WBA Employing mates and sons just isn't right.
#1
I can't believe I should have to say it, but letting the director give the manager's job to his mate - who then gives the top coach job to his son - isn't a professional way to run a top club.

In what other company of a similar stature would this be tolerated? Even if it's your own company, outside investors would frown at it.

It just stinks of amateurishness.

Even the "I watched thomas asante, whilst watching my son in law" makes me shudder. Is that really how we found about him? I'm pleased we've got him, but if that is how we do our scouting - how many more have we missed? What are our scouts doing? If they are doing something - are they been listened to as much as the manager's son in law? If they're not - how do they feel about that?

Many people have said how the club is rotten all through. If this is how we recruit key talent, I'm not surprised.

Not only that, how does it impact on everyone else? Surely, we should spend as much time and care as possible getting the best possible support staff and giving them a development path? How can we do that if we close down progression by letting someone walk straight in at a senior position because their dad got the top job or the director is a drinking pal? How about if all your scouting work was gazumped by the managers son in law?

I know I wouldn't work for a company like that. (Or maybe I would now, but then I'm at a time in my life where I'm not ambitious, or even that interested. I would, however,  happily just take the pay cheque - sound familiar?!) All the best talent will just leave. 

So if we can't develop our own talent - Where's the progression? Where's the nurturing? Where's the improvement? Crucially, where's the continuity - Is it right to rip everything up once the manager leaves?


If a new manager doesn't like/rate a coach that's fine, but at least go through the proper procedure, try and help them like any manager would in any industry - don't just bring in your mates or your son.

Otherwise, we're back to square one every six months - except bereft of any developing talent. This is exactly why clubs lurch from manager to manager.

We are still a top club in this country and we should be able to attract some of the best people with the most potential - but only if we start acting like it off the pitch.
Reply
#2
Can't disagree with anything there. Out of interest, where did the 'watching my son in law' comment come from?

My slim slither of hope is that Gourmet is busy building something that can take over this systemic shambles, and that's the reason why he's silent/not fired Bruce yet.
Reply
#3
(09-15-2022, 12:29 PM)SophLad Wrote: Can't disagree with anything there.  Out of interest, where did the 'watching my son in law' comment come from?

My slim slither of hope is that Gourmet is busy building something that can take over this systemic shambles, and that's the reason why he's silent/not fired Bruce yet.

An escape tunnel that pops up on Greggs car park?
Reply
#4
(09-15-2022, 12:29 PM)SophLad Wrote: Can't disagree with anything there.  Out of interest, where did the 'watching my son in law' comment come from?

My slim slither of hope is that Gourmet is busy building something that can take over this systemic shambles, and that's the reason why he's silent/not fired Bruce yet.


"The powerful 5ft 11ins (180cm) striker was actually recommended to Bruce by one of Thomas-Asante's team-mates at League Two side Salford, Bruce's son-in law, the former Oldham Athletic, Leeds United, Fulham, QPR and Millwall striker Matt Smith." 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/62795507

“He deserves his chance,” Bruce told The Athletic. “I’ve seen him quite a lot because my son-in-law (Matt Smith) plays for Salford. Every time I’ve gone, he’s caught my eye because he’s quick, powerful and got a bit of a trick. He’s a bit erratic at times and raw, but he’s got something about him.

I didn't know this one - this time concerning Jed wallace -

"Widely regarded as one of the best players in the Championship, former Wolves man Wallace is expected to leave Millwall as a free agent this summer.

Albion are in talks with 28-year-old to lure him to The Hawthorns.

And Millwall boss Gary Rowett wouldn’t be surprised if Smith, who played with Wallace at The Den, puts in a good word with his father-in-law.
“When Steve Bruce is Matt Smith’s father-in-law, I think you can definitely imagine that Smudge has told Steve just how good a character the player (Wallace) is,” Rowett said."
Reply
#5
It's all a bit Don's Cortina isn't it?
Reply
#6
So this is our Chief Scout?
[Image: 1_Matt-Smith-house-of-dragonjpg.jpg]
Reply
#7
(09-15-2022, 12:38 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 12:29 PM)SophLad Wrote: Can't disagree with anything there.  Out of interest, where did the 'watching my son in law' comment come from?

My slim slither of hope is that Gourmet is busy building something that can take over this systemic shambles, and that's the reason why he's silent/not fired Bruce yet.


"The powerful 5ft 11ins (180cm) striker was actually recommended to Bruce by one of Thomas-Asante's team-mates at League Two side Salford, Bruce's son-in law, the former Oldham Athletic, Leeds United, Fulham, QPR and Millwall striker Matt Smith." 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/62795507

“He deserves his chance,” Bruce told The Athletic. “I’ve seen him quite a lot because my son-in-law (Matt Smith) plays for Salford. Every time I’ve gone, he’s caught my eye because he’s quick, powerful and got a bit of a trick. He’s a bit erratic at times and raw, but he’s got something about him.

I didn't know this one - this time concerning Jed wallace -

"Widely regarded as one of the best players in the Championship, former Wolves man Wallace is expected to leave Millwall as a free agent this summer.

Albion are in talks with 28-year-old to lure him to The Hawthorns.

And Millwall boss Gary Rowett wouldn’t be surprised if Smith, who played with Wallace at The Den, puts in a good word with his father-in-law.
“When Steve Bruce is Matt Smith’s father-in-law, I think you can definitely imagine that Smudge has told Steve just how good a character the player (Wallace) is,” Rowett said."

West Brom sign out of contract Matt Smith in the summer?
Reply
#8
100% agree with this. I think its awful that bruce was "just" employed. we all know why he was employed, and it wasn't really down to his coaching merits, which have become very apparent. I'm sure him and Ron are out playing golf or something today. We've sunk to the bottom.
Reply
#9
(09-15-2022, 12:38 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 12:29 PM)SophLad Wrote: Can't disagree with anything there.  Out of interest, where did the 'watching my son in law' comment come from?

My slim slither of hope is that Gourmet is busy building something that can take over this systemic shambles, and that's the reason why he's silent/not fired Bruce yet.


"The powerful 5ft 11ins (180cm) striker was actually recommended to Bruce by one of Thomas-Asante's team-mates at League Two side Salford, Bruce's son-in law, the former Oldham Athletic, Leeds United, Fulham, QPR and Millwall striker Matt Smith." 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/62795507

“He deserves his chance,” Bruce told The Athletic. “I’ve seen him quite a lot because my son-in-law (Matt Smith) plays for Salford. Every time I’ve gone, he’s caught my eye because he’s quick, powerful and got a bit of a trick. He’s a bit erratic at times and raw, but he’s got something about him.

I didn't know this one - this time concerning Jed wallace -

"Widely regarded as one of the best players in the Championship, former Wolves man Wallace is expected to leave Millwall as a free agent this summer.

Albion are in talks with 28-year-old to lure him to The Hawthorns.

And Millwall boss Gary Rowett wouldn’t be surprised if Smith, who played with Wallace at The Den, puts in a good word with his father-in-law.
“When Steve Bruce is Matt Smith’s father-in-law, I think you can definitely imagine that Smudge has told Steve just how good a character the player (Wallace) is,” Rowett said."

I once rang Albion's Chief Scout recommending a player at Stafford Rangers, I can't remember if it was Devlin or Collymore I think the former.  He said they'd been watching him for years.   I think our scouting network would have known all about Asante and would have been monitoring him.  Bruce has simply commented that he'd personally seen him many times as he'd watched his son-in-law so I don't see a problem with that. 

And do you think we didn't know about Wallace? 

Nepotism is rife in every walk of life starting at the top and throughout the establishment, government and big business.  Hasn't Truss just given all her mates top jobs in the Cabinet!? 

Is Bruce a 'mate' of Gourmet's (in the sense you're implying) or did they just know each other from working at United?
Reply
#10
(09-15-2022, 12:56 PM)Hopalong Wrote: I once rang Albion's Chief Scout recommending a player at Stafford Rangers, I can't remember if it was Devlin or Collymore I think the former.  He said they'd been watching him for years.   I think our scouting network would have known all about Asante and would have been monitoring him.  Bruce has simply commented that he'd personally seen him many times as he'd watched his son-in-law so I don't see a problem with that. 

And do you think we didn't know about Wallace? 

Nepotism is rife in every walk of life starting at the top and throughout the establishment, government and big business.  Hasn't Truss just given all her mates top jobs in the Cabinet!? 

Is Bruce a 'mate' of Gourmet's (in the sense you're implying) or did they just know each other from working at United?

"Nepotism is rife in every walk of life starting at the top and throughout the establishment, government and big business.  Hasn't Truss just given all her mates top jobs in the Cabinet!?"

There's lots of things rife in every walk of life. That doesn't make it right. But in a major organisation - as we still are - for outside investors, employing your mates and friends will count very heavily against you. You can almost guarantee they'll want a NED representing them - that's if they don't walk away.

Truss gave the jobs to colleagues within her party - as she must, unlike west brom who have a whole industry to get the best possible talent! Even with the limits Truss has, she still didn't employ her son...

Bruce is a long time friend as both men have freely and quite rightly acknowledged. Bruce even gave it as a reason he took the job. 

Both Bruce's son in law and his son have also owned up to their relationship!

I'm sure we knew about both Wallace and Asante. But do you think it was a coincidence they were both friends of his son in law? Whichever way, it gives him a bitter hit rate than all our other employed scouts. Throw in Wallace being a longstanding friend of Swift and yokuslu being a 'friend' of the club, then at the very least, it portrays a very high reliance on an informal network that seems more reactive than planned. Surely that's not healthy in the long term?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: