This 'ere Net Zero
#1
Trigger Warning: This post includes RESEARCH and FACTS!

During the Tory party leadership shenanigans, some posters decried the lack of (or seeming lack of) concern about the environment from some candidates.  Thought I’d look at some stats on Greenhouse Gas emissions by various states in the world.  

Top Five emitters for financial liability
(don’t know how that is determined but beloved experts say it)
USA, China, Russia India and Brazil alone have caused €6 Trillion in climate damage on the rest of the world. The top 10 global emitters caused more than two-thirds of losses worldwide. 
www.msn.com/en-gb/money/other/these-5-countries-alone-inflicted-nearly-6-trillion-in-climate-damage-on-the-rest-of-the-world/ar-AAZx10J?ocid=msedgdhp&pc=U531&cvid=5e952f4b8d5341a59a1d74cca368e0bc

Top 10 for quantity of greenhouse gas emitters  (since 1990)
China
The U.S.
Russia
India
Indonesia
Japan
Germany
Brazil       (and its government is encouraging the deforestation of the rain forest   (the Earth’s lungs)
Canada
U.K.          
  www.newsweek.com/worst-countries-2021-greenhouse-gas-emissions-climate-cop26-china-united-states-1645399
China has more than tripled its emissions since 1990. And still increasing them.
Russia increased by 20%
Japan virtually no reduction.
USA reduced by 10%
The UK has almost halved its emissions since 1990!
 
The U.K. is 52nd in emissions per capita.  18th in quantity.
At least 13 countries in the E.U. are above the U.K. in quantity.
The UK emits 3% of the world’s total greenhouse gas emissions per year and it’s falling.
Deforestation of the  rainforest in Brazil has surged to its highest level since 2008.
4,281 sqr miles of rainforest were destroyed between August 2019 to July 2020, a 9.5% increase from the previous year.
A vital carbon store, that slows down the pace of global warming, and producer of 40% of the world’s oxygen. Scientists say it is being lost at an accelerated rate since president Bolsonaro took office in 2019.
The Brazilian president has actively encouraged agriculture and mining activities in the forest.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-55130304

So, I ask what difference will it make if the UK achieves Net Zero sooner? Will it just make our industries even more uncompetitive and simply export jobs?  The question isn’t that simple of course, as we already do export our carbon footprint through our retail habits.
So, I assume all those concerned posters do not have smart phones and tablets, don’t buy cheap tee shirts or purchase trainers made in China or Indonesia. Do not drive cars built in China, Korea or Japan or eat exotic fruits and spices all of which are transported here by the most oil guzzling and polluting form of transport out, Container ships. I assume everyone has their order in for an EV. A Nissan Leaf of course as they are made in England. And do not eat beef burgers or the vegans, soy products!

And. Obviously everyone is happy to pay the extra 8% green levy on their power bills.
So, is it as easy and the argument as simple to say the U.K. should rush to Net Zero despite what the rest of the world does? It’s certainly easy to sit and tap a keyboard to write ‘that nasty person wants to slow down our headlong rush to Net Zero’. It’s not that easy to accept the consequences of rushing to being carbon neutral on the people or industry.  

I believe the U.K. is already, more than, pulling its weight in the fight against climate change.
Reply
#2
We should stop and let the other catch up a bit
Reply
#3
(07-24-2022, 06:48 AM)SophLad Wrote: We should stop and let the other catch up a bit

Big Grin
Reply
#4
(07-24-2022, 06:48 AM)SophLad Wrote: We should stop and let the other catch up a bit

Perhaps that boat has sailed.

Maybe the laddies were right .

One thing I will predict, if this thread has legs it will move to the politics board.
Reply
#5
We don’t have any influence or control over any other country on the planet, we can only make decisions about the UK. We also know that the world needs to do this, so the simple answer to your question is because we should. If the rest of the world sees this as us leading the way and decides to follow us then that is good, if they don’t then at least we tried to do our bit.

One thing is certain, if every country says ‘x are worse than us, why should we bother’, then we’ll never get anywhere.
Reply
#6
(07-24-2022, 08:01 AM)baggy1 Wrote: We don’t have any influence or control over any other country on the planet, we can only make decisions about the UK. We also know that the world needs to do this, so the simple answer to your question is because we should. If the rest of the world sees this as us leading the way and decides to follow us then that is good, if they don’t then at least we tried to do our bit.

One thing is certain, if every country says ‘x are worse than us, why should we bother’, then we’ll never get anywhere.

Why do you think the knuckledraggers are trotting out that line? Because they don't want to fix anything, they want to kick the can down the road.
Reply
#7
An excellent summary. In fact while the dogooders try to take the moral high ground they are in fact living in a fantasy world. They are trying to show they have the power when in reality they simply don't. IMO all efforts should be directed into making air scrubbers that clean the atmosphere. The climate change activists IMO need to have a reality check. They need to focus on what we can influence and what we can't. The ban on petrol - diesel cars. EVs and anything the UK does will make absolutely no difference to Climate change. A world unlimited budget to manufacture atmosphere scrubbers should be an industry that achieve something.
Reply
#8
(07-24-2022, 08:34 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: An excellent summary. In fact while the dogooders try to take the moral high ground they are in fact living in a fantasy world. They are trying to show they have the power when in reality they simply don't. IMO all efforts should be directed into making air scrubbers that clean atmosphere. The climate change activists IMO need to have a reality check. They need to focus on what we can influence and what we can't. The ban on petrol - diesel cars. EVs and anything the UK does will make absolutely no difference to Climate change. A world unlimited budget to manufacture atmosphere scrubbers should be an industry that achieve something.

What is an atmosphere scrubber and where do you get one?
Reply
#9
Back of Rackhams, I think.
Reply
#10
(07-24-2022, 08:39 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Back of Rackhams, I think.

Wow I didn't think you remembered that far back. ARF
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: