Trippier tackle on KDB
#11
The height of the contact made it look like an obvious red on first watching.

It was borderline and, by Trippier's own admission, calculated; he was probably fortunate to benefit from the overturn.
Reply
#12
(08-22-2022, 09:21 AM)Loanee Wrote: Professional fouls, where there is no intention to play the ball, to cynically stop attacks should be a red (dangerous or not).  Seems to be happening more & more, not good for the game

I don't disagree with this. But it would be an ideal scenario to be using a sin-bin. Essentially the attacking team get no benefit; in effect they get less as the attack has been halted and the defence can all get back into position.
Reply
#13
The inconsistency of that foul and its consequences,  compared with a slight brush of the shin in the penalty area resulting in an Olympic standard dive from the 10 metre board (a la Vardy ) resulting in a penalty, and possibly a red card for the defender,  demonstrates all that is wrong with the standard of refereeing in the Premier League.

I also blame morons like Martin Keown,  who has obviously never read the rules of the game,  pronouncing on on-field decisions that contravene the thuggish defender's charter. 

There was an incident in the world cup a few years back where six or seven Italian defenders were ripping the shirts off their attacking opponents as a corner came over.   The ref quite rightly gave a penalty.

Keown was outraged saying " if you're going to give penalties for shirt pulling in the penalty area there will be no defenders left on the field".

Precisely you twat.
Reply
#14
(08-22-2022, 09:26 AM)Fido Wrote:
(08-22-2022, 09:21 AM)Loanee Wrote: Professional fouls, where there is no intention to play the ball, to cynically stop attacks should be a red (dangerous or not).  Seems to be happening more & more, not good for the game

I don't disagree with this. But it would be an ideal scenario to be using a sin-bin. Essentially the attacking team get no benefit; in effect they get less as the attack has been halted and the defence can all get back into position.

Sin bins will create terrible periods of time wasting to run the sin bin clock down. Will increase gamesmanship for 10-15 minute periods. Would be way more negatives to them than positives IMO.
Reply
#15
(08-22-2022, 09:23 AM)Ossian Wrote: The height of the contact made it look like an obvious red on first watching.

It was borderline and, by Trippier's own admission, calculated; he was probably fortunate to benefit from the overturn.

This.

I'm not a fan of red cards, I much prefer watching games where 11 play 11, so take a lenient view on many incidents, including this one.

But once the red card was given I don't understand the rational for overturning the decision, given the clear and obvious criteria for the use of var.

It was cynical, meaning he knew he was going to foul him, no mistimed tackle, and it caught De Bruyne on the knee, so it was high and it was a bit of a lunge.

When he went to the monitor to review the decision what was he seeing to change his mind, or was it that to keep to his original decision,  he would be publicly disagreeing with another referee, and that would never do to have two refs coming to different conclusions about the same incident. Even though we know that happens all the time.
Reply
#16
I would have given it a yellow but I do not see how that met the threshold of "clear and obvious error".
Reply
#17
(08-22-2022, 05:56 AM)Fido Wrote:
(08-22-2022, 12:16 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Yet another example of a tackle worse than ones Jake has been sent off for.

Don’t agree. Was cynical but no more than what Rhodri had done earlier in the match. Yellow all day.

It was high though, Fido, at knee height roughly..

The point Im making though is Jake has been sent off for less IMO, to much derision from some fans. The inconsistency irks me.
Reply
#18
So the next time  Jimmy Anderson runs up to bowl, it will be OK for the batsman at the bowling crease to stick his leg out to put him off?    

That's a strategic foul, nothing more.
Reply
#19
(08-22-2022, 11:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-22-2022, 09:23 AM)Ossian Wrote: The height of the contact made it look like an obvious red on first watching.

It was borderline and, by Trippier's own admission, calculated; he was probably fortunate to benefit from the overturn.

This.

I'm not a fan of red cards, I much prefer watching games where 11 play 11, so take a lenient view on many incidents, including this one.

But once the red card was given I don't understand the rational for overturning the decision, given the clear and obvious criteria for the use of var.

It was cynical, meaning he knew he was going to foul him, no mistimed tackle, and it caught De Bruyne on the knee, so it was high and it was a bit of a lunge.

When he went to the monitor to review the decision what was he seeing to change his mind, or was it that to keep to his original decision,  he would be publicly disagreeing with another referee, and that would never do to have two refs coming to different conclusions about the same incident. Even though we know that happens all the time.
Agree with that. Debatable but should never have been overturned under the rules
Reply
#20
(08-22-2022, 12:16 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Yet another example of a tackle worse than ones Jake has been sent off for.

I thought exactly the same thing myself
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: