Alex Neil is top of the list for summer
#51
(04-08-2019, 05:22 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 01:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 09:44 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 05:16 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: The simple  fact that Neil appears to be our number 1 choice someone who can work well with a small or no budget really sums up or short sightedness short term cheap penny pinching entrenched Dna approach as a club no wonder we're where we are and the Vile have taken the piss for the best part of the last 40yrs Angry

Would you prefer someone who needs a big budget? Spends money we don’t have or, even if we did have it, put us in breach of FFP? Someone like Redknapp would tick those boxes I reckon.
No i just want the club to show a modicome of ambition instead of the usual default of let's see how cheap we can do this.

Hiding behind FFP is just an excuse for not spending IMO, I will just say Seals and Dingles, Blues, Leeds, Fulham, Huddersfield, Forest, it's feels like it's just us who hides behind the rule book. Can anyone explain what has happened to the others for blowing the FFP rules out of the window. QPR appeared to have a mega fine - which has not been paid yet and Blues docked 9 points, but most of that was attributed to illegally signing a player not the overspend. Seals & Dingle NOTHING.
As for spending money we don't have - like Greg and Sturridge and Burke was all sensible?. Having a £3m release clause for Evans - most of us can see how crap the people are who are running the show. The loans we got in January IMO have performed no better then players we already had. Actually we have got worse and our manager now sacked. 
Basically is it better to have tried and failed or to have a half hearted attempt? That's the biggest issue IMO
(As for Redknapp he only spent what people let him - he didn't sign the cheques did he?) 
Nothing I can do but whinge and wait for Lai and Jenkins to get the boot and someone who is prepared to have a real go at winning something run the club.

QPR are struggling to stay up, go anywhere 
Blues are going nowhere and could still go down. They were fined in the main for over spending 
Huddersfield relegated after two seasons but as far as I’m aware they haven’t flouted the rules have they?
Forest are going nowhere 
Fulham relegated after spending over £100m ffs and some want Jankmycrank who allowed it to happen on his watch. Whether he wanted those players or not it shows a weakness that he agreed to them been foisted upon him if he didn’t. 
Villa will probably be in trouble as will Derby, Leeds and Forest next season, if they don’t go up. This has been mooted many times by national and local media.  

Evans I imagine would not have signed for us without the clause. 
Fans wanted Moore, did he get the best out the squad, did he spend wisely? Did he get the best out of the loans he must if sanctioned? That’s up for debate
We are making a loss and have done our best to keep a squad better than most together this season
Our wage bill is in the top three in the league
Redknapp has a string of clubs with financial woes after he’s left on his C.V

The managers sacking and subsequent indecision is baffling, frustrating and a huge risk given we are told how important it is for promotion this season but this is football and frankly it’s not the most intelligent or rational game.
Reply
#52
(04-08-2019, 07:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 05:22 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 01:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 09:44 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(04-08-2019, 05:16 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: The simple  fact that Neil appears to be our number 1 choice someone who can work well with a small or no budget really sums up or short sightedness short term cheap penny pinching entrenched Dna approach as a club no wonder we're where we are and the Vile have taken the piss for the best part of the last 40yrs Angry

Would you prefer someone who needs a big budget? Spends money we don’t have or, even if we did have it, put us in breach of FFP? Someone like Redknapp would tick those boxes I reckon.
No i just want the club to show a modicome of ambition instead of the usual default of let's see how cheap we can do this.

Hiding behind FFP is just an excuse for not spending IMO, I will just say Seals and Dingles, Blues, Leeds, Fulham, Huddersfield, Forest, it's feels like it's just us who hides behind the rule book. Can anyone explain what has happened to the others for blowing the FFP rules out of the window. QPR appeared to have a mega fine - which has not been paid yet and Blues docked 9 points, but most of that was attributed to illegally signing a player not the overspend. Seals & Dingle NOTHING.
As for spending money we don't have - like Greg and Sturridge and Burke was all sensible?. Having a £3m release clause for Evans - most of us can see how crap the people are who are running the show. The loans we got in January IMO have performed no better then players we already had. Actually we have got worse and our manager now sacked. 
Basically is it better to have tried and failed or to have a half hearted attempt? That's the biggest issue IMO
(As for Redknapp he only spent what people let him - he didn't sign the cheques did he?) 
Nothing I can do but whinge and wait for Lai and Jenkins to get the boot and someone who is prepared to have a real go at winning something run the club.

QPR are struggling to stay up, go anywhere 
Blues are going nowhere and could still go down. They were fined in the main for over spending 
Huddersfield relegated after two seasons but as far as I’m aware they haven’t flouted the rules have they?
Forest are going nowhere 
Fulham relegated after spending over £100m ffs and some want Jankmycrank who allowed it to happen on his watch. Whether he wanted those players or not it shows a weakness that he agreed to them been foisted upon him if he didn’t. 
Villa will probably be in trouble as will Derby, Leeds and Forest next season, if they don’t go up. This has been mooted many times by national and local media.  

Evans I imagine would not have signed for us without the clause. 
Fans wanted Moore, did he get the best out the squad, did he spend wisely? Did he get the best out of the loans he must if sanctioned? That’s up for debate
We are making a loss and have done our best to keep a squad better than most together this season
Our wage bill is in the top three in the league
Redknapp has a string of clubs with financial woes after he’s left on his C.V

The managers sacking and subsequent indecision is baffling, frustrating and a huge risk given we are told how important it is for promotion this season but this is football and frankly it’s not the most intelligent or rational game.

Fair few decision / indecision's IMO indicates massive problems / differences within the senior mgt team.
Darren was the 1st and easy scapegoat - who is next ? Lai if nothing is a business man and will have a plan I'm sure of that. You don't become a billionaire by accident.   
Hudds have blown £80 Million on transfers in the last 2 years I would have expected FFP rules to be exceeded when they come back down. Unless they shuffle the numbers around like the others. I think QPR will get the £42M fine reduced or written off in time.
Reply
#53
I assume Dowling was effectively BD's line-manager? 

So, why didn't he just speak to BD and say  - look this playing out from the back bollox isn't working.  Go back to the successful formula of the back-end of last season and if that means GS going, I'll deal with it.
Reply
#54
(04-09-2019, 12:15 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I assume Dowling was effectively BD's line-manager? 

So, why didn't he just speak to BD and say  - look this playing out from the back bollox isn't working.  Go back to the successful formula of the back-end of last season and if that means GS going, I'll deal with it.

Maybe that was suggested Hopalong? IMO more will come out once season has finished
Reply
#55
(04-09-2019, 12:26 AM)Albion Wrote:
(04-09-2019, 12:15 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I assume Dowling was effectively BD's line-manager? 

So, why didn't he just speak to BD and say  - look this playing out from the back bollox isn't working.  Go back to the successful formula of the back-end of last season and if that means GS going, I'll deal with it.

Maybe that was suggested Hopalong? IMO more will come out once season has finished

I'm sure someone on here said BD was told to sack off Graeme Jones and he chose not to.
Reply
#56
(04-09-2019, 12:26 AM)Albion Wrote:
(04-09-2019, 12:15 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I assume Dowling was effectively BD's line-manager? 

So, why didn't he just speak to BD and say  - look this playing out from the back bollox isn't working.  Go back to the successful formula of the back-end of last season and if that means GS going, I'll deal with it.

Maybe that was suggested Hopalong? IMO more will come out once season has finished
Confused
Reply
#57
(04-09-2019, 07:55 AM)Squid Wrote:
(04-09-2019, 12:26 AM)Albion Wrote:
(04-09-2019, 12:15 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I assume Dowling was effectively BD's line-manager? 

So, why didn't he just speak to BD and say  - look this playing out from the back bollox isn't working.  Go back to the successful formula of the back-end of last season and if that means GS going, I'll deal with it.

Maybe that was suggested Hopalong? IMO more will come out once season has finished

I'm sure someone on here said BD was told to sack off Graeme Jones and he chose not to.

I don’t know Squid. However reading between the lines suggests that something happened. Talk is Jones set to join Luton in Summer. It will be v interesting to see Moore’s next move. He’s done enough to get a crack at Championship level. As for what you’ve stated, I don’t think that would surprise anyone. Moore is a genuine, fair and loyal man.
Reply
#58
I doubt his arguments with Dowlimg over transfers, while negotiating a move to Luton endeared Jones to anyone. Think that had more to play with Moore being sacked than actual results.

I also think Jones was a bad choice as assistant.
Reply
#59
(04-09-2019, 10:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I doubt his arguments with Dowlimg over transfers, while negotiating a move to Luton endeared Jones to anyone. Think that had more to play with Moore being sacked than actual results.

I also think Jones was a bad choice as assistant.


It makes you question who wanted to sign Johansen and Montero? I genuinely believe that we’ve wasted money. I’d rather we give the youth an opportunity. Holgate was a Moore target in Summer and  Murphy was targeted as Barnes replacement.

It’s all conjecture though. You could argue Jones was loyal that he was willing to stay till the end of the season, club questioning his commitment makes me laugh to be honest.

Who knows without Jones we could also have been worse off. I think people forget when QPR came down with experienced players under Redknapp, they finished 4th and went up via play offs against Derby. Or what about Allardyce at West Ham, he only got them through the play offs too.

The pertinent point is that the hierarchy had lost all confidence in Moore, Jones + Jacobs. 

Who would have thought what would have unravelled walking out at 10pm on 19th February at Loftus Road....
Reply
#60
Jones had too much of an influence and Mooro has to take blame for that. I love the bloke to bits but it felt like he was a bit out his depth and relied on Jones too much like he relied on Shan at the end of last season. The extra time against Brighton where Jones gave the team talk and Mooro listened in just like the players said it all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)