Mowatt
#41
Ideally it would be Livermore making way for Choudhary and not Mowatt. Who would be staying to take set pieces late-on. But that’s not really what’s happening is it.
Reply
#42
(08-09-2022, 04:12 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 04:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: He's bang average I'm afraid.

That said I'd certainly not be loaning him to one of our rivals in this division. He's welcome to head back to Barnsley, mind.

If he’s can’t average, why don’t you want him going to a rival? Surely sending a bang average player to a rival would be a good thing? Unless, he’s not hang average at all.

I wouldn't be loaning any of our players to a rival. If one of them wants to chuck us a couple of million then sell to whoever. 

He's a steady Championship player. At the moment we have Molumby (younger and in form), Yokuslu (one of the best in the division), Livermore (captains pick but poor) and it's between one of TGH and Mowatt for the final spot. I'd sooner keep TGH as one for the future. He's on a decent wage and if it freed that cash up for the striker we need then it's a no brainer.
Reply
#43
(08-09-2022, 05:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 04:12 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 04:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: He's bang average I'm afraid.

That said I'd certainly not be loaning him to one of our rivals in this division. He's welcome to head back to Barnsley, mind.

If he’s can’t average, why don’t you want him going to a rival? Surely sending a bang average player to a rival would be a good thing? Unless, he’s not hang average at all.

I wouldn't be loaning any of our players to a rival. If one of them wants to chuck us a couple of million then sell to whoever. 

He's a steady Championship player. At the moment we have Molumby (younger and in form), Yokuslu (one of the best in the division), Livermore (captains pick but poor) and it's between one of TGH and Mowatt for the final spot. I'd sooner keep TGH as one for the future. He's on a decent wage and if it freed that cash up for the striker we need then it's a no brainer.

Last night was a taste of what's to come. Livermore breathing out of his arse and Molumby getting booked. He'll be needed for more than a few games and if fit will do a decent job.
Reply
#44
Mowatt is a better player than Molumby. This is all that matters.

Molumby had a decent game last night but when we face more stubborn defensive teams we will need a little extra guile on the ball and neither Okay nor Molumby possess that. Also, look back at some of the passes and finishes Mowatt managed pre-injury last season, again neither Okay nor Molumby are capable of that.

For me our strongest central midfield is Okay and Mowatt, with Molumby next in line.

Letting Mowatt leave would be a mistake, letting him go to Boro would be insanity.

We really are paying the price for letting Livermore stay past last summer and extending Phillips’ deals.

Still, the £10m quid the club is owed would really help at a time like this.
Reply
#45
This would be a bad idea. Not only would it strengthen a rival, we'd be a couple of injuries/suspensions away from seeing Reach back in CM.

There's already some concerns whether OY can play 2 games a week, Livermore should be faded out now and Molumby has started well but will he keep it up all season?

I wouldn't be entirely against Mowatt leaving, but if he does it should be for a fee and he needs to be replaced.
Reply
#46
It's economics. And somebody has to leave to fund a striker. The sum of the parts of the team is greater than the individuals. This is what Brucebonce is good at, and one of the reasons he is here.
Reply
#47
I quite like Mowatt for one reason predominantly. He played much of last season injured. That tells me he is far more useful than a number of our pea-hearts.  As has been said, he is left footed, and good for a couple of goals. We have too many non goalscoring midfielders, they really ought to put in some shooting practice after training each day. I agree, his first season wasn't great but as a clean slate was offered to the likes of KZ, then Mowatt should be treated the same.
Reply
#48
If Molumby gets injured or suspended, Mowatt is a perfect like for like.

So I'd rather we didn't get rid.
Reply
#49
(08-09-2022, 05:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Mowatt is a better player than Molumby. This is all that matters.

Molumby had a decent game last night but when we face more stubborn defensive teams we will need a little extra guile on the ball and neither Okay nor Molumby possess that. Also, look back at some of the passes and finishes Mowatt managed pre-injury last season, again neither Okay nor Molumby are capable of that.

For me our strongest central midfield is Okay and Mowatt, with Molumby next in line.

Letting Mowatt leave would be a mistake, letting him go to Boro would be insanity.

We really are paying the price for letting Livermore stay past last summer and extending Phillips’ deals.

Still, the £10m quid the club is owed would really help at a time like this.

Mowatt isn’t better at the moment as he’s not playing. Molumby has started really well and deserves his place. As for Okay your giving him a disservice saying he doesn’t possess the guile he showed in his little cameo last night he has all the skills required. I will be undsnd why fans/posters worry about loaning/selling a player to a rival club. I have faith in my club if a player is deemed not required let him go. If he’s not good enough for us let someone else have the problem.
Reply
#50
(08-09-2022, 06:32 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 05:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Mowatt is a better player than Molumby. This is all that matters.

Molumby had a decent game last night but when we face more stubborn defensive teams we will need a little extra guile on the ball and neither Okay nor Molumby possess that. Also, look back at some of the passes and finishes Mowatt managed pre-injury last season, again neither Okay nor Molumby are capable of that.

For me our strongest central midfield is Okay and Mowatt, with Molumby next in line.

Letting Mowatt leave would be a mistake, letting him go to Boro would be insanity.

We really are paying the price for letting Livermore stay past last summer and extending Phillips’ deals.

Still, the £10m quid the club is owed would really help at a time like this.

Mowatt isn’t better at the moment as he’s not playing. Molumby has started really well and deserves his place. As for Okay your giving him a disservice saying he doesn’t possess the guile he showed in his little cameo last night he has all the skills required. I will be undsnd why fans/posters worry about loaning/selling a player to a rival club. I have faith in my club if a player is deemed not required let him go. If he’s not good enough for us let someone else have the problem.

No, Mowatt is a better player than Molumby, Molumby has shown some good form in preseason and was the right selection for the games at Boro and Watford, however Mowatt has a pedigree that Molumby does not and I fully expect he will come into the side in the coming months if he’s not moved on.  

Maybe my words were poorly selected, Okay does have class but he has never been a player that will play a progressive pass. He’s neat and tidy and won’t lose possession but he won’t open up a stubborn defence in the way Mowatt can, and he also doesn’t possess the attacking output that Mowatt does.

I wish I had your faith in our club when it comes to transfer business, it’s their god awful approach to scouting, contracts and general recruitment that’s got us in this mess.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: