Scorchio!!
#41
(08-09-2022, 03:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Random musing;

If copious amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere cause the planet to warm up (same applies to Venus, I believe, but on a far grander scale!), then, in theory, isn't there a chemical or substance we can pump into the atmosphere to cool a planet down?

Or is it only possible to warm a planet up?

I wonder if there's a civilisation out there with the complete opposite problem to us, in that they're producing too much of a specific substance that it's cooling their world down, and they're having to deal with constant snow storms and freezing temperatures.

As soon as you start talking about geo-engineering all the eco-hobbits who just want to end capitalism have a hissy fit. Forget it.
Reply
#42
We should get Elong to build a giant mirror in front of the sun
Reply
#43
(08-09-2022, 05:04 PM)SophLad Wrote: We should get Elong to build a giant mirror in front of the sun

Four of them, in fact. Each tilted towards one of Moscow, Tehran, Beijing and Pyong-Yang. Bit more like Sun Wars instead of Star Wars.
Reply
#44
(08-09-2022, 03:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I wonder if there's a civilisation out there with the complete opposite problem to us, in that they're producing too much of a specific substance that it's cooling their world down, and they're having to deal with constant snow storms and freezing temperatures.

It’s called Reading.
Reply
#45
(08-09-2022, 03:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 03:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Random musing;

If copious amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere cause the planet to warm up (same applies to Venus, I believe, but on a far grander scale!), then, in theory, isn't there a chemical or substance we can pump into the atmosphere to cool a planet down?

Or is it only possible to warm a planet up?

I wonder if there's a civilisation out there with the complete opposite problem to us, in that they're producing too much of a specific substance that it's cooling their world down, and they're having to deal with constant snow storms and freezing temperatures.

As soon as you start talking about geo-engineering all the eco-hobbits who just want to end capitalism have a hissy fit. Forget it.

We could train all dolphins and whales to spurt loads of water into the air simultaneously? 

Your great-great-grandkids can build a statue of me later.
Reply
#46
(08-09-2022, 03:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Random musing;

If copious amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere cause the planet to warm up (same applies to Venus, I believe, but on a far grander scale!), then, in theory, isn't there a chemical or substance we can pump into the atmosphere to cool a planet down?

Or is it only possible to warm a planet up?

I wonder if there's a civilisation out there with the complete opposite problem to us, in that they're producing too much of a specific substance that it's cooling their world down, and they're having to deal with constant snow storms and freezing temperatures.

Not actually a stupid question.

However it's not so much that CO2 warms the planet up itself, what it does is traps heat within the atmosphere, so it doesn't escape into space. As far as I know, but I'm not an expert, there isn't a substance which would have an opposite effect, ideally we'd have a substance that could take the CO2 out of the atmosphere, that didn't cause a similar problem itself.
Reply
#47
(08-09-2022, 03:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Random musing;

If copious amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere cause the planet to warm up (same applies to Venus, I believe, but on a far grander scale!), then, in theory, isn't there a chemical or substance we can pump into the atmosphere to cool a planet down?

Or is it only possible to warm a planet up?

I wonder if there's a civilisation out there with the complete opposite problem to us, in that they're producing too much of a specific substance that it's cooling their world down, and they're having to deal with constant snow storms and freezing temperatures.

Yes - see ice ages.

(08-09-2022, 03:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote: As soon as you start talking about geo-engineering all the eco-hobbits who just want to end capitalism have a hissy fit. Forget it.

Would cost a significant factor more to engineer the climate to cool down than it is to slow the growth of warming. Would like to see your proposed and costed solution to cutting off high pressure ocean currents (typically done by plate shifting), altering the Earth's orbit or cutting the intensity of radiation output from the sun.

Also it's difficult to model the environmental effects, could end up making things worse be affecting specific microclimates.

Geo-engineering is a lot harder than you're making out.
Reply
#48
Which weather site should you take as most accurate?

My Met Office app is saying we'll see tempratures up to 30 degrees between now and Sunday. However the BBC website (which I always assumed used Met Office data?) is showing as up to 35 degrees in the same period. Are the BBC scaremongering? Or is there a legitimate reason for this discrepancy?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#49
(08-10-2022, 07:41 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Which weather site should you take as most accurate?

My Met Office app is saying we'll see tempratures up to 30 degrees between now and Sunday. However the BBC website (which I always assumed used Met Office data?) is showing as up to 35 degrees in the same period. Are the BBC scaremongering? Or is there a legitimate reason for this discrepancy?
The BBC switched its provider of meteorological information a few years ago, so it no longer comes from the Met Office and is instead taken from a different company who are using an alternative weather prediction algorithm.

Personally, I find the met Office one to be more accurate for where I live
Reply
#50
(08-10-2022, 07:55 PM)spudgun Wrote:
(08-10-2022, 07:41 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Which weather site should you take as most accurate?

My Met Office app is saying we'll see tempratures up to 30 degrees between now and Sunday. However the BBC website (which I always assumed used Met Office data?) is showing as up to 35 degrees in the same period. Are the BBC scaremongering? Or is there a legitimate reason for this discrepancy?
The BBC switched its provider of meteorological information a few years ago, so it no longer comes from the Met Office and is instead taken from a different company who are using an alternative weather prediction algorithm.

Personally, I find the met Office one to be more accurate for where I live

This is true. It now comes from the same source as those outlets who love to - really annoyingly - not hesitate to tell that us it’s warmer than Athens or Barbados or Ibiza or wherever, when it absolutely isn’t the other 90% of the time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: