In defence of Bruce…
#11
Last season his frequent comment after games was ‘ this club won’t accept mid table ‘ he doesn’t seem to say it so much now does he ? He’s actually said tonight ‘we might have to face going into the international break in the bottom 3 which is bonkers ‘ . It’s not bonkers the league table doesn’t lie . Goodbye Steve .
Reply
#12
(09-17-2022, 06:30 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(09-17-2022, 06:27 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-17-2022, 06:25 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Great post. I think giving him until the World Cup break would be sensible and then have a look at where we are.

We just need a bit of consistency in these performances. It's no good playing well one game and then playing poor in the next. Bruce needs to be capable of getting us on a winning run if we have any ambition to be near the top 6.

Hi Ron.
Can you sack Bruce please you fat headed prick Big Grin

Yes, i'm on the phone to Lee Bowyer right now.

Perfect. He usually has a decent upturn in results when he arrives.
Reply
#13
I’m not sure SB is going anywhere yet - given Fat Ron and as the deadline day signings (limited that they are) have had so little game time

But FWIW, on oddschecker he is the 2nd fave manager to go (after the Hull manager)
Reply
#14
(09-17-2022, 06:52 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: I’m not sure SB is going anywhere yet - given Fat Ron and as the deadline day signings (limited that they are) have had so little game time

But FWIW, on oddschecker he is the 2nd fave manager to go (after the Hull manager)

They both need ditching.
Reply
#15
Posts like this are good as they offer a different perspective well argued.
I always said 12 games, but really don’t think unless we get 4 points or 6 I’d keep him now.
If I was making decisions the next game would be d day- win or P45.
Reply
#16
(09-17-2022, 06:36 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: Last season his frequent comment after games was ‘ this club won’t accept mid table ‘ he doesn’t seem to say it so much now does he ? He’s actually said tonight ‘we might have to face going into the international break in the bottom 3 which is bonkers ‘ . It’s not bonkers the league table doesn’t lie . Goodbye Steve .

I genuinely looked at the table for the first time this season and whilst we are in the bottom six, we are only 5 points from the top 6.

To say that for the next 10 games the table will be very fluid is an understatement.

I'm minded to stick with Bruce.

Blues game excepted I have been impressed with the performances I have watched, an improvement on last season. 
Would like to see what he will do with the squad once all the incoming pkayers are up to speed and available for selection, plus a fit again Dike (assuming his return to fitness is keeping to the original timetable )

From my point of view we are close to a side that can consistently get good results at this level.
Obviously we need more clean sheets, hoping the arrival of Pieters and Kelly will help in this regard.
Need to have more composure in the final attacking third.
Would be good to get a bit of luck.

Review progress made at Workd Cup break.
Reply
#17
(09-17-2022, 06:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m sure I’m now in a minority and I’m beginning to question how much he should get too.

However a few things need to be considered, which does include ‘who else then’.

1) i don’t blame him for last season.  Yes he failed to hit the remit but we we’re sixth and teams had games in hand to drop us to 8th.  Val’s style had stopped working after 10 games, Bruce tried to change it and found the players wanting.  There was a lack of forwards and zero midfield creativity, as soon as he started to try and make us more expansive we shipped goals.  The squad was totally unbalanced and had no focal point to play off.

2) The finances.  I’m sure what he’s said in the press and how he really feels are 2 different things.  It’s rare to find a manager who doesn’t want that extra player.  We clearly had to cut the wage bill and you can only shift players that other clubs want.  I’m sure Martin Kelly wasn’t the first player he thought of ffs.

3) Resources.  I keep hearing our wage bill is so much higher we should be doing better.  Bartley, Livermore, Phillips and Zohore must be taking £6m a year from our budget and offering fuck all.  Furlong a fair chunk alongside Grant.  

4) The squad.  How many would get in a top of the table squad, or the newly relegated teams?
Our keeper is mist, the ball goes through him.
We don’t have a defender, maybe O’Shea, worthy of a top 6 starting XI.
Molumby is at best a bang average Champ midfielder, Livermore is shot.
The only quality we have is Okay, Swift, Wallace, Diangana and we don’t know about Dike.  Grant is a decent Champo player but having to play out of position. 
Basically the best players we have Bruce has brought in, maybe he should get January to add to that?

5) Luck.  Has been in short supply, what bit there has been is all bad.

One win in 10 isn’t good enough, but all bar 2-3 games we’ve deserved more, which shows the performances are there just, to me, that lack of quality.  Dike may make a huge difference, he should be able to hold the ball up and be a focal point for the quality we do have to play off him.

We haven’t kept anyone long enough to form a balanced squad for a few years now which is why we’ve ended up with this potpourri overpaid shit bunch.  They’re difficult to motivate because they know it’s down hill from here, nothing left to achieve, they need weeding out and replacing.  Bruce is at least getting that bit done.

For me I’d give him the opportunity to get Rogic fit, get Pieters and Kelly involved and hopefully Dike and let’s see where we are at the World Cup break.

Have some ambition while you have the squad you have
Reply
#18
(09-17-2022, 06:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m sure I’m now in a minority and I’m beginning to question how much he should get too.

However a few things need to be considered, which does include ‘who else then’.

1) i don’t blame him for last season.  Yes he failed to hit the remit but we we’re sixth and teams had games in hand to drop us to 8th.  Val’s style had stopped working after 10 games, Bruce tried to change it and found the players wanting.  There was a lack of forwards and zero midfield creativity, as soon as he started to try and make us more expansive we shipped goals.  The squad was totally unbalanced and had no focal point to play off.

2) The finances.  I’m sure what he’s said in the press and how he really feels are 2 different things.  It’s rare to find a manager who doesn’t want that extra player.  We clearly had to cut the wage bill and you can only shift players that other clubs want.  I’m sure Martin Kelly wasn’t the first player he thought of ffs.

3) Resources.  I keep hearing our wage bill is so much higher we should be doing better.  Bartley, Livermore, Phillips and Zohore must be taking £6m a year from our budget and offering fuck all.  Furlong a fair chunk alongside Grant.  

4) The squad.  How many would get in a top of the table squad, or the newly relegated teams?
Our keeper is mist, the ball goes through him.
We don’t have a defender, maybe O’Shea, worthy of a top 6 starting XI.
Molumby is at best a bang average Champ midfielder, Livermore is shot.
The only quality we have is Okay, Swift, Wallace, Diangana and we don’t know about Dike.  Grant is a decent Champo player but having to play out of position. 
Basically the best players we have Bruce has brought in, maybe he should get January to add to that?

5) Luck.  Has been in short supply, what bit there has been is all bad.

One win in 10 isn’t good enough, but all bar 2-3 games we’ve deserved more, which shows the performances are there just, to me, that lack of quality.  Dike may make a huge difference, he should be able to hold the ball up and be a focal point for the quality we do have to play off him.

We haven’t kept anyone long enough to form a balanced squad for a few years now which is why we’ve ended up with this potpourri overpaid shit bunch.  They’re difficult to motivate because they know it’s down hill from here, nothing left to achieve, they need weeding out and replacing.  Bruce is at least getting that bit done.

For me I’d give him the opportunity to get Rogic fit, get Pieters and Kelly involved and hopefully Dike and let’s see where we are at the World Cup break.
Really good post this and it certainly mirrors what most Albion fans I know think. And, incidentally, these are Albion fans who go rather than ones who watch streams when Besiktas aren't playing.

Has Bruce done a great job? Not really. Is he a great tactician? Not really. But he has one hand tied behind his back yet the football has been massively more enjoyable, we have brought some real quality in (particularly Wallace) and with a little bit more luck we'd be much higher up the table. I saw a post earlier about had Hull scored first we could be bottom. Well what about the pen we should have had against Huddersfield? The goal today should have been ruled out. On another day we'd have scored another v Boro, Burnley, Watford. We are where we are but Pieters has improved us for starters. I'd like to see Palmer come in and Kelly for Furlong and Rogic sounds exciting. Any team can beat anyone in this league and three wins on the spin would get us up the table.

(09-17-2022, 07:19 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-17-2022, 06:36 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: Last season his frequent comment after games was ‘ this club won’t accept mid table ‘ he doesn’t seem to say it so much now does he ? He’s actually said tonight ‘we might have to face going into the international break in the bottom 3 which is bonkers ‘ . It’s not bonkers the league table doesn’t lie . Goodbye Steve .

I genuinely looked at the table for the first time this season and whilst we are in the bottom six, we are only 5 points from the top 6.

To say that for the next 10 games the table will be very fluid is an understatement.

I'm minded to stick with Bruce.

Blues game excepted I have been impressed with the performances I have watched, an improvement on last season. 
Would like to see what he will do with the squad once all the incoming pkayers are up to speed and available for selection, plus a fit again Dike (assuming his return to fitness is keeping to the original timetable )

From my point of view we are close to a side that can consistently get good results at this level.
Obviously we need more clean sheets, hoping the arrival of Pieters and Kelly will help in this regard.
Need to have more composure in the final attacking third.
Would be good to get a bit of luck.

Review progress made at Workd Cup break.
Spot on Shabby. Thing I liked about today was that we looked more solid and compact with a bank of four and five.
Reply
#19
Would you honestly keep him tho Clem, based on results this season/last relative to resources?
Reply
#20
(09-17-2022, 06:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m sure I’m now in a minority and I’m beginning to question how much he should get too.

However a few things need to be considered, which does include ‘who else then’.

1)  The squad was totally unbalanced and had no focal point to play off. Agree so why didnt Bruce bring in a proper number 9 after getting in Wallace and Swift? 

2) The finances.   We clearly had to cut the wage bill and you can only shift players that other clubs want.  Other clubs recruited really well on tighter budgets. Estupinan was a free transfer for Hull and scored 15 goals last season in the Portuguese top flight. Our scouting is dreadful. 

3) Resources.  I keep hearing our wage bill is so much higher we should be doing better.  Bartley, Livermore, Phillips and Zohore must be taking £6m a year from our budget and offering fuck all.  Furlong a fair chunk alongside Grant.  Correct but all clubs have shite players draining their rescources and as a percentage of income I doubt we are much worse than anyone else. 

4) The squad.  How many would get in a top of the table squad, or the newly relegated teams?
Our keeper is mist, the ball goes through him. Bruce signed him when we could have looked elsewhere or heaven forbid used our 2 very good homegrown keepers and spent the money elsewhere. 
We don’t have a defender, maybe O’Shea, worthy of a top 6 starting XI.
Molumby is at best a bang average Champ midfielder, Livermore is shot.
The only quality we have is Okay, Swift, Wallace, Diangana and we don’t know about Dike.  Grant is a decent Champo player but having to play out of position. 
Basically the best players we have Bruce has brought in, maybe he should get January to add to that?

5) Luck.  Has been in short supply, what bit there has been is all bad. You make your own and it'll even itself out. I hate using luck as an excuse. 

 They’re difficult to motivate because they know it’s down hill from here, nothing left to achieve, they need weeding out and replacing.  Bruce is at least getting that bit done. Yet he's  just signed Pieters and Kelly who are both nearing mid 30's
.

My thoughts in bold.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: