. My concern is that there is nobody in our club giving the likes of Big Ron any context and we are running on the substantial guts of those guys at the top.

For me the data suggested that Val needed a strong backing from the club - the players needed reassurance this was where we were going and that with the right additions the system would work.

We should have used similar analysis to show where we needed to focus our priority this summer - a bloody striker.

I can forgive letting Taylor and Kipre go out on loan, but to then bring in Pieters and Kelly a couple months later is insanity.
Reply
#16
(09-22-2022, 12:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-22-2022, 11:50 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Great post SW4, but, and no disrespect intended, if you can establish this, then so should the club. So, why the fuck did we:

Let Kipre and Taylor go?
Let Robinson go?
Not attempt to bring in a genuine goalscorer?

Not doing all of the above, may well have altered some of those stats, luck or no luck, and Bruce has to be, at least partly, culpable for that.

No offense taken Bob - I've not done anything complex here, just the type of analysis any half decent Football department ought to have a work experience kid doing - it took about an hour last night.

Data shouldn't be making decisions for us, but ought to be giving context and informing those in positions making decisions to try and ensure they make the right choices more often than not. My concern is that there is nobody in our club giving the likes of Big Ron any context and we are running on the substantial guts of those guys at the top.

For me the data suggested that Val needed a strong backing from the club - the players needed reassurance this was where we were going and that with the right additions the system would work.

We should have used similar analysis to show where we needed to focus our priority this summer - a bloody striker.

I can forgive letting Taylor and Kipre go out on loan, but to then bring in Pieters and Kelly a couple months later is insanity.

[Image: images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSVrKbWCqWHD5S8IYTtgSZ...w&usqp=CAU]
Reply
#17
I really appreciate the stats and the work it has taken to generate them.

But I think it masks what is happening on the pitch. I will leave the Val times, but in the Bruce era, too often I have seen a disorganised, clueless team. The XG stats mask that we have needing to be more attacking in most of our matches because we have consistently been a goal down very early on.

All this handwringing about luck. Good teams win. With the exception of one match, we haven't.

For all the talk about attitude and pea hearts, the team can still put in performances, so (Bartley aside), I don't think that is the issue. Having no gameplan, beyond "Go out and enjoy yourself" is.
Reply
#18
(09-22-2022, 01:19 PM)Squid Wrote: I really appreciate the stats and the work it has taken to generate them.

But I think it masks what is happening on the pitch. I will leave the Val times, but in the Bruce era, too often I have seen a disorganised, clueless team. The XG stats mask that we have needing to be more attacking in most of our matches because we have consistently been a goal down very early on.

All this handwringing about luck. Good teams win. With the exception of one match, we haven't.

For all the talk about attitude and pea hearts, the team can still put in performances, so (Bartley aside), I don't think that is the issue. Having no gameplan, beyond "Go out and enjoy yourself" is.

I would surmise that we have xG  in spite of Bruce - not because of Bruce.
Reply
#19
(09-22-2022, 01:19 PM)Squid Wrote: I really appreciate the stats and the work it has taken to generate them.

But I think it masks what is happening on the pitch. I will leave the Val times, but in the Bruce era, too often I have seen a disorganised, clueless team. The XG stats mask that we have needing to be more attacking in most of our matches because we have consistently been a goal down very early on.

All this handwringing about luck. Good teams win. With the exception of one match, we haven't.

For all the talk about attitude and pea hearts, the team can still put in performances, so (Bartley aside), I don't think that is the issue. Having no gameplan, beyond "Go out and enjoy yourself" is.

+1
Reply
#20
There’s a strong correlation between xg and number of shots (you don’t shoot, your xg stays the same) and also a correlation between having more shots and chasing a game.

We’ve been chasing most games, which has resulted in more shots. It’s not the only factor. But it’s definitely an element. We have attacked more than we did under Bruce last season but I would imagine our xg per minute increases massively once we go behind.

If you go behind week in week out, that’s not unlucky, that’s a coaching and tactical issue
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: