Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad
#1
I think as someone who has supported the club 47 years I've seen a good few and being honest our recent 21st century history has given the best 3. Foster, Hoult and Johnstone in that order.

Guys like Godden, Osborne, Naylor and Kiely were all worthy custodians of the shirt.

However, we have had some gash too. Crichton was appalling and what was it with Zuberhowler and his pedigree?

Trying not to get too downbeat but we now have one of the most uninspiring keepers in many moons. Button just isn't going to make those once every couple of matches saves that wins you points. 

I think his inclusion is a major reason why we are shipping in soft goals. I maintain Sam Johnstone in normal form would have meant we'd be 3-4 points better off already.

We've overlooked this vital position criminally for this season and its neglect is a major reason we are in a pickle.
Reply
#2
(09-15-2022, 10:06 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think as someone who has supported the club 47 years I've seen a good few and being honest our recent 21st century history has given the best 3. Foster, Hoult and Johnstone in that order.

Guys like Godden, Osborne, Naylor and Kiely were all worthy custodians of the shirt.

However, we have had some gash too. Crichton was appalling and what was it with Zuberhowler and his pedigree?

Trying not to get too downbeat but we now have one of the most uninspiring keepers in many moons. Button just isn't going to make those once every couple of matches saves that wins you points. 

I think his inclusion is a major reason why we are shipping in soft goals. I maintain Sam Johnstone in normal form would have meant we'd be 3-4 points better off already.

We've overlooked this vital position criminally for this season and its neglect is the reason we are in a pickle.

I think it's only fair that Button is now given the next 9 games and see how he does. He's earned the right after 15 years with the club.
Reply
#3
(09-15-2022, 10:10 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 10:06 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think as someone who has supported the club 47 years I've seen a good few and being honest our recent 21st century history has given the best 3. Foster, Hoult and Johnstone in that order.

Guys like Godden, Osborne, Naylor and Kiely were all worthy custodians of the shirt.

However, we have had some gash too. Crichton was appalling and what was it with Zuberhowler and his pedigree?

Trying not to get too downbeat but we now have one of the most uninspiring keepers in many moons. Button just isn't going to make those once every couple of matches saves that wins you points. 

I think his inclusion is a major reason why we are shipping in soft goals. I maintain Sam Johnstone in normal form would have meant we'd be 3-4 points better off already.

We've overlooked this vital position criminally for this season and its neglect is the reason we are in a pickle.

I think it's only fair that Button is now given the next 9 games and see how he does. He's earned the right after 15 years with the club.

I guess you mean Palmer and I agree. Here's a list of our keepers. I'd forgotten Phil Whitehead. https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/west-bro...verein/984
Reply
#4
I wouldn't mention Johnstone in the same breath as Foster or Hoult. Warming the bench for an average Prem club, approaching the prime of his career.

Foster was the dogs. Over 200 top flight appearances, the best keeper I've ever seen in a similar timescale to SB. Hoult was what we need now. The marshal of a tight defence, keeping a record number of clean sheets. Not outstanding, but bloody dependable. He deserved an England call up at a time when there weren't many good English keepers kicking around.
Reply
#5
(09-15-2022, 12:33 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I wouldn't mention Johnstone in the same breath as Foster or Hoult. Warming the bench for an average Prem club, approaching the prime of his career.

Foster was the dogs. Over 200 top flight appearances, the best keeper I've ever seen in a similar timescale to SB. Hoult was what we need now. The marshal of a tight defence, keeping a record number of clean sheets. Not outstanding, but bloody dependable. He deserved an England call up at a time when there weren't many good English keepers kicking around.

Regardless of your views of Sam J he is way ahead of what we have now. It's unfortunate how he left but overlooking a replacement is now looking criminal.
Reply
#6
(09-15-2022, 12:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 12:33 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I wouldn't mention Johnstone in the same breath as Foster or Hoult. Warming the bench for an average Prem club, approaching the prime of his career.

Foster was the dogs. Over 200 top flight appearances, the best keeper I've ever seen in a similar timescale to SB. Hoult was what we need now. The marshal of a tight defence, keeping a record number of clean sheets. Not outstanding, but bloody dependable. He deserved an England call up at a time when there weren't many good English keepers kicking around.

Regardless of your views of Sam J he is way ahead of what we have now. It's unfortunate how he left but overlooking a replacement is now looking criminal.

Oh, I agree on that point, SB.
Reply
#7
Just checked and unsurprisingly Button has comfortably the worst save % for shots against him in the division
Reply
#8
Must say, Button doesn't inspire confidence..

Also recall us having Peter Latchford Graham Smith & Chris Adamson, all rubbish.
Reply
#9
Alan Miller in my top 3 without a doubt rip
Reply
#10
(09-15-2022, 03:34 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Alan Miller in my top 3 without a doubt    rip

I would rate him third behind Hoult - purely because of Hoult's clean sheet record. I would definitely rate him higher than Johnstone. 

I would put Naylor and Johnstone level. Not bad keepers, good reactions, but neither commanded their area/defence well, and both had a mistake in them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: