Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(04-10-2019, 11:32 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (04-10-2019, 08:04 AM)Peachy Wrote: I personally think Jenkins gets the brunt of the stick because Lai is so far removed from the club. Jenkins has after all been given freedom to make the decisions. Is it soley his fault? No but he can carry a large proportion of the blame for the current managerial mess we find ourselves in.
Do you think Lai would have known about our poor home form and great away form and sacked Moore without consulting Jenkins? No way. Jenkins would have let him know what was happening with GJ etc.
So with that in mind and helping influence the decision he should have had his new man lined up. Instead Jenkins found himself in precisely the same situation he had done with Moore at the end of last season. He had a caretaker who suddenly started getting results and what did he do..........exactly what he had done with Moore. He got suckered in to some short term upturn in results and made the wrong long term decision.
He's not a clear thinker in my eyes and we need someone with conviction and vision.
Jenkins may not be the anti Christ but he is front and centre to our issues imvhfo.
Jenkins is part of a board and I think you'll find the chinese rep on there is pulling the strings more than we realise. Dowling is irrelevant and another disastrous appointment like the Italian.
The only bloke who is Albion through and through and with any integrity has been unceremoniously kicked out. Now if he was not prepared to get rid of GS and his hallucinatory coaching methods then I suppose they had no choice.
We are now in the biggest mess we have been in since Trev the Shed jumped into the dugout and I for one can't see the way out unless you get another Pulis type dictator in.
We need a George Graham type. Jokanovic could have been the man but clearly too ambitious for this lot. I'm expecting another AFI announcement. Lol
Actually, at this juncture I think someone like David Moyes would be perfect, no nonsense with plenty of grit. Or McInnes.
I really, really think McInnes could do a job. We need a tough, ruthless manager with ambition. He'd do.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(04-10-2019, 11:43 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-10-2019, 11:32 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (04-10-2019, 08:04 AM)Peachy Wrote: I personally think Jenkins gets the brunt of the stick because Lai is so far removed from the club. Jenkins has after all been given freedom to make the decisions. Is it soley his fault? No but he can carry a large proportion of the blame for the current managerial mess we find ourselves in.
Do you think Lai would have known about our poor home form and great away form and sacked Moore without consulting Jenkins? No way. Jenkins would have let him know what was happening with GJ etc.
So with that in mind and helping influence the decision he should have had his new man lined up. Instead Jenkins found himself in precisely the same situation he had done with Moore at the end of last season. He had a caretaker who suddenly started getting results and what did he do..........exactly what he had done with Moore. He got suckered in to some short term upturn in results and made the wrong long term decision.
He's not a clear thinker in my eyes and we need someone with conviction and vision.
Jenkins may not be the anti Christ but he is front and centre to our issues imvhfo.
Jenkins is part of a board and I think you'll find the chinese rep on there is pulling the strings more than we realise. Dowling is irrelevant and another disastrous appointment like the Italian.
The only bloke who is Albion through and through and with any integrity has been unceremoniously kicked out. Now if he was not prepared to get rid of GS and his hallucinatory coaching methods then I suppose they had no choice.
We are now in the biggest mess we have been in since Trev the Shed jumped into the dugout and I for one can't see the way out unless you get another Pulis type dictator in.
We need a George Graham type. Jokanovic could have been the man but clearly too ambitious for this lot. I'm expecting another AFI announcement. Lol
Actually, at this juncture I think someone like David Moyes would be perfect, no nonsense with plenty of grit. Or McInnes.
I really, really think McInnes could do a job. We need a tough, ruthless manager with ambition. He'd do.
I'd take McIness in a heartbeat tbh.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
If he hadn't played for us he wouldn't even be in our thoughts.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
04-10-2019, 01:26 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2019, 01:27 PM by Hopalong.)
(04-10-2019, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-10-2019, 08:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Success and failure can be narrow margins and whilst we were getting the results under Pulis to people outside the club it looked rosy. We knew it was short termist and destined to end in tears as well as being excruciating to be part of.
The years under him, to my mind, is the big issue. Remember Pardew, as hopeless as he was, took over a bunch of players who only knew how to score from set pieces and many who never crossed the half way line. The way Rondon has shone at Newcastle emphasises the way he was under-used.
You are arguing that the squad he inherited was better before he arrived for it to be ravaged. It wasn’t that’s my argument. It was an extremely weak squad that had no resale value whatsoever. Yes we wasted millions and TP is culpable for relegation as are the owners and those that have left. You won’t get any argument there but the point remains and it isn’t subjective we were in a tailspin of poor decisions and poor appoint to before TP arrived. He was a sticking plaster solution to a festering wound and over the long term the plaster was causing just as much infection as the original wound was.
Luckily we bought in Pardew who got the knife out amputated the problem.
Pulis is a strange one, we had two respectable finishes, he signed some great players and it was a combination of not being able to launch his masterplan with Chadli and Burke (due to injuries lol) and the fact he needed money finally did for him. Whilst I hated his 'football' - mainly after we'd reached 40 points - there were also some good moments.
He also managed the Saddo situation extraordinarily well, getting us 12m for in effect someone who was worthless. Half the current 1st team and Rondon are his signings and if we go down we'll get around 50m for them.
You have to be balanced!
ps not forgetting the 5m for McLean!
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-10-2019, 01:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (04-10-2019, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-10-2019, 08:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Success and failure can be narrow margins and whilst we were getting the results under Pulis to people outside the club it looked rosy. We knew it was short termist and destined to end in tears as well as being excruciating to be part of.
The years under him, to my mind, is the big issue. Remember Pardew, as hopeless as he was, took over a bunch of players who only knew how to score from set pieces and many who never crossed the half way line. The way Rondon has shone at Newcastle emphasises the way he was under-used.
You are arguing that the squad he inherited was better before he arrived for it to be ravaged. It wasn’t that’s my argument. It was an extremely weak squad that had no resale value whatsoever. Yes we wasted millions and TP is culpable for relegation as are the owners and those that have left. You won’t get any argument there but the point remains and it isn’t subjective we were in a tailspin of poor decisions and poor appoint to before TP arrived. He was a sticking plaster solution to a festering wound and over the long term the plaster was causing just as much infection as the original wound was.
Luckily we bought in Pardew who got the knife out amputated the problem.
Pulis is a strange one, we had two respectable finishes, he signed some great players and it was a combination of not being able to launch his masterplan with Chadli and Burke (due to injuries lol) and the fact he needed money finally did for him. Whilst I hated his 'football' - mainly after we'd reached 40 points - there were also some good moments.
He also managed the Saddo situation extraordinarily well, getting us 12m for in effect someone who was worthless. Half the current 1st team and Rondon are his signings and if we go down we'll get around 50m for them.
You have to be balanced!
ps not forgetting the 5m for McLean!
Good post Hoppy and you didn’t rewrite history
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-10-2019, 11:47 AM)Peachy Wrote: (04-10-2019, 11:43 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-10-2019, 11:32 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (04-10-2019, 08:04 AM)Peachy Wrote: I personally think Jenkins gets the brunt of the stick because Lai is so far removed from the club. Jenkins has after all been given freedom to make the decisions. Is it soley his fault? No but he can carry a large proportion of the blame for the current managerial mess we find ourselves in.
Do you think Lai would have known about our poor home form and great away form and sacked Moore without consulting Jenkins? No way. Jenkins would have let him know what was happening with GJ etc.
So with that in mind and helping influence the decision he should have had his new man lined up. Instead Jenkins found himself in precisely the same situation he had done with Moore at the end of last season. He had a caretaker who suddenly started getting results and what did he do..........exactly what he had done with Moore. He got suckered in to some short term upturn in results and made the wrong long term decision.
He's not a clear thinker in my eyes and we need someone with conviction and vision.
Jenkins may not be the anti Christ but he is front and centre to our issues imvhfo.
Jenkins is part of a board and I think you'll find the chinese rep on there is pulling the strings more than we realise. Dowling is irrelevant and another disastrous appointment like the Italian.
The only bloke who is Albion through and through and with any integrity has been unceremoniously kicked out. Now if he was not prepared to get rid of GS and his hallucinatory coaching methods then I suppose they had no choice.
We are now in the biggest mess we have been in since Trev the Shed jumped into the dugout and I for one can't see the way out unless you get another Pulis type dictator in.
We need a George Graham type. Jokanovic could have been the man but clearly too ambitious for this lot. I'm expecting another AFI announcement. Lol
Actually, at this juncture I think someone like David Moyes would be perfect, no nonsense with plenty of grit. Or McInnes.
I really, really think McInnes could do a job. We need a tough, ruthless manager with ambition. He'd do.
I'd take McIness in a heartbeat tbh.
Not but me. Have had enough of sentimental appointments
Posts: 335
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
04-10-2019, 04:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2019, 04:46 PM by LIMABAGGIE.)
Big Sam it is then...
I will rephrase the first line of my original post to represent what I really meant to say.. I don't think our board really wants to spend any money or do anything reasonably ambitious to gain promotion. They want it if it falls into our laps and they have to spend nothing
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-10-2019, 04:37 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: Big Sam it is then...
I will rephrase the first line of my original post to represent what I really meant to say.. I don't think our board really wants to spend any money or do anything reasonably ambitious to gain promotion. They want it if it falls into our laps and they have to spend nothing
To be fair to the board who wouldn't want to spend the minimum for the maximum return?
The problem may be in that our board reckon they might be able to do that.
Ultimately as long as they don't completely destroy us it could just land us with a better owner (or maybe even an even worse one) when Lai decides enough is enough and cuts his loses.
For all the "asset stripping" hysteria he might as well sell the club for a bit including the assets rather than piss around taking them all out until we're worth nothing.
Posts: 87
Threads: 16
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(04-10-2019, 08:04 AM)Peachy Wrote: I personally think Jenkins gets the brunt of the stick because Lai is so far removed from the club. Jenkins has after all been given freedom to make the decisions. Is it soley his fault? No but he can carry a large proportion of the blame for the current managerial mess we find ourselves in.
Do you think Lai would have known about our poor home form and great away form and sacked Moore without consulting Jenkins? No way. Jenkins would have let him know what was happening with GJ etc.
So with that in mind and helping influence the decision he should have had his new man lined up. Instead Jenkins found himself in precisely the same situation he had done with Moore at the end of last season. He had a caretaker who suddenly started getting results and what did he do..........exactly what he had done with Moore. He got suckered in to some short term upturn in results and made the wrong long term decision.
He's not a clear thinker in my eyes and we need someone with conviction and vision.
Jenkins may not be the anti Christ but he is front and centre to our issues imvhfo. +1
Jenkins doesn’t have the conviction to make key long term decisions, because realistically we lack an owner with long term ambition. That doesn’t mean Lai should be shovelling in vast amounts of cash left, right & centre; its more appointing an experienced manager with a long term plan that we can all buy into and back him with sensible funding.
As a result, Jenkins has no direction. The fact that he has free reign is actually more detrimental for us, in the sense that he is afraid to make mistakes - any shortcomings fall at his feet. As Peachy says, he appointed Moore because he did well in his caretaker role. He wanted to do the same with Shan after (in my opinion) he dropped a bollock in firing BD.
Posts: 581
Threads: 58
Joined: Apr 2019
It was more Dowling who wanted Moore out
|