Bruce Sackometer
#81
(08-15-2022, 01:48 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 01:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Bruce didn't improve us last season and so far results have not improved this one. Noone ought to be calling for his head today, he deserves 10 games this season to demonstrate he can get us promoted. If after 10 games we aren't comfortably in the promotion conversation, he has to come under serious review.

I think this view is fair enough. Last season we were top after 10 games and averaging 2 goals scored per game. Yet some fans were already booing every time we didn't win and this became increasingly toxic as time went on as we all know.

Fast forward to this season and everyone's rightly raving about the arrival of Swift, Wallace and Yokuslu. However, it's not unreasonable to expect us to be there or thereabouts after 10 games this season, given what we did last season and now that we have these better players. It's at that point that I'll be starting to firm up on my assessment of things.

I don't regard Bruce's games last season as a free pass though, because he was brought in to achieve promotion (which he fully acknowledged) and we ended up in the bottom half of the table, so he carries some of that baggage for me. The best managers can get a tune out of the players who are already at a club on the new manager's arrival.

It's not true.

Just because you say it or say that we were 5th in the league when he took over doesn't make it true.  It isn't.

There's enough holes in Bruce's record for last season's performance without fake news.

We were 6th and teams had games in hand and we finished 10th.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#82
(08-15-2022, 01:30 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can we please stop the bullshit of a team that was in 5th when he took over.  It's simply not true.

https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/leag...uary-2022/  Teams won their games in hand.

Both managers failed last season, Bruce gets more slack because he was the one walking into the fragmented club.  A split fanbase, player fall outs, questionable attitudes and no transfer window.

This season needs to be a clean slate for the players and the manager.  4 games, all acceptable performances over the 90 mins which is a start, let him have the transfer window too ffs. 

I'm sure Bruce would change much more but considering our owner is forcing us to release a first team squad member to bring in a forward we all need to accept that it's more evolution than revolution.

He gets to the World Cup break for me, by then we'll have played 21 games.  I'll caveat that by saying if performances continue etc.  If we lose the next 12 on the bounce then I think it's fair to say he'll be toast.

The argument is Val was 5th when he was sacked. This is true. We dropped to 6th by the time Bruce took over because Huddersfield played before us and won. We actually had a game in hand over them and if we'd have won we'd have jumped back up to 5th regardless of the scoreline; of course we went on a terrible run so Huddersfield pulled away. However the fact of the matter is whether we were 5th, 6th or 7th it doesn't matter.

What I find ridiculous is that some are trying to justify Bruce's record by saying "well ACTUALLY we were only 6th when he took over and those below had a game in hand which they won" although we had a game in hand over the team above us but more pertinently........we weren't 10th and 8 points off the playoffs.

Whether we were 5th or 6th or 7th, games in hand or not. We weren't 10th or cut adrift from the playoffs. This is the important point.

If Bruce was doing a decent job there wouldn't be any need to look back and say "well ACTUALLY Bruce is doing ok because we were more like 7th when he took over rather than 5th" or "If you take the last 17 games of last season and compare them to Val's worst 17 games Bruce got 2 more points".

Val was CORRECTLY sacked. If Bruce was doing well then justifications about whether he got 2 points more or 2 points less or whether he took us from 5th to 10th or 6th to 10th with games in hand for the teams below would be irrelevant. At the absolute best Bruce has done comparable to the previous manager that was rightly sacked. That's not good enough.
Reply
#83
(08-15-2022, 07:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 01:30 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can we please stop the bullshit of a team that was in 5th when he took over.  It's simply not true.

https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/leag...uary-2022/  Teams won their games in hand.

Both managers failed last season, Bruce gets more slack because he was the one walking into the fragmented club.  A split fanbase, player fall outs, questionable attitudes and no transfer window.

This season needs to be a clean slate for the players and the manager.  4 games, all acceptable performances over the 90 mins which is a start, let him have the transfer window too ffs. 

I'm sure Bruce would change much more but considering our owner is forcing us to release a first team squad member to bring in a forward we all need to accept that it's more evolution than revolution.

He gets to the World Cup break for me, by then we'll have played 21 games.  I'll caveat that by saying if performances continue etc.  If we lose the next 12 on the bounce then I think it's fair to say he'll be toast.

The argument is Val was 5th when he was sacked. This is true. We dropped to 6th by the time Bruce took over because Huddersfield played before us and won. We actually had a game in hand over them and if we'd have won we'd have jumped back up to 5th regardless of the scoreline; of course we went on a terrible run so Huddersfield pulled away. However the fact of the matter is whether we were 5th, 6th or 7th it doesn't matter.

What I find ridiculous is that some are trying to justify Bruce's record by saying "well ACTUALLY we were only 6th when he took over and those below had a game in hand which they won" although we had a game in hand over the team above us but more pertinently........we weren't 10th and 8 points off the playoffs.

Whether we were 5th or 6th or 7th, games in hand or not. We weren't 10th or cut adrift from the playoffs. This is the important point.

If Bruce was doing a decent job there wouldn't be any need to look back and say "well ACTUALLY Bruce is doing ok because we were more like 7th when he took over rather than 5th" or "If you take the last 17 games of last season and compare them to Val's worst 17 games Bruce got 2 more points".

Val was CORRECTLY sacked. If Bruce was doing well then justifications about whether he got 2 points more or 2 points less or whether he took us from 5th to 10th or 6th to 10th with games in hand for the teams below would be irrelevant. At the absolute best Bruce has done comparable to the previous manager that was rightly sacked. That's not good enough.

Very good. The 17-game stat that i threw in there was merely to point out the mistake that Bruce made us worse. He clearly didn't. Did he make us better? No. Could Pep or Klopp have made that under-performing, disenchanted bunch any better? I doubt it.

Since then Bruce has signed 3 very good players for nowt in transfer fees. First half at Boro excepted, we have played well, decent football, and look like a football team with a plan. Trouble is we haven't put enough chances away (same old story) and our £7m striker is injured again.

So what do we do now? Sack the manager, and get someone else? Start all over again? If so, who? Come on. Lets have it. Give us the alternative, seeing as we don't have a pot to piss in, sacking Bruce would cost money, finding a replacement would cost money, and any transfer plans for the remainder of this window would be scrapped.

Or, do we give him a reasonable amount of time (say mid-November) and see where we are? If we are mid-table, not getting results, then by all means seek an alternative?
Reply
#84
(08-15-2022, 07:32 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 07:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 01:30 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can we please stop the bullshit of a team that was in 5th when he took over.  It's simply not true.

https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/leag...uary-2022/  Teams won their games in hand.

Both managers failed last season, Bruce gets more slack because he was the one walking into the fragmented club.  A split fanbase, player fall outs, questionable attitudes and no transfer window.

This season needs to be a clean slate for the players and the manager.  4 games, all acceptable performances over the 90 mins which is a start, let him have the transfer window too ffs. 

I'm sure Bruce would change much more but considering our owner is forcing us to release a first team squad member to bring in a forward we all need to accept that it's more evolution than revolution.

He gets to the World Cup break for me, by then we'll have played 21 games.  I'll caveat that by saying if performances continue etc.  If we lose the next 12 on the bounce then I think it's fair to say he'll be toast.

The argument is Val was 5th when he was sacked. This is true. We dropped to 6th by the time Bruce took over because Huddersfield played before us and won. We actually had a game in hand over them and if we'd have won we'd have jumped back up to 5th regardless of the scoreline; of course we went on a terrible run so Huddersfield pulled away. However the fact of the matter is whether we were 5th, 6th or 7th it doesn't matter.

What I find ridiculous is that some are trying to justify Bruce's record by saying "well ACTUALLY we were only 6th when he took over and those below had a game in hand which they won" although we had a game in hand over the team above us but more pertinently........we weren't 10th and 8 points off the playoffs.

Whether we were 5th or 6th or 7th, games in hand or not. We weren't 10th or cut adrift from the playoffs. This is the important point.

If Bruce was doing a decent job there wouldn't be any need to look back and say "well ACTUALLY Bruce is doing ok because we were more like 7th when he took over rather than 5th" or "If you take the last 17 games of last season and compare them to Val's worst 17 games Bruce got 2 more points".

Val was CORRECTLY sacked. If Bruce was doing well then justifications about whether he got 2 points more or 2 points less or whether he took us from 5th to 10th or 6th to 10th with games in hand for the teams below would be irrelevant. At the absolute best Bruce has done comparable to the previous manager that was rightly sacked. That's not good enough.

Very good. The 17-game stat that i threw in there was merely to point out the mistake that Bruce made us worse. He clearly didn't. Did he make us better? No. Could Pep or Klopp have made that under-performing, disenchanted bunch any better? I doubt it.

Since then Bruce has signed 3 very good players for nowt in transfer fees. First half at Boro excepted, we have played well, decent football, and look like a football team with a plan. Trouble is we haven't put enough chances away (same old story) and our £7m striker is injured again.

So what do we do now? Sack the manager, and get someone else? Start all over again? If so, who? Come on. Lets have it. Give us the alternative, seeing as we don't have a pot to piss in, sacking Bruce would cost money, finding a replacement would cost money, and any transfer plans for the remainder of this window would be scrapped.

Or, do we give him a reasonable amount of time (say mid-November) and see where we are? If we are mid-table, not getting results, then by all means seek an alternative?

Assuming you're aiming this at me. I've answered this 3 times already in the thread. I wouldn't sack the manager and I don't think we're anywhere near sacking the manager. I also have said multiple times that he's done well in the transfer window. On the pitch he needs to improve. It seems like we largely agree.
Reply
#85
(08-15-2022, 07:40 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 07:32 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 07:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 01:30 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can we please stop the bullshit of a team that was in 5th when he took over.  It's simply not true.

https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/leag...uary-2022/  Teams won their games in hand.

Both managers failed last season, Bruce gets more slack because he was the one walking into the fragmented club.  A split fanbase, player fall outs, questionable attitudes and no transfer window.

This season needs to be a clean slate for the players and the manager.  4 games, all acceptable performances over the 90 mins which is a start, let him have the transfer window too ffs. 

I'm sure Bruce would change much more but considering our owner is forcing us to release a first team squad member to bring in a forward we all need to accept that it's more evolution than revolution.

He gets to the World Cup break for me, by then we'll have played 21 games.  I'll caveat that by saying if performances continue etc.  If we lose the next 12 on the bounce then I think it's fair to say he'll be toast.

The argument is Val was 5th when he was sacked. This is true. We dropped to 6th by the time Bruce took over because Huddersfield played before us and won. We actually had a game in hand over them and if we'd have won we'd have jumped back up to 5th regardless of the scoreline; of course we went on a terrible run so Huddersfield pulled away. However the fact of the matter is whether we were 5th, 6th or 7th it doesn't matter.

What I find ridiculous is that some are trying to justify Bruce's record by saying "well ACTUALLY we were only 6th when he took over and those below had a game in hand which they won" although we had a game in hand over the team above us but more pertinently........we weren't 10th and 8 points off the playoffs.

Whether we were 5th or 6th or 7th, games in hand or not. We weren't 10th or cut adrift from the playoffs. This is the important point.

If Bruce was doing a decent job there wouldn't be any need to look back and say "well ACTUALLY Bruce is doing ok because we were more like 7th when he took over rather than 5th" or "If you take the last 17 games of last season and compare them to Val's worst 17 games Bruce got 2 more points".

Val was CORRECTLY sacked. If Bruce was doing well then justifications about whether he got 2 points more or 2 points less or whether he took us from 5th to 10th or 6th to 10th with games in hand for the teams below would be irrelevant. At the absolute best Bruce has done comparable to the previous manager that was rightly sacked. That's not good enough.

Very good. The 17-game stat that i threw in there was merely to point out the mistake that Bruce made us worse. He clearly didn't. Did he make us better? No. Could Pep or Klopp have made that under-performing, disenchanted bunch any better? I doubt it.

Since then Bruce has signed 3 very good players for nowt in transfer fees. First half at Boro excepted, we have played well, decent football, and look like a football team with a plan. Trouble is we haven't put enough chances away (same old story) and our £7m striker is injured again.

So what do we do now? Sack the manager, and get someone else? Start all over again? If so, who? Come on. Lets have it. Give us the alternative, seeing as we don't have a pot to piss in, sacking Bruce would cost money, finding a replacement would cost money, and any transfer plans for the remainder of this window would be scrapped.

Or, do we give him a reasonable amount of time (say mid-November) and see where we are? If we are mid-table, not getting results, then by all means seek an alternative?

Assuming you're aiming this at me. I've answered this 3 times already in the thread. I wouldn't sack the manager and I don't think we're anywhere near sacking the manager. I also have said multiple times that he's done well in the transfer window. On the pitch he needs to improve. It seems like we largely agree.

Bruce is the sensible option for now.
Reply
#86
(08-15-2022, 07:40 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 07:32 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 07:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 01:30 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can we please stop the bullshit of a team that was in 5th when he took over.  It's simply not true.

https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/leag...uary-2022/  Teams won their games in hand.

Both managers failed last season, Bruce gets more slack because he was the one walking into the fragmented club.  A split fanbase, player fall outs, questionable attitudes and no transfer window.

This season needs to be a clean slate for the players and the manager.  4 games, all acceptable performances over the 90 mins which is a start, let him have the transfer window too ffs. 

I'm sure Bruce would change much more but considering our owner is forcing us to release a first team squad member to bring in a forward we all need to accept that it's more evolution than revolution.

He gets to the World Cup break for me, by then we'll have played 21 games.  I'll caveat that by saying if performances continue etc.  If we lose the next 12 on the bounce then I think it's fair to say he'll be toast.

The argument is Val was 5th when he was sacked. This is true. We dropped to 6th by the time Bruce took over because Huddersfield played before us and won. We actually had a game in hand over them and if we'd have won we'd have jumped back up to 5th regardless of the scoreline; of course we went on a terrible run so Huddersfield pulled away. However the fact of the matter is whether we were 5th, 6th or 7th it doesn't matter.

What I find ridiculous is that some are trying to justify Bruce's record by saying "well ACTUALLY we were only 6th when he took over and those below had a game in hand which they won" although we had a game in hand over the team above us but more pertinently........we weren't 10th and 8 points off the playoffs.

Whether we were 5th or 6th or 7th, games in hand or not. We weren't 10th or cut adrift from the playoffs. This is the important point.

If Bruce was doing a decent job there wouldn't be any need to look back and say "well ACTUALLY Bruce is doing ok because we were more like 7th when he took over rather than 5th" or "If you take the last 17 games of last season and compare them to Val's worst 17 games Bruce got 2 more points".

Val was CORRECTLY sacked. If Bruce was doing well then justifications about whether he got 2 points more or 2 points less or whether he took us from 5th to 10th or 6th to 10th with games in hand for the teams below would be irrelevant. At the absolute best Bruce has done comparable to the previous manager that was rightly sacked. That's not good enough.

Very good. The 17-game stat that i threw in there was merely to point out the mistake that Bruce made us worse. He clearly didn't. Did he make us better? No. Could Pep or Klopp have made that under-performing, disenchanted bunch any better? I doubt it.

Since then Bruce has signed 3 very good players for nowt in transfer fees. First half at Boro excepted, we have played well, decent football, and look like a football team with a plan. Trouble is we haven't put enough chances away (same old story) and our £7m striker is injured again.

So what do we do now? Sack the manager, and get someone else? Start all over again? If so, who? Come on. Lets have it. Give us the alternative, seeing as we don't have a pot to piss in, sacking Bruce would cost money, finding a replacement would cost money, and any transfer plans for the remainder of this window would be scrapped.

Or, do we give him a reasonable amount of time (say mid-November) and see where we are? If we are mid-table, not getting results, then by all means seek an alternative?

Assuming you're aiming this at me. I've answered this 3 times already in the thread. I wouldn't sack the manager and I don't think we're anywhere near sacking the manager. I also have said multiple times that he's done well in the transfer window. On the pitch he needs to improve. It seems like we largely agree.

Wasn't aimed at you personally. Didn't mean to come across that way. Aimed more at the pant-wetting brigade who are quick at the 'potato head' insults but slower at coming up with a sensible alternative. 

All this after a 2-1 loss away at a team with a 100% record, whose two goals came from their only two efforts on target.
Reply
#87
It's fine man, no worries
Reply
#88
(08-15-2022, 03:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 03:05 PM)MassDebater Wrote: This is up there with posts about wishing the deludeds well in a game.

That thread was truly Ziz-esque in terms of attention seeking.

So is this one!
Reply
#89
4 games in now and pretty much settled back into the dross of last season with the Watford positives apparently the exception rather than the rule.

This thread looks a little less ridiculous tonight unfortunately.
Reply
#90
Give him time etc etc etc
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: