Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
08-01-2022, 12:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-01-2022, 03:56 AM by Everything Zin.)
(07-31-2022, 11:40 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Nathan Jones a better manager than Bruce?? 
Well, he outperformed him last season and with what most people would say was a weaker squad. Bruce’s only success in recent years was taking Villa into the bottom half of the Championship ( well,I consider that a success!) We have a squad capable of at least a top 6 finish - I fear we have a manager who isn’t.
Posts: 318
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(07-30-2022, 06:50 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Button 6 Kicking shit but ok, feel more comfortable with balls in the box than Johnstone
Furlong 2 Awful for far too long now
Ajayi 8 Excellent, especially second half
OShea 7 Struggled a bit 1st half but superb 2nd
Townsend 7 Very disciplined, held his position and dropped in when Ajayi got forward
Livermore 4 Timing is shot so constantly off the pace and his passing as poor as ever
Molumby 5 Passenger 1st half, better 2nd but can't play him and Livermore together
Swift 6 Great goal but didn't get enough of the ball due to the inability of Livermore and Molumby to find him on a regular basis
Wallace 8 Very good debut, keep him fit and we will always have a chance
Phillips 3 Offered nothing going forward and failed to cover the woeful Furlong
Grant 4 Out of position and it showed, anonymous
Dike 7 Looks a beast although a bit raw, but I remember when that was said about Big Cyrille
Diangana 5 Needs too much time on the ball
Bruce 4 Terrible starting 11 which warranted a 1, but pulled it back slightly with his half time team talk
Not sure how Phillips could’ve provided cover for Furlong from his position on the left wing.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
We shouldn't be scared about changing manager's, the average stay is 53 weeks.
Bruce will already be looking at where his next job is going to be. We should also be actively looking and preparing a list of possible replacements.
Bruce IMO now has a squad which are capable of automatically getting promotion, but if he cannot get the best from these players then let's get someone who can
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(07-31-2022, 11:01 PM)wba13 Wrote: (07-31-2022, 10:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
We got a point away against a decent team at a difficult ground to play at. We didn’t play defensively we went out to win the game.
Grady did one decent run what else? We looked better from the start of the second half. He didn’t turn the game.
Livermore was ok, nowhere as bad as you’re making out. The tackle inside our box was very important intervention.
Molumby grew into the game as many of our players did.
I’m never quite sure what Mowatt does, particularly in a team that doesn’t play Val ball. He’s not a defensive midfielder, he’s not particularly creative and isn’t great at passing so I’m not sure how he fits into a central two. Until Okay is fit Livermore and Molumby will play I imagine.
Dike looked good when he came on but he’s coming back from a long injury and has to be introduced carefully and given the choice of bringing him on when their players are tiring or from the start I’d argue Bruce got that call right.
TGH should play ahead of Furlong who was our worst performer I agree.
Bruce is going nowhere soon unless we have disastrous results and a 1-1 draw isn’t one of them.
Bruce did what Bruce does… took an acceptable amount of points from a tricky game.
The question mark around Bruce for his whole career has been whether he’s done a good job, or just done what’s expected.
IMO Boro we’re actually there for the taking, and a less risk adverse XI could have seen us take the win. Second half we throughly deserved to win the game but we should have been 2-down as a minimum by HT, and that was purely down to our overly cautious selection.
I have no doubt Bruce will make the playoffs; the issue is that I struggle to see 2 sides in this division with a better squad, but I do see plenty with a better manager.
Who are all these managers who are better?
Wilder
Robins
Jones
For a start.
The three names you mention don’t have a better record in the championship than Bruce, Jones couldn’t hack it at Stoke,Robins been around a while and no bigger club than Coventry have took the chance.Wilder good manager and my choice before Ismael. It’s about time we Give Bruce a real chance with his team not Ismael’s. Add Smith to the list. Unless you want to go into ancient history.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(07-31-2022, 09:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-31-2022, 08:28 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I deleted my ratings this morning as they read like a 5 year old had written them, as I was hammered at 1am... So here I go again.
Button - 6 - Safe hands, terrible distribution.
Furlong - 4 - Ran his bollocks off, but everything else was awful. Terrible on and off the ball.
Ajayi - 8 - Couple of dodgy moments with the ball at his feet in the first 15 mins. But when we push up higher he comes into his own. Great 1v1 defender and so much pace.
O'Shea - 7 - Got better as the game went on. Thought he was targeted first half and it seems too much for him. Will develop nicely as the season goes on.
Townsend - 5 - Still looks slow and off the pace, much like last season.
Molumby - 6 - Extra mark for the pass for the equaliser. Didn't track his man enough and goes missing so much for a player who runs as much as he does.
Livermore - 4 - Slow, didn't do his work defensively, done bollock all going forwards, and his passing was off. No good.
Wallace - 8 - Did well and looked promising. Lost mark for his awful finish when through 1v1. Will be a great signing.
Swift - 8 - Picks up great positions, has a touch of class we need. Cracking finish. Will be a good signing also.
Phillips - 4 - Ran a bit, shouted abit, achieved sod all. Why ever Bruce thinks he should okay on the left especially is beyond me.
Grant - 6 - Worked hard enough, made some good runs which created space for those around him. But never looked likely to score.
Subs:
Dike - 8 - Fucking unit. Flash backs of a young Rom. Will be a fans favourite.
Grady - 7 - Looks like he is more focussed and improved us, he must start.
TGH & Mowatt - Should have been the starting 2 in midfield.
Many people are berating people for calling for Bruce's head, hiding behind the arbitrary "changing of seasons" as a restart. Well for me the first half performance, the starting XI, the lack of ambition etc, etc. Is just symptomatic of his tenure for half a season. He's got 5 games for me. If he is not settling the team up right and showing more ambition he should be gone.
We got a point away against a decent team at a difficult ground to play at. We didn’t play defensively we went out to win the game.
Grady did one decent run what else? We looked better from the start of the second half. He didn’t turn the game.
Livermore was ok, nowhere as bad as you’re making out. The tackle inside our box was very important intervention.
Molumby grew into the game as many of our players did.
I’m never quite sure what Mowatt does, particularly in a team that doesn’t play Val ball. He’s not a defensive midfielder, he’s not particularly creative and isn’t great at passing so I’m not sure how he fits into a central two. Until Okay is fit Livermore and Molumby will play I imagine.
Dike looked good when he came on but he’s coming back from a long injury and has to be introduced carefully and given the choice of bringing him on when their players are tiring or from the start I’d argue Bruce got that call right.
TGH should play ahead of Furlong who was our worst performer I agree.
Bruce is going nowhere soon unless we have disastrous results and a 1-1 draw isn’t one of them.
Bruce did what Bruce does… took an acceptable amount of points from a tricky game.
The question mark around Bruce for his whole career has been whether he’s done a good job, or just done what’s expected.
IMO Boro we’re actually there for the taking, and a less risk adverse XI could have seen us take the win. Second half we throughly deserved to win the game but we should have been 2-down as a minimum by HT, and that was purely down to our overly cautious selection.
I have no doubt Bruce will make the playoffs; the issue is that I struggle to see 2 sides in this division with a better squad, but I do see plenty with a better manager.
Fair comments. If we were getting Bruce ten years ago then I think we'd arguably have the best manager too but times seem to have changed. I was actually really happy with the appointment but only the most one eyed of supporters would try and claim he did anything other than terrible last season.
However, I definitely think having a strong squad is the most important thing. I think the championship this season is weaker than last year and we've undoubtedly got stronger over the summer; partially due to the planning of Bruce/Gourlay and partially due to the board actually delivering on the players the manager wanted while not shipping off key players.
However, clean slate needed for the new season. I'm really happy with how well Wallace and Swift are linking up. That could be absolutely massive and, given the depth in the squad we now have, absolutely no reason to be finishing at least top 6 and probably top 2.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
08-01-2022, 07:47 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-01-2022, 07:53 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(07-31-2022, 11:01 PM)wba13 Wrote: (07-31-2022, 10:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-31-2022, 09:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
We got a point away against a decent team at a difficult ground to play at. We didn’t play defensively we went out to win the game.
Grady did one decent run what else? We looked better from the start of the second half. He didn’t turn the game.
Livermore was ok, nowhere as bad as you’re making out. The tackle inside our box was very important intervention.
Molumby grew into the game as many of our players did.
I’m never quite sure what Mowatt does, particularly in a team that doesn’t play Val ball. He’s not a defensive midfielder, he’s not particularly creative and isn’t great at passing so I’m not sure how he fits into a central two. Until Okay is fit Livermore and Molumby will play I imagine.
Dike looked good when he came on but he’s coming back from a long injury and has to be introduced carefully and given the choice of bringing him on when their players are tiring or from the start I’d argue Bruce got that call right.
TGH should play ahead of Furlong who was our worst performer I agree.
Bruce is going nowhere soon unless we have disastrous results and a 1-1 draw isn’t one of them.
Bruce did what Bruce does… took an acceptable amount of points from a tricky game.
The question mark around Bruce for his whole career has been whether he’s done a good job, or just done what’s expected.
IMO Boro we’re actually there for the taking, and a less risk adverse XI could have seen us take the win. Second half we throughly deserved to win the game but we should have been 2-down as a minimum by HT, and that was purely down to our overly cautious selection.
I have no doubt Bruce will make the playoffs; the issue is that I struggle to see 2 sides in this division with a better squad, but I do see plenty with a better manager.
Who are all these managers who are better?
Wilder
Robins
Jones
For a start.
The three names you mention don’t have a better record in the championship than Bruce, Jones couldn’t hack it at Stoke,Robins been around a while and no bigger club than Coventry have took the chance.Wilder good manager and my choice before Ismael. It’s about time we Give Bruce a real chance with his team not Ismael’s.
That's because none of those managers have had the budgets in the Championship which Bruce has enjoyed.
Bruce is a very experienced Championship manager that has to a degree delivered when heavily backed. For this reason I expect him to get us into the top 6 this season, but it will be punctuated by a season-long debate about whether Bruce is getting the most he could be out of the squad.
If we had Wilder, Robins or Jones with the budget we have I'd be much more excited about what our team could be, I know the latter gets a lot of stick for his Stoke spell, but his record at Luton is just plain ridiculous, and he did no worse than O'Neill and Rowatt did who are both very capable managers too.
(08-01-2022, 07:40 AM)Sliced Wrote: Fair comments. If we were getting Bruce ten years ago then I think we'd arguably have the best manager too but times seem to have changed. I was actually really happy with the appointment but only the most one eyed of supporters would try and claim he did anything other than terrible last season.
However, I definitely think having a strong squad is the most important thing. I think the championship this season is weaker than last year and we've undoubtedly got stronger over the summer; partially due to the planning of Bruce/Gourlay and partially due to the board actually delivering on the players the manager wanted while not shipping off key players.
However, clean slate needed for the new season. I'm really happy with how well Wallace and Swift are linking up. That could be absolutely massive and, given the depth in the squad we now have, absolutely no reason to be finishing at least top 6 and probably top 2.
Bruce was a long way away from my first choice because I felt we needed to take a more long term view, but I understood the rationale in bringing in someone with his track record.
With our resources I still believe persevering with the Val project was the right thing to do. As a club I feel we need an identity and a plan for how we intend on making progress beyond this season, how we incorporate youth players and how we plan to recruit under much tighter financial circumstances (either in the PL or should we remain at this level). Bruce is not this man, and nor is he the kind of manager who will wring every last ounce out of our existing squad. He just feels like another bag carrier, appointed to get us through this season and we will see where we are come May and this really frustrates me.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-01-2022, 07:47 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Bruce was a long way away from my first choice because I felt we needed to take a more long term view, but I understood the rationale in bringing in someone with his track record.
With our resources I still believe persevering with the Val project was the right thing to do. As a club I feel we need an identity and a plan for how we intend on making progress beyond this season, how we incorporate youth players and how we plan to recruit under much tighter financial circumstances (either in the PL or should we remain at this level). Bruce is not this man, and nor is he the kind of manager who will wring every last ounce out of our existing squad. He just feels like another bag carrier, appointed to get us through this season and we will see where we are come May and this really frustrates me.
Particularly agree with the last paragraph. I said on here previously, we moan non-stop about moving on deadwood like Livermore and Phillips yet we have the managerial equivalent sat in the dugout.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(08-01-2022, 08:36 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-01-2022, 07:47 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Bruce was a long way away from my first choice because I felt we needed to take a more long term view, but I understood the rationale in bringing in someone with his track record.
With our resources I still believe persevering with the Val project was the right thing to do. As a club I feel we need an identity and a plan for how we intend on making progress beyond this season, how we incorporate youth players and how we plan to recruit under much tighter financial circumstances (either in the PL or should we remain at this level). Bruce is not this man, and nor is he the kind of manager who will wring every last ounce out of our existing squad. He just feels like another bag carrier, appointed to get us through this season and we will see where we are come May and this really frustrates me.
Particularly agree with the last paragraph. I said on here previously, we moan non-stop about moving on deadwood like Livermore and Phillips yet we have the managerial equivalent sat in the dugout.
Indeed, and one who regards the deadwood as actually being the mighty oaks in the forest!
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(08-01-2022, 08:44 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (08-01-2022, 08:36 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-01-2022, 07:47 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Bruce was a long way away from my first choice because I felt we needed to take a more long term view, but I understood the rationale in bringing in someone with his track record.
With our resources I still believe persevering with the Val project was the right thing to do. As a club I feel we need an identity and a plan for how we intend on making progress beyond this season, how we incorporate youth players and how we plan to recruit under much tighter financial circumstances (either in the PL or should we remain at this level). Bruce is not this man, and nor is he the kind of manager who will wring every last ounce out of our existing squad. He just feels like another bag carrier, appointed to get us through this season and we will see where we are come May and this really frustrates me.
Particularly agree with the last paragraph. I said on here previously, we moan non-stop about moving on deadwood like Livermore and Phillips yet we have the managerial equivalent sat in the dugout.
Indeed, and one who regards the deadwood as actually being the mighty oaks in the forest!
I see Bruce as unable to get the best from his players, weather that was at Villa, Newcastle or here. He is far to cautious. The players he selects, his formations and tactics are focused on hoping to snatch a win. And not lose. He sees a draw as a point gained, I see it as 2 points lost.
As soon as Smith took over at Villa up they went. Now Howe is at Newcastle he will take them higher then Bruce did. He's really a nice dinosaur and should not be seen as a safe option. IMO he has no excuses, he knows the players, he now needs to quickly show us he's up for the task or move aside.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
08-01-2022, 09:32 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-01-2022, 09:38 AM by Big Daddy Cool.)
(08-01-2022, 12:20 AM)Everything Zin Wrote: (07-31-2022, 11:40 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Nathan Jones a better manager than Bruce?? 
Well, he outperformed him last season and with what most people would say was a weaker squad. Bruce’s only success in recent years was taking Villa into the bottom half of the Championship ( well,I consider that a success!) We have a squad capable of at least a top 6 finish - I fear we have a manager who isn’t.
If he outperforms Bruce this season then you'll have a point. Bruce had Val's squad last season. Now he's starting to get his own players in. Funnily enough two of our better attacking players on Saturday were Bruce signings and MOTM was a player Val had sitting on the bench until Bruce came in.
In terms of Bruce's recent success, he finished 12th and 13th in the Premier League with Newcastle and did a good job in the little time he was at Sheff Wed (only lost 3 in 18 games). Also Villa were a mess before he came in and he got them to a play off final although the following season obviously wasn't as successful. I understand some of the criticisms of Bruce but some seem to want to ignore the success he has had because it doesn't fit their agenda.
|