Val ball
#11
There's just a hint of Ismael revisionism creeping into some recent posts on here. A surprising willingness to cut the bloke some slack, perhaps?

I think he was a total fecking disaster for us. He declared his intention of playing "out of possession" football, didn't sign the players to carry it off, couldn't motivate the players he had to carry on with it. His whole scheme was based on stats and wasn't backed up by even a shred of flexibility, football common-sense or motivation. He turned on the players far too readily, ran out of ideas and left us with an unbalanced squad of broken and feeble-spirited men. I'm not defending the players, the senior ones were spineless at best and actively disruptive at worst, but Ismael was responsible for making it work. xG stats don't put the ball in the net or points on the board.
Reply
#12
(07-23-2022, 10:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There's just a hint of Ismael revisionism creeping into some recent posts on here. A surprising willingness to cut the bloke some slack, perhaps?

I think he was a total fecking disaster for us. He declared his intention of playing "out of possession" football, didn't sign the players to carry it off, couldn't motivate the players he had to carry on with it. His whole scheme was based on stats and wasn't backed up by even a shred of flexibility, football common-sense or motivation. He turned on the players far too readily, ran out of ideas and left us with an unbalanced squad of broken and feeble-spirited men. I'm not defending the players, the senior ones were spineless at best and actively disruptive at worst, but Ismael was responsible for making it work. xG stats don't put the ball in the net or points on the board.

Fair amount of revisionism in this post Chesh.

The board failed to deliver the players or the squad overhaul that he wanted, outside of Mowatt, and when we did deliver Dike he got injured. He was promised several windows and a long term rebuild and then wasnt backed to even start the process. 

Ismael then was probably overly flexible with his tactics… when he should have doubled down on his methods, increased the intensity of the press he tried to introduce possession and cave into the players’ needs.

The whole sorry mess was far more than Val’s fault, he should never have been appointed, but given we did, we should have bloody backed the project.
Reply
#13
This SW4

I respect Ches to bits but that post is farcical

The fact Bruce took us backwards in terms of result and ideas and he’s getting time on the job compared to Val speaks volumes about our fan base

It’s a chapter in our clubs history, move on

The bloke did OK, who knows how we would have got on if we stuck with him but I’d comfortably wager we would have been no lower than 9th

Let’s see if Bruce can kick us on and if Val can satisfy the Turks barmy fans, highly unlikely

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#14
(07-23-2022, 10:34 PM)Cuzer Wrote: This SW4

I respect Ches to bits but that post is farcical

The fact Bruce took us backwards in terms of result and ideas and he’s getting time on the job compared to Val speaks volumes about our fan base

It’s a chapter in our clubs history, move on

The bloke did OK, who knows how we would have got on if we stuck with him but I’d comfortably wager we would have been no lower than 9th

Let’s see if Bruce can kick us on and if Val can satisfy the Turks barmy fans, highly unlikely

Cuzer

It's harsh to compare the results of a man who had a full preseason and implemented a philosophy of play, with a manager who was brought in not fully knowing what he was walking into. Bruce should get a fair shake and he will.

That said, I would've given Val the whole season because I think we weren't gonna go up with whoever in charge. At least the board would've had more time to think about their next appointment. I know we're desperate to go up, but we weren't good enough. That became evident as the season went on.
Reply
#15
Val at Barnsley was right club at right time, right players, right levels of expectation. Val at Albion was polar opposite on each. Given a ridiculous contract by an inexperienced management team who thought they had pulled off a stroke of genius guaranteeing success with limited investment. If he learns from his time here will go onto have a decent career in management on the continent. Given some success this year will soon drift into the memory filed under failed experiment. I don't ever expect the word Project to be uttered at the Hawthorns again.
Reply
#16
Let it go. He's moved on. We've moved on. So should our fans.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#17
(07-23-2022, 10:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2022, 10:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There's just a hint of Ismael revisionism creeping into some recent posts on here. A surprising willingness to cut the bloke some slack, perhaps?

I think he was a total fecking disaster for us. He declared his intention of playing "out of possession" football, didn't sign the players to carry it off, couldn't motivate the players he had to carry on with it. His whole scheme was based on stats and wasn't backed up by even a shred of flexibility, football common-sense or motivation. He turned on the players far too readily, ran out of ideas and left us with an unbalanced squad of broken and feeble-spirited men. I'm not defending the players, the senior ones were spineless at best and actively disruptive at worst, but Ismael was responsible for making it work. xG stats don't put the ball in the net or points on the board.

Fair amount of revisionism in this post Chesh.

The board failed to deliver the players or the squad overhaul that he wanted, outside of Mowatt, and when we did deliver Dike he got injured. He was promised several windows and a long term rebuild and then wasnt backed to even start the process. 

Ismael then was probably overly flexible with his tactics… when he should have doubled down on his methods, increased the intensity of the press he tried to introduce possession and cave into the players’ needs.

The whole sorry mess was far more than Val’s fault, he should never have been appointed, but given we did, we should have bloody backed the project.

Fair comment. Fact is I didn't like and don't like Val's idea of football. It's a ball playing game, so if your main plan is what to do without the ball you're missing out on the artistry and entertainment. Pulis never seemed to coach attacking play so his success was limited to 1-0 wins. Val wanted his players to scramble the ball into the net somehow but they couldn't do it. Either way, it's not what I want to see.
Reply
#18
(07-24-2022, 10:17 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2022, 10:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2022, 10:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There's just a hint of Ismael revisionism creeping into some recent posts on here. A surprising willingness to cut the bloke some slack, perhaps?

I think he was a total fecking disaster for us. He declared his intention of playing "out of possession" football, didn't sign the players to carry it off, couldn't motivate the players he had to carry on with it. His whole scheme was based on stats and wasn't backed up by even a shred of flexibility, football common-sense or motivation. He turned on the players far too readily, ran out of ideas and left us with an unbalanced squad of broken and feeble-spirited men. I'm not defending the players, the senior ones were spineless at best and actively disruptive at worst, but Ismael was responsible for making it work. xG stats don't put the ball in the net or points on the board.

Fair amount of revisionism in this post Chesh.

The board failed to deliver the players or the squad overhaul that he wanted, outside of Mowatt, and when we did deliver Dike he got injured. He was promised several windows and a long term rebuild and then wasnt backed to even start the process. 

Ismael then was probably overly flexible with his tactics… when he should have doubled down on his methods, increased the intensity of the press he tried to introduce possession and cave into the players’ needs.

The whole sorry mess was far more than Val’s fault, he should never have been appointed, but given we did, we should have bloody backed the project.

Fair comment. Fact is I didn't like and don't like Val's idea of football. It's a ball playing game, so if your main plan is what to do without the ball you're missing out on the artistry and entertainment. Pulis never seemed to coach attacking play so his success was limited to 1-0 wins. Val wanted his players to scramble the ball into the net somehow but they couldn't do it. Either way, it's not what I want to see.

And I guess this is the difference. I am a big fan of what Val wanted to do… I like high intensity, super fit, high pressing, aggressive football. I love the way the Red Bull franchise have built their footballing model, and think for a club of our means, it gives us the best chance of reestablishing itself in the Prem without significant backing. You only have to look at how well Leeds did with a group of Championship players in Bielsa’s first season (given most their big money signings barely featured)

For me, fitness, defensive organisation, intensity cost nothing, and Val had all this in spades, but he didn’t have the group of players to do it. I realise he was underperforming, but those that appointed him should have known what they were getting, but we were naive.

I would much rather have Val in the dugout than Bruce, and I’d have rather given him another window to continue the project, with the hope that the longer term gain would outweigh the short term negative, but we will never know. 

FWIW I think he will do much better out of his time here than we will.
Reply
#19
(07-24-2022, 09:51 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Let it go. He's moved on. We've moved on. So should our fans.

Are you stuck on repeat  Big Grin
Reply
#20
(07-25-2022, 06:12 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-24-2022, 09:51 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Let it go. He's moved on. We've moved on. So should our fans.

Are you stuck on repeat  Big Grin

I've hit the same repeat button as many of our fans who keep harking on about players and/or managers who are no longer with us.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)