Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(09-18-2022, 10:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
It’s always the same story under Bruce. We raise our game against the stronger teams in the league and struggle against the ones we should be beating. We played well yesterday, as we did against all the newly relegated teams, the way we did against Fulham last year. That’s fine for a coach trying to keep a team in the league, its not fine when you’re aiming for promotion.
I’m not saying it is but arguments weaken when fans suggest we played badly / defensively when it’s clearly not true. It just makes their argument look like an agenda. There is ample to criticise the manager and club for without the need to embellish the arguments.
We put in a well drilled disciplined performance yesterday massively helped by an early goal and a rigid 4-5-1 out of possession.
We had our moments and with a little more composure we could have won 2 if not 3 -1. My stream froze as Grady was about to pass to the overlapping Swift and I felt sure once refreshed I would see the ball in the back of the net, sadly not.
Now I have no problem with the change in formation yesterday but it wasn't our normal modus operandi. Bruce knew he had to get a result after the Blues debacle and we didn't allow Norwich to play which is often what happens at our place.
Much as I think he's clueless, if Gourmet wants him to complete a rebuild and the consequences of that are another season in the Championship then that's his and the owner's prerogative. But if we lose say against Swansea then the place will erupt and it will eventually become impossible for Bruce to continue as the cabbages rain down.
There has to be massive improvement in results the next 10 games. 5/6 wins, 3/4 draws. Unbeaten if we can, so going into the break we are in touch with the POs.
The other side of the WC it should be a different story with hopefully a fully fit Ajayi, Dike and Bryan and Rogic, Kelly and Pieters full bedded in. Plus a couple of quality loans or signings with the £5m loan repayment.
Any kind of run in this division is going to quickly move us near to the play-offs. I do believe our quality we come through as the season wears on.
Back to back wins would completely change our season.
Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(09-18-2022, 10:44 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (09-18-2022, 10:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
It’s always the same story under Bruce. We raise our game against the stronger teams in the league and struggle against the ones we should be beating. We played well yesterday, as we did against all the newly relegated teams, the way we did against Fulham last year. That’s fine for a coach trying to keep a team in the league, its not fine when you’re aiming for promotion.
I’m not saying it is but arguments weaken when fans suggest we played badly / defensively when it’s clearly not true. It just makes their argument look like an agenda. There is ample to criticise the manager and club for without the need to embellish the arguments.
We put in a well drilled disciplined performance yesterday massively helped by an early goal and a rigid 4-5-1 out of possession.
We had our moments and with a little more composure we could have won 2 if not 3 -1. My stream froze as Grady was about to pass to the overlapping Swift and I felt sure once refreshed I would see the ball in the back of the net, sadly not.
Now I have no problem with the change in formation yesterday but it wasn't our normal modus operandi. Bruce knew he had to get a result after the Blues debacle and we didn't allow Norwich to play which is often what happens at our place.
Much as I think he's clueless, if Gourmet wants him to complete a rebuild and the consequences of that are another season in the Championship then that's his and the owner's prerogative. But if we lose say against Swansea then the place will erupt and it will eventually become impossible for Bruce to continue as the cabbages rain down.
There has to be massive improvement in results the next 10 games. 5/6 wins, 3/4 draws. Unbeaten if we can, so going into the break we are in touch with the POs.
The other side of the WC it should be a different story with hopefully a fully fit Ajayi, Dike and Bryan and Rogic, Kelly and Pieters full bedded in. Plus a couple of quality loans or signings with the £5m loan repayment.
Any kind of run in this division is going to quickly move us near to the play-offs. I do believe our quality we come through as the season wears on.
Back to back wins would completely change our season.
That’s cute.
Posts: 4,732
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
(09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
Agree.
Our gameplan was spot on yesterday and deserved the three points. Hard to criticise Bruce for a poor referee decision costing us the game but some will find a way!
Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(09-18-2022, 11:04 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
Agree.
Our gameplan was spot on yesterday and deserved the three points. Hard to criticise Bruce for a poor referee decision costing us the game but some will find a way!
I didn’t see yesterday’s game which is why I’ve held off criticising yesterday’s performance. It’s not about just yesterday though is it? This is about Bruce’s reign as a whole, last season was abject. This season we have ten points from ten games and are fourth bottom. That’s not good enough, and it isn’t an agenda it’s a simple fact.
There have been too many incidences like yesterday where we put in an encouraging performance (and fail to win) only to revert to type the following week.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-18-2022, 11:15 AM)Duffers Wrote: (09-18-2022, 11:04 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
Agree.
Our gameplan was spot on yesterday and deserved the three points. Hard to criticise Bruce for a poor referee decision costing us the game but some will find a way!
I didn’t see yesterday’s game which is why I’ve held off criticising yesterday’s performance. It’s not about just yesterday though is it? This is about Bruce’s reign as a whole, last season was abject. This season we have ten points from ten games and are fourth bottom. That’s not good enough, and it isn’t an agenda it’s a simple fact.
There have been too many incidences like yesterday where we put in an encouraging performance (and fail to win) only to revert to type the following week.
I think my argument was pretty clear, there is plenty to criticise the club, Bruce for but those who are arguing we played poorly or defensively / negatively yesterday weaken their own argument when it bears little resemblance to what happened. Then it becomes an agenda rather than justified criticism.
Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(09-18-2022, 11:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-18-2022, 11:15 AM)Duffers Wrote: (09-18-2022, 11:04 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who argues we didn’t play well yesterday is clearly biased and only seeing what they want to see. I’m staying short of saying agenda but it is really, even if they believe it is best for the club.
Agree.
Our gameplan was spot on yesterday and deserved the three points. Hard to criticise Bruce for a poor referee decision costing us the game but some will find a way!
I didn’t see yesterday’s game which is why I’ve held off criticising yesterday’s performance. It’s not about just yesterday though is it? This is about Bruce’s reign as a whole, last season was abject. This season we have ten points from ten games and are fourth bottom. That’s not good enough, and it isn’t an agenda it’s a simple fact.
There have been too many incidences like yesterday where we put in an encouraging performance (and fail to win) only to revert to type the following week.
I think my argument was pretty clear, there is plenty to criticise the club, Bruce for but those who are arguing we played poorly or defensively / negatively yesterday weaken their own argument when it bears little resemblance to what happened. Then it becomes an agenda rather than justified criticism.
And what’s the argument when you look at the league table?
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I’ve maybe seen one person saying we didn’t play well yesterday. Pretty much everyone is saying that we played well but it’s about where we are after ten games, which is level on points with the relegation zone with teams below us having games in hand.
I saw far more posts after we’ve been crap trying to claim that we were actually decent and just unlucky.
Posts: 612
Threads: 29
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Our weakness is our inability to beat the weaker teams. If we did, yesterday would be a good result,
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
I'm still backing Bruce. I've enjoyed most games I've seen. Admittedly some have been disappointing but it's not too hard to see the problems IMO.
We've had the most shots in this league, and 3rd most on target but terrible at converting those chances. We need a striker. Grant ain't a CF and BTA won't fill the role IMO. I'm a bit dismayed we didn't get a free agent but I'd like to think that maybe Dike is close to returning. He has the physicality we need.
Defensively, we're one of the meanest in terms of shots against but we have the GK with lowest save ratio. I hope Bruce doesn't stay too loyal to him. There's no reason to think he will tbf - after all, he has dropped Livermore, Yokoslu and Grant.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(09-18-2022, 10:41 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (09-18-2022, 09:58 AM)HLS Wrote: To be promoted, you need to either be scoring a hatful of goals relatively regularly (Mowbray/DiM/Fulham) or have a commanding defense (Pulis/Meggo). We have neither under Bruce and we look no closer to doing either than we did at the start of the season.
I've enjoyed the games this season but there's something missing at both ends of the pitch that Bruce cannot seem to rectify and that means we are not winning games.
That would in the main be a decent keeper to save shots AND organise the defence, along with a decent centre forward. I’m damn sure Bruce would have liked another forward, regardless of his media comments, the reality is that the budget didn’t and doesn’t allow that and to strengthen elsewhere so he’s gambled on which bit to try and sort first.
Maybe the couple of windows comment is true, a couple of changes in January and then next summer, bye-bye Bartley, Livermore and Zohore and hello to Griffiths in goal, Taylor at CB and some ability to wheel and deal again. I’ll repeat myself and say the better players in the squad have all been brought in by Bruce, in one window. Maybe he should take a DoF role and let someone else do the coaching (not his son ffs)?
I started this thread just as an alternate way of saying it’s not all Bruce’s fault and yet he’s going to carry the can which could just see us start all over again on the recruitment side and round we go.
Just maybe another month of stick is better than twist at this point. I’m on the “haven’t got what we deserved” side of the argument and would like to see if this can change with the players we brought in and maybe Dike for a few weeks.
We’d have sacked Johnny Giles if social media existed.
Pretty much these two posts. It was always unlikely we'd be able to address every issue from last season. If we're not spending money on transfer fees then we are going with whoever is available on a free and that has allowed us to bring in some much needed craft in the midfield. However, it hasn't allowed us to bring in assured goalscorers or defenders who haven't got a rick in them every game (Pieters and Kelly might help with the latter short term). I agree that signing Button was a bit of an odd move (being kind) and not something I would have done, other than having him as back-up to Palmer (to start with).
I can't see us doing much in January other than a loan or two. There won't be any long-term signings so the next rebuild stage will be in the Summer. And that might not address everything that needs addressing at that time. But with contracts being up, it gives us a bit more leeway to spend (assuming we're allowed to spend).
It will also see Bruce's contract up, at which point the next big thing managerial-wise may be available and eager to sign!
As an aside, I never see the point in people saying they are giving a manager the next game or two games or whatever before deciding if they should be sacked. If they win those games but lose the next ten then your issue with the manager hasn't been resolved. If you have reached the stage where you are giving the manager "the next game" then really you have already made up your mind that they should be gone.
|