Grant
#21
(08-09-2022, 07:58 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

Correct. He didn't choose his transfer fee and it's about 95% of the reason he gets so much grief.

Rubbish.

Most of us completely forget a player's transfer fee once they're in the door. It's purely about what they show on the pitch.

If a player plays badly, it doesn't make any difference whether they were free or cost £20m.

Nah that’s nonsense. You think if Burke had been signed on a free he’d have gotten the abuse he did? Expectations are higher for those we’ve spent more money on. Of course they get criticised more
Reply
#22
(08-09-2022, 07:58 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

Correct. He didn't choose his transfer fee and it's about 95% of the reason he gets so much grief.

Rubbish.

Most of us completely forget a player's transfer fee once they're in the door. It's purely about what they show on the pitch.

If a player plays badly, it doesn't make any difference whether they were free or cost £20m.

(08-09-2022, 07:57 AM)Fido Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 07:56 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

He doesn't get unfairly criticised at all.

It's rather typical of fans with goldfish bowl memories who only remember the last 90 minutes. Grant drove everyone mad last year with his poor workrate. It was always said that unless he scored we were effectively playing with ten men.

One display doesn't eradicate that.

His finishing was poor last night, had it not been, he'd have won us the game but he was much more involved, finally, and Bruce should tell him that is the standard if he wants to stay in the side.

Fair comment. Needs to take a few more gambles now he knows he has someone on the right who is looking to feed him each time he gets the ball too.

That's a very good point on Wallace. We've not had someone consistently putting the ball in for some time.

I know Swift got in for that one chance first half but as the #10, if you want, there needs to be some communication/plan so that in the rare event Grant does go front post to get in front of the defender then we have that more central runner to be there if it goes past him. I know it almost means asking someone to do two jobs but there are enough players who have shown they can do both. If this is going to be our pattern of play going forwards with crosses aplenty (and I certainly hope it is) then that's something else that needs a tweak.
Reply
#23
(08-09-2022, 07:58 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

Correct. He didn't choose his transfer fee and it's about 95% of the reason he gets so much grief.

Rubbish.

Most of us completely forget a player's transfer fee once they're in the door. It's purely about what they show on the pitch.

If a player plays badly, it doesn't make any difference whether they were free or cost £20m.


You new here? Zohore and Burke always have their fees mentioned, as do many others, and rightly so too. Of course the expectation of fans is adjusted based on the cost of the player. If say Cleary had played and had Grant's chances, people would be saying ah, but he's a kid... if it had been Burke then we'd all be making the same gags and mentionign the £15m... if it had been Zohore, well OK that's just stupid as it would never have been Zohore.
Reply
#24
(08-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 07:58 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

Correct. He didn't choose his transfer fee and it's about 95% of the reason he gets so much grief.

Rubbish.

Most of us completely forget a player's transfer fee once they're in the door. It's purely about what they show on the pitch.

If a player plays badly, it doesn't make any difference whether they were free or cost £20m.

Nah that’s nonsense. You think if Burke had been signed on a free he’d have gotten the abuse he did? Expectations are higher for those we’ve spent more money on. Of course they get criticised more

He might not have got the same level of abuse but we'd all have still thought he was shit, just like previously when Grant hadn't shown up in many games last season and was criticised for lack of effort.
Reply
#25
Grant has never been lazy. In fact he has consistently covered lots of ground and always makes good, sometimes selfless runs. Yes he occasionally has the first touch like he's playing with a giant bouncy ball and misses some decent chances. But his goal return is still good, whcih proves he gets into these scoring areas regularly.

As an aside. Yes 15 million is a decent sum of money, but lets not pretend its a huge sum. Thats the going rate for a crap clubs best player. Infact alot of average players are going for huge sums of money these days. Lets look at Gibbs-White as a direct comparison. Last season for Sheff Utd he played 37 games scored 12 and got 10 assists, so a total of 22 GC's in 37 games, so a GCx of 0.59. He's 2 years younger and is being touted for a pushing 50 million quid move to Forest. KG got 18 goals and 6 assists in 44, so a GCx of 0.5. Now Sheff Utd were going like a stream train for much of the year whilst we were shite.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#26
(08-09-2022, 08:11 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grant has never been lazy. In fact he has consistently covered lots of ground and always makes good, sometimes selfless runs. Yes he occasionally has the first touch like he's playing with a giant bouncy ball and misses some decent chances. But his goal return is still good, whcih proves he gets into these scoring areas regularly.

As an aside. Yes 15 million is a decent sum of money, but lets not pretend its a huge sum. Thats the going rate for a crap clubs best player. Infact alot of average players are going for huge sums of money these days. Lets look at Gibbs-White as a direct comparison. Last season for Sheff Utd he played 37 games scored 12 and got 10 assists, so a total of 22 GC's in 37 games, so a GCx of 0.59. He's 2 years younger and is being touted for a pushing 50 million quid move to Forest. KG got 18 goals and 6 assists in 44, so a GCx of 0.5. Now Sheff Utd were going like a stream train for much of the year whilst we were shite.

Good post
Reply
#27
(08-09-2022, 08:11 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grant has never been lazy. In fact he has consistently covered lots of ground and always makes good, sometimes selfless runs. Yes he occasionally has the first touch like he's playing with a giant bouncy ball and misses some decent chances. But his goal return is still good, whcih proves he gets into these scoring areas regularly.

As an aside. Yes 15 million is a decent sum of money, but lets not pretend its a huge sum. Thats the going rate for a crap clubs best player. Infact alot of average players are going for huge sums of money these days. Lets look at Gibbs-White as a direct comparison. Last season for Sheff Utd he played 37 games scored 12 and got 10 assists, so a total of 22 GC's in 37 games, so a GCx of 0.59. He's 2 years younger and is being touted for a pushing 50 million quid move to Forest. KG got 18 goals and 6 assists in 44, so a GCx of 0.5. Now Sheff Utd were going like a stream train for much of the year whilst we were shite.

Excellent post. Personally I've always quite liked Grant. As I've said before, for me, the strikers (or whatever they want to call them these days) are there to score or create chances, if they're doing that then I am more likely to cut them some slack. Grant will score more this year (if he plays as many) then last year, because our team looks like it wants to play football again and therefore he and Grady will benefit a lot from it. That's my prediction based on last night, I think if he plays as many as he did he will score over 20, and may even push 25. I honestly think had he been in Slav's Champ team then he'd have been scoring week in week out.

How's that for a bold prediction?
Reply
#28
(08-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-09-2022, 07:58 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-08-2022, 10:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Grant gets goals. Simple. Misses his fair share. But scores a decent amount. A very valuable member of our squad who is unfairly criticised imo.

Correct. He didn't choose his transfer fee and it's about 95% of the reason he gets so much grief.

Rubbish.

Most of us completely forget a player's transfer fee once they're in the door. It's purely about what they show on the pitch.

If a player plays badly, it doesn't make any difference whether they were free or cost £20m.

Nah that’s nonsense. You think if Burke had been signed on a free he’d have gotten the abuse he did? Expectations are higher for those we’ve spent more money on. Of course they get criticised more

Yes I do. Because he was shit.
Reply
#29
Had Burke signed on a free he’d have been cheap, lazy, nasty shit. Instead he was overpriced shit.
Reply
#30
Generally reading posts especially on march days Grant is heavily criticized until he scores.
If he gets 15+ goals again this season thats fantastic.
Our focus should be on who else is going to step up and get 15+ goals. That's where our problem lies.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)