Poll: Where do you stand?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Bloody useless Dinosaur - Should have been sacked before KO after his starting XI
21.95%
18 21.95%
He's getting on my wick - Last change saloon (Reply to teh post with how many games hes got in your book)
48.78%
40 48.78%
Its ridiculous to have a go at Bruce-y, he is teh right man for the job.
29.27%
24 29.27%
Total 82 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll
(08-02-2022, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Regardless of the Valxit debate (again) taking over and some labelling the thread stupid. I am glad to see that Bruce still enjoys plenty of support as it might be me thats seeing it wrong, do there's still hope of things working out... Fingers crossed.

Because this is his first real season and transfer window. He clearly needs to get us into the play-offs minimum but how can you judge anything after one game? This is why I think the poll is meaningless and stupid. We had the same posters last season saying we needed to give the manager 1, 2, 3, years and multiple transfer windows before we could judge. We had a meltdown from some because they didn’t like the team Bruce had picked ffs!

Questioning the team selection is standard forum bread and butter for every club in the country, hardly meltdown material.
The selection was hardly vindicated 1st half either, took a rollocking at half time to wake them up and, to be honest, was lucky it was only 1-0.

Personally I can see the negatives and the positives in it. Awful team selection from Bruce, but played a blinder at half time.
Reply
(08-02-2022, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Regardless of the Valxit debate (again) taking over and some labelling the thread stupid. I am glad to see that Bruce still enjoys plenty of support as it might be me thats seeing it wrong, do there's still hope of things working out... Fingers crossed.

Because this is his first real season and transfer window. He clearly needs to get us into the play-offs minimum but how can you judge anything after one game? This is why I think the poll is meaningless and stupid. We had the same posters last season saying we needed to give the manager 1, 2, 3, years and multiple transfer windows before we could judge. We had a meltdown from some because they didn’t like the team Bruce had picked ffs!

Following relegation there as a general acceptance from our fan base that we needed to rebuild. The squad had grown stale and we needed to freshen things up. Val was brought in with that brief and the initial signs were very positive, and for the first time in a while we were doing something different and it interesting. In the short term it didn’t work and we have reverted to the short term thinking and appointed a manager with a simple brief - get us into the playoffs, which he failed to do, and is now briefed with getting us up this year. 

Bruce will be judged more harshly than Val because he failed to deliver his objective last year, he has been backed more heavily this summer, and because he is seen as an experienced old head that gives us the best chance of doing it this season, if he looks unlikely to do that then he will be under immediate pressure. His form last season, and the 45 minutes preceding a lot of the so called hysteria compounded the general feeling he probably isn’t up to delivering promotion this year.

There's no such thing as a long term manager. Just short term managers who get results. Val brought in 8 players including 3 loans from Premier League sides and was given £7million to spend on Dike so he was backed. I've heard that he got unlucky with Dike because of the injury but he was the one who rushed him in the team too quickly when he wasn't fully fit whereas Bruce seems to be easing him in.

You say the first 45 minutes compound the feeling that he won't get us promoted but fail to mention the second half where we played very well and were unlucky not to win the game against a promotion rival away from home. Last season he had an unbalanced team without a creative midfielder, he's now fixed that and actually brought in players who will improve us which is more than can be said for Val. Judging him for last season to say he's not up to getting us promoted is like saying Allardyce is not up to avoiding relegation with a Premier League side because of the poor results he had after being left with Bilic's squad.
Reply
(08-02-2022, 09:48 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 09:33 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 09:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How the fuck did this descend into a discussion about Val?

Bruce's team selection was questionable -> "Criticising Bruce is hysterical" -> "but he finished tenth" -> Val's fault. Poor players still traumatised from "Valball"

And here we are.

It's a pretty standard route unfortunately.

People called for Bruce to get the sack, ott insults etc and that’s perfectly ok / not hysterical after or even before a ball had been kicked. 

People give reasons for team selection that are perfectly reasonable reposts 

People defend hysterical reaction to team news by bringing up that we were 5th when he took over last season. People point out / put in perspective the general trajectory of team at the time due to former managers leadership. 

People suggest this seasons league is easier because Fulham aren’t in it. Ignoring the teams that have come down. 

People post on ludicrous poll thread 

The end

I'm just gonna leave it there. I literally wrote a 16 line post about why I think the league is weaker this year of which 90% isn't about Fulham and which talks about all the teams that came down.

It's just pointless trying to have a discussion.

And you were correct, but some just like to play devils advocate. Don't rise to it
Reply
(08-02-2022, 02:29 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Regardless of the Valxit debate (again) taking over and some labelling the thread stupid. I am glad to see that Bruce still enjoys plenty of support as it might be me thats seeing it wrong, do there's still hope of things working out... Fingers crossed.

Because this is his first real season and transfer window. He clearly needs to get us into the play-offs minimum but how can you judge anything after one game? This is why I think the poll is meaningless and stupid. We had the same posters last season saying we needed to give the manager 1, 2, 3, years and multiple transfer windows before we could judge. We had a meltdown from some because they didn’t like the team Bruce had picked ffs!

Following relegation there as a general acceptance from our fan base that we needed to rebuild. The squad had grown stale and we needed to freshen things up. Val was brought in with that brief and the initial signs were very positive, and for the first time in a while we were doing something different and it interesting. In the short term it didn’t work and we have reverted to the short term thinking and appointed a manager with a simple brief - get us into the playoffs, which he failed to do, and is now briefed with getting us up this year. 

Bruce will be judged more harshly than Val because he failed to deliver his objective last year, he has been backed more heavily this summer, and because he is seen as an experienced old head that gives us the best chance of doing it this season, if he looks unlikely to do that then he will be under immediate pressure. His form last season, and the 45 minutes preceding a lot of the so called hysteria compounded the general feeling he probably isn’t up to delivering promotion this year.

There's no such thing as a long term manager. Just short term managers who get results. Val brought in 8 players including 3 loans from Premier League sides and was given £7million to spend on Dike so he was backed. I've heard that he got unlucky with Dike because of the injury but he was the one who rushed him in the team too quickly when he wasn't fully fit whereas Bruce seems to be easing him in.

You say the first 45 minutes compound the feeling that he won't get us promoted but fail to mention the second half where we played very well and were unlucky not to win the game against a promotion rival away from home. Last season he had an unbalanced team without a creative midfielder, he's now fixed that and actually brought in players who will improve us which is more than can be said for Val. Judging him for last season to say he's not up to getting us promoted is like saying Allardyce is not up to avoiding relegation with a Premier League side because of the poor results he had after being left with Bilic's squad.

Exactly and thank you
Reply
(08-02-2022, 02:29 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Regardless of the Valxit debate (again) taking over and some labelling the thread stupid. I am glad to see that Bruce still enjoys plenty of support as it might be me thats seeing it wrong, do there's still hope of things working out... Fingers crossed.

Because this is his first real season and transfer window. He clearly needs to get us into the play-offs minimum but how can you judge anything after one game? This is why I think the poll is meaningless and stupid. We had the same posters last season saying we needed to give the manager 1, 2, 3, years and multiple transfer windows before we could judge. We had a meltdown from some because they didn’t like the team Bruce had picked ffs!

Following relegation there as a general acceptance from our fan base that we needed to rebuild. The squad had grown stale and we needed to freshen things up. Val was brought in with that brief and the initial signs were very positive, and for the first time in a while we were doing something different and it interesting. In the short term it didn’t work and we have reverted to the short term thinking and appointed a manager with a simple brief - get us into the playoffs, which he failed to do, and is now briefed with getting us up this year. 

Bruce will be judged more harshly than Val because he failed to deliver his objective last year, he has been backed more heavily this summer, and because he is seen as an experienced old head that gives us the best chance of doing it this season, if he looks unlikely to do that then he will be under immediate pressure. His form last season, and the 45 minutes preceding a lot of the so called hysteria compounded the general feeling he probably isn’t up to delivering promotion this year.

There's no such thing as a long term manager. Just short term managers who get results. Val brought in 8 players including 3 loans from Premier League sides and was given £7million to spend on Dike so he was backed. I've heard that he got unlucky with Dike because of the injury but he was the one who rushed him in the team too quickly when he wasn't fully fit whereas Bruce seems to be easing him in.

You say the first 45 minutes compound the feeling that he won't get us promoted but fail to mention the second half where we played very well and were unlucky not to win the game against a promotion rival away from home. Last season he had an unbalanced team without a creative midfielder, he's now fixed that and actually brought in players who will improve us which is more than can be said for Val. Judging him for last season to say he's not up to getting us promoted is like saying Allardyce is not up to avoiding relegation with a Premier League side because of the poor results he had after being left with Bilic's squad.

I haven't mentioned long term managers? I said we appointed Val with a view to a long term plan, namely a style of play that ran through the club, and overhauling a squad that was going to take a few windows to reshape.

You say Val was backed more heavily than Bruce? How many of last summer's signings will be on contracts like Swift and Wallace? They were two of the stand-out players in the league last season. Potentially Mowatt, but that's about it. The remaining signings were hardly ones which fixed the glaring gaps in our squad - I mean we signed Molumby, Reach and Hugill FFS!!

I agree Val took the decision to play Dike too quickly after his injury, but I presume this wasn't his choice alone, I'm sure his medical team and the player had assessed the injury and agreed it was safe to play?

The reason I mentioned the first 45 minutes and not the second is the alleged "hysteria" all took place before the game and during the first half. In the second half most people have quite rightly praised Bruce for making the tweaks that got us back into the game, unfortunately many of those tweaks were only what most of the "hystericals" were suggesting may have been our best approach to start the game, and that given Boro were arguably the weakest they'll line up all season, this could have been an opportunity for us to take the game to them, and not risk being 2 or 3 goals behind by HT...
Reply
(08-02-2022, 03:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 02:29 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Regardless of the Valxit debate (again) taking over and some labelling the thread stupid. I am glad to see that Bruce still enjoys plenty of support as it might be me thats seeing it wrong, do there's still hope of things working out... Fingers crossed.

Because this is his first real season and transfer window. He clearly needs to get us into the play-offs minimum but how can you judge anything after one game? This is why I think the poll is meaningless and stupid. We had the same posters last season saying we needed to give the manager 1, 2, 3, years and multiple transfer windows before we could judge. We had a meltdown from some because they didn’t like the team Bruce had picked ffs!

Following relegation there as a general acceptance from our fan base that we needed to rebuild. The squad had grown stale and we needed to freshen things up. Val was brought in with that brief and the initial signs were very positive, and for the first time in a while we were doing something different and it interesting. In the short term it didn’t work and we have reverted to the short term thinking and appointed a manager with a simple brief - get us into the playoffs, which he failed to do, and is now briefed with getting us up this year. 

Bruce will be judged more harshly than Val because he failed to deliver his objective last year, he has been backed more heavily this summer, and because he is seen as an experienced old head that gives us the best chance of doing it this season, if he looks unlikely to do that then he will be under immediate pressure. His form last season, and the 45 minutes preceding a lot of the so called hysteria compounded the general feeling he probably isn’t up to delivering promotion this year.

There's no such thing as a long term manager. Just short term managers who get results. Val brought in 8 players including 3 loans from Premier League sides and was given £7million to spend on Dike so he was backed. I've heard that he got unlucky with Dike because of the injury but he was the one who rushed him in the team too quickly when he wasn't fully fit whereas Bruce seems to be easing him in.

You say the first 45 minutes compound the feeling that he won't get us promoted but fail to mention the second half where we played very well and were unlucky not to win the game against a promotion rival away from home. Last season he had an unbalanced team without a creative midfielder, he's now fixed that and actually brought in players who will improve us which is more than can be said for Val. Judging him for last season to say he's not up to getting us promoted is like saying Allardyce is not up to avoiding relegation with a Premier League side because of the poor results he had after being left with Bilic's squad.

I haven't mentioned long term managers? I said we appointed Val with a view to a long term plan, namely a style of play that ran through the club, and overhauling a squad that was going to take a few windows to reshape.

You say Val was backed more heavily than Bruce? How many of last summer's signings will be on contracts like Swift and Wallace? They were two of the stand-out players in the league last season. Potentially Mowatt, but that's about it. The remaining signings were hardly ones which fixed the glaring gaps in our squad - I mean we signed Molumby, Reach and Hugill FFS!!

I agree Val took the decision to play Dike too quickly after his injury, but I presume this wasn't his choice alone, I'm sure his medical team and the player had assessed the injury and agreed it was safe to play?

The reason I mentioned the first 45 minutes and not the second is the alleged "hysteria" all took place before the game and during the first half. In the second half most people have quite rightly praised Bruce for making the tweaks that got us back into the game, unfortunately many of those tweaks were only what most of the "hystericals" were suggesting may have been our best approach to start the game, and that given Boro were arguably the weakest they'll line up all season, this could have been an opportunity for us to take the game to them, and not risk being 2 or 3 goals behind by HT...

No they weren’t, we were well on top in the second half before we made our first sub in the 68th minute. The second and third changes were in the final ten - 15 mins and by that point the game could have gone either way. Go back and look at the reactions to the team announcement and half time and ask yourself are they the reactions of fans who allegedly followed football for twenty, thirty, forty years, I say allegedly because the reactions suggested they were new to the game.
Reply
All I see here is people entrenched in a previous discussion desperately stating opinions as if they were facts in an effort to reinforce past posts.  The pro Bruce campaigners blaming Ismael for last season omitting they had already said we had a top 2 team anyway and anyone else but VI managing would improve us. We clearly were not top 2 material. Big Fat Sam knew this and chose to retire from management instead.  The team suffered from non investment last August and it was plain to see. The arrival of Dike in January proved too little too late.
Meanwhile; The anti Bruce brigade are more really anti Jake and Matt Phillips, forgetting that we normally get better results with Livermore in the side and Phillips was one of our better performers up until last season. I agree wholeheartedly that we need better but I can see the reason both were selected. The continued selection of Furlong is something I can't defend. (I also think Townsend should be dropped for Reach IMO). 
My onions FWIW,  changing managers too soon again would not help. There are a number of things Bruce can be called to account for.  First, some of the uninspiring games -i.e.Blues away- and similar games where if we had just scraped a few more points we could have made the play offs. Next, not giving kids too much of a chance when there was little to play for and the experienced pros were selected instead. Biggest of all for me, I actually didn't see any clear definitive style or tactics plus the previously mentioned Full Backs issue.  I'm for giving Bruce a fair go to see if he can address some of these. The addition to the squad of a proper CF, (a hopefully fit Dike), and three very decent midfielders has given us a squad that I reckon should be top four. I am looking to see a clear pattern of teamwork inspired by the multiple coaches Bruce seems to bring with him, and a steadily growing self belief in the ability of our players. Otherwise, we'll be starting all over again.
Reply
(08-02-2022, 04:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: All I see here is people entrenched in a previous discussion desperately stating opinions as if they were facts in an effort to reinforce past posts.  The pro Bruce campaigners blaming Ismael for last season omitting they had already said we had a top 2 team anyway and anyone else but VI managing would improve us. We clearly were not top 2 material. Big Fat Sam knew this and chose to retire from management instead.  The team suffered from non investment last August and it was plain to see. The arrival of Dike in January proved too little too late.
Meanwhile; The anti Bruce brigade are more really anti Jake and Matt Phillips, forgetting that we normally get better results with Livermore in the side and Phillips was one of our better performers up until last season. I agree wholeheartedly that we need better but I can see the reason both were selected. The continued selection of Furlong is something I can't defend. (I also think Townsend should be dropped for Reach IMO). 
My onions FWIW,  changing managers too soon again would not help. There are a number of things Bruce can be called to account for.  First, some of the uninspiring games -i.e.Blues away- and similar games where if we had just scraped a few more points we could have made the play offs. Next, not giving kids too much of a chance when there was little to play for and the experienced pros were selected instead. Biggest of all for me, I actually didn't see any clear definitive style or tactics plus the previously mentioned Full Backs issue.  I'm for giving Bruce a fair go to see if he can address some of these. The addition to the squad of a proper CF, (a hopefully fit Dike), and three very decent midfielders has given us a squad that I reckon should be top four. I am looking to see a clear pattern of teamwork inspired by the multiple coaches Bruce seems to bring with him,  and a steadily growing self belief in the ability of our players. Otherwise, we'll be starting all over again.

A excellent post, that 99% will agree with.
Reply
Positive opening 2 results / performances, bar the first half of the first game of the season (away vs a promotion favourite).

Think it’s obvious Bruce has a plan, knows what he is doing & deserves the fans backing
Reply
(08-09-2022, 07:40 AM)Loanee Wrote: Positive opening 2 results / performances, bar the first half of the first game of the season (away vs a promotion favourite).

Think it’s obvious Bruce has a plan, knows what he is doing & deserves the fans backing

Correct. However I don't think it's unfair to say that if we're well off it (which looks more and more unlikely each day) after 10-12 games it wouldn't be unfair to reassess his position then.

My opinion hasn't changed, I'm just far more encouraged than I was a week ago.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: