WBA Managers this century
#11
8 for Robson? Let’s not forget we went down the following season with barely a whimper. For all the talk of Livermore staying in the team at the moment, ditto Campbell back then. From what I recall it was the unfittest group of players I’d ever seen, all blowing out their arses after 75 mins.

Max 4 from me, and that’s being generous given it was only a last-game set of fluke results that took us off bottom in the Great Escape season.
Reply
#12
I always felt we survived in spite of Robson not because of.
Reply
#13
Megson 10
Hodgson 9
Clarke 8
Di Matteo 8
Mowbray 8
Bilic 8
Pulis 7
Moore 6
Robson 5
Bruce 5
Allardyce 5
Irvine 4
Val 3
Pardew 1
Mel 1
Little 1
Reply
#14
Bilic is hideously overrated.
Reply
#15
(08-15-2022, 12:54 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Bilic is hideously overrated.

A few months of good football, then some dire football and results.
Reply
#16
Pardew beat Liverpool, Away, in the Cup. Worth an extra mark so minus 999
Reply
#17
Yeh, Robson was not a great manager.

I personally feel the great escape was achieved in spite of him, rather than because of…
Reply
#18
Robson was key to getting Richardson and Campbell which were the signings that turned us around. Didn't rate him as a manager at all but some great memories from the last few months of that season.
Reply
#19
What did allardyce do to merit anything over 3?
Reply
#20
Prefer an A-F grade system

Little - Don't remember. Maybe that's for the best.
Megson A (Changed everything for the better. Would be A+ but was ultimately couldn't establish us in the top division)
Robson B (Just for the Great Escape)
Mowbray A- (It has been the best football we've played in decades with the league championship and an FA Cup semi to boot)
Di Matteo B (Got us back up with minimal fuss. Couldn't really build on it though)
Hodgson A (Our best Premier League manager by a mile)
Clarke B (Gave us one great season. We didn't get to see what was next so limited to a B)
Mel C - (Barely kept us up. Continental intrigue but didn't spice up our lives Wink)
Irvine D - (Bad appointment. A real non-starter)
Pulis B (Overstayed his welcome, but did what he was brought in for)
Pardew F (Brought in and sacked before the end of the season. Shite)
Moore B (A better manager would've taken us up, but for a rookie not bad)
Shan B (See above)
Bilic B + (A cut above the other Bs for me. After Covid it became a bit of a shitshow, but he took a squad up that wasn't ready to go up and it showed the following year)
Allardyce B - (Didn't keep us up, but it was really hard to do with that squad)
Val C- (Great start but it was only heading one way after that)
Bruce - ?

(08-15-2022, 12:43 PM)Duffers Wrote: I always felt we survived in spite of Robson not because of.

I don't think the players who played under him would agree.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: