Ratings
#1
Palmer - 7 - couple of good stops, swept up a few through balls well, perfectly fine back up
Ingram - 5 - didn't really notice him that much, constantly left out to dry by Phillips
Barts - 0 - absolute dogshit, massively unfit, seems to have aged ten years in the off season, at fault for the goal trying to flick the ball out of play only for it to go straight to a derby player, then pretty much stopping and turning his back to play, was taking 4 or 5 touches late on when the ball needed to be released quicker. Release him and get Taylor back.
O'Shea - 4.5 - Poor, also culpable for goal.
Ashworth - 3.5 - As someone else said, he was eaten alive.
TGH - 2.5 - I'm officially worried about him absolute passenger tonight
Livermore - 0 - Fuckin el, if he was a yard off the pace last year, this years he's got to be about ten yards off, will always try I'll give him that, should probably be moved back at this stage of his career, maybe as a back-up cb, wish we still had Mowatt
Phillips - minus 5 - The worst of the lot, a winger who can't beat a man, often at times found more inline with the 18 yard box than out wide, never moves to the ball to help out his young full back, yet at one point when the ball dropped to the corner of the 18 was huffing and puffing his way to get up with play, just an absolute fraud of a player, at one point was playing cm with predictably shite results, another I would release in the morning
Robinson - 5.5 - Actually gets into some nice positions and does some nice things, yet seemed to be actively trying not to score tonight.
Reach - 6 - Just a bang average chump player, at times looks ok, makes some nice runs, few nice passes, the next he's falling on his arse with no one next to him
Cleary - 6 - Thought he was decent tbf, used his physicality a few times to good effect, seems to have a right booming shot, still raw, I'd persevere with him rather than someone like Grabban

Subs - 
Fellows - 5 - tried, got to the by-line a few times, poor delivery
Swift - 6.5 - Dropped deep to try and get us going, linked up well with Diangana
Diangana - 7 - A threat, going to be key this season, hopefully stays fit
Jed - 5.5 - Anonymous
Grant - 4.5- Even more anonymous

Bruce - 4 - Fair enough he made changes in what will be a long old season, but we made 10 changes and then multiple changes and players shifted around in the second half, just left it all horribly disjointed until we added a modicum of pressure in the last 10 minutes. Always seems to be waiting for the game to come to him, him and the assistant had the pieces of paper out and were pointing and discussing at the 55th minute, yet it took until the 66th to actually enact a change, you have to wonder if they actually do any game planning or anything pre match or at half time for how they are gonna react should we be 1-0 down.

Booby Madeley - 3.5 - Inconsistent clown, a Derby player went down feigning injury off the pitch, pretty much allowed him to crawl back on and stopped us going on the counter, just weak refereeing. 

Was mildly impressed with McGoldrick for them.
Reply
#2
Prefer Cleary to a bloke who has constantly scored goals at Championship level?
Reply
#3
Ingram got absolutely battered and was rightly brought off at HT. Tough night for the kid.

I don’t think anybody came away from that game with credit tbh. The manager or the players. Poor.
Reply
#4
Would like to see Palmer given a league start. I really do not rate Button. In fact I think he’s very rubbish
Reply
#5
Palmer - 7
Ingram - 5
Barts - 4
O'Shea - 5
Ashworth - 3
TGH - 5
Livermore - 3
Phillips - 3
Robinson - 6
Reach - 7
Cleary - 5
Reply
#6
Livermore seems like the mate who never really plays or cares about football but gives it a proper go when he joins in with the lads. He'll kick air, can't control it but runs around and will give it a welly when he can.

He just doesn't seem like a footballer anymore.
Reply
#7
(08-24-2022, 10:05 AM)HLS Wrote: Livermore seems like the mate who never really plays or cares about football but gives it a proper go when he joins in with the lads. He'll kick air, can't control it but runs around and will give it a welly when he can.

He just doesn't seem like a footballer anymore.

The problem with professional football is that even if your heart isn’t in it anymore how can you ever walk away and do something else ? The money is to good
Reply
#8
(08-24-2022, 10:04 AM)Sliced Wrote: Palmer - 7
Ingram - 5
Barts - 4
O'Shea - 5
Ashworth - 3
TGH - 5
Livermore - 3
Phillips - 3

Robinson - 6
Reach - 7
Cleary - 5
For all the talk about the kids being poor, the highlighted scores are an absolute disgrace. What chance have the kids got when high earners and first team regulars turn in this kind of performance.
Reply
#9
(08-24-2022, 10:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-24-2022, 10:04 AM)Sliced Wrote: Palmer - 7
Ingram - 5
Barts - 4
O'Shea - 5
Ashworth - 3
TGH - 5
Livermore - 3
Phillips - 3

Robinson - 6
Reach - 7
Cleary - 5
For all the talk about the kids being poor, the highlighted scores are an absolute disgrace. What chance have the kids got when high earners and first team regulars turn in this kind of performance.

And this was definitely part of the issue. Looking at that starting 11 you'd have hoped that Phillps, Livermore, Bartley would be the experienced guiding heads for the youngsters, even if they aren't superstars.

In reality it was Robinson and Reach that stepped up and at least looked like they wanted to win.
Reply
#10
(08-24-2022, 09:58 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Would like to see Palmer given a league start. I really do not rate Button. In fact I think he’s very rubbish

Were you at the Hull game, because he kept us in that first half?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: