Accounts
(07-05-2022, 12:54 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: They don’t “make loans to themselves”.  The directors make the loans.  They were reckless and in breach of their fiduciary duty owed by them to the company, for which they will be accountable to the minority shareholders.
A Fidicuary Duty works in two ways, Prag, both for and against the Director.

Enforcement is difficult
[/quote]

personally I have no idea how any of this works, other than to keep rich feckers rich... Could this duty and failure to carry it out be why they sacked the board members recently? Nice and tidy excuse and sneakily hidden under us being shyte last year? Or is that too simple?
Reply
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?
Reply
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.
Reply
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(07-06-2022, 06:48 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.

Big Grin
Reply
(07-06-2022, 06:48 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.


Oh dear.  

It looks like a dividend will be paid to enable the loan to be “repaid”.   So effectively, writing off the loan, but technically not, as there’s nothing illegal in declaring a dividend. But this goes against Lai wanting the club to be self sufficient, if he is taking money out of the club. 

I feared he’d declare a dividend to repay the JP loan.  Now it looks as though he will be doing just that to repay the loan to one of his other companies. 

For those who don’t understand accounting….. the club will be £5m worse off as a result.  For example purposes , let’s say in March 2021 the club club had £25m in it’s bank account. The club then lent £5m to one of Lai’s other companies and so the club’s bank balance decreased by £5m to £20m

If a £5m dividend is paid, then the bank balance drops again by £5m to £15m and then increases by £5m when the loan is repaid taking it back to £20m.

So, in the balance sheet, the bank balance has dropped by £5m (£25m to £20m) and the loan outstanding in the balance sheet cleared. But the club now has £20m in the bank compared to £25m in March 2021.  

https://www.westbromnews.co.uk/2022/07/0...de-public/
Reply
(07-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-06-2022, 06:48 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.


Oh dear.  

It looks like a dividend will be paid to enable the loan to be “repaid”.   So effectively, writing off the loan, but technically not, as there’s nothing illegal in declaring a dividend. But this goes against Lai wanting the club to be self sufficient, if he is taking money out of the club. 

I feared he’d declare a dividend to repay the JP loan.  Now it looks as though he will be doing just that to repay the loan to one of his other companies. 

For those who don’t understand accounting….. the club will be £5m worse off as a result.  For example purposes , let’s say in March 2021 the club club had £25m in it’s bank account. The club then lent £5m to one of Lai’s other companies and so the club’s bank balance decreased by £5m to £20m

If a £5m dividend is paid, then the bank balance drops again by £5m to £15m and then increases by £5m when the loan is repaid taking it back to £20m.

So, in the balance sheet, the bank balance has dropped by £5m (£25m to £20m) and the loan outstanding in the balance sheet cleared. But the club now has £20m in the bank compared to £25m in March 2021.  

https://www.westbromnews.co.uk/2022/07/0...de-public/

Must admit I always thought the value of the dividend that could be paid was always based on profit... I guess not though?
Reply
(07-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Oh dear.  

It looks like a dividend will be paid to enable the loan to be “repaid”.   So effectively, writing off the loan, but technically not, as there’s nothing illegal in declaring a dividend. But this goes against Lai wanting the club to be self sufficient, if he is taking money out of the club. 

I feared he’d declare a dividend to repay the JP loan.  Now it looks as though he will be doing just that to repay the loan to one of his other companies. 

For those who don’t understand accounting….. the club will be £5m worse off as a result.  For example purposes , let’s say in March 2021 the club club had £25m in it’s bank account. The club then lent £5m to one of Lai’s other companies and so the club’s bank balance decreased by £5m to £20m

If a £5m dividend is paid, then the bank balance drops again by £5m to £15m and then increases by £5m when the loan is repaid taking it back to £20m.

So, in the balance sheet, the bank balance has dropped by £5m (£25m to £20m) and the loan outstanding in the balance sheet cleared. But the club now has £20m in the bank compared to £25m in March 2021.  

https://www.westbromnews.co.uk/2022/07/0...de-public/

How depressing (not your analysis, FF, which I'm sure will help a few understand).

"...it will receive no funding from its shareholders and the attendance of crowds at the stadium and relevant commercial income will remain at the same level as 2021/22. Furthermore, the base forecasts also include a potential dividend pay-out to settle a £5m receivable provided to related party Wisdom Smart Corporation Limited in March 2021, and futher settlement of a £2m loan borrowed by West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited from Warmfront Holdings Limited in September 2021 and loaned to a related party, since the group are not budgeteding to receive any of the £7m funds in the period to the end of next season. The Board will not commit the club to further liabililites in the upcoming transfer windows without the source of funding for such liabilities being confirmed."
Reply
(07-09-2022, 09:05 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(07-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-06-2022, 06:48 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.


Oh dear.  

It looks like a dividend will be paid to enable the loan to be “repaid”.   So effectively, writing off the loan, but technically not, as there’s nothing illegal in declaring a dividend. But this goes against Lai wanting the club to be self sufficient, if he is taking money out of the club. 

I feared he’d declare a dividend to repay the JP loan.  Now it looks as though he will be doing just that to repay the loan to one of his other companies. 

For those who don’t understand accounting….. the club will be £5m worse off as a result.  For example purposes , let’s say in March 2021 the club club had £25m in it’s bank account. The club then lent £5m to one of Lai’s other companies and so the club’s bank balance decreased by £5m to £20m

If a £5m dividend is paid, then the bank balance drops again by £5m to £15m and then increases by £5m when the loan is repaid taking it back to £20m.

So, in the balance sheet, the bank balance has dropped by £5m (£25m to £20m) and the loan outstanding in the balance sheet cleared. But the club now has £20m in the bank compared to £25m in March 2021.  

https://www.westbromnews.co.uk/2022/07/0...de-public/

Must admit I always thought the value of the dividend that could be paid was always based on profit... I guess not though?

That would be partnerships/LLP's?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(07-09-2022, 08:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-06-2022, 06:48 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?  

Maybe false promises were made that should the loan be made, which in turn keeps his other company in business, that said business would invest in the club, once COVID cash flow issues have been resolved. 

That's the only tenious reason I can think of? 

I can see the potential benefit, if we had an honest owner who has a history of investing funds. But we don't, so I can't! I'm just trying to find some sort of logic, here.

(07-06-2022, 06:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 10:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-05-2022, 11:14 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I'm not sure the fiduciary duties argument will stand up.  If this decision was taken not to spend the money, then provided he's paying interest above what could have been earned elsewhere I don't see how it could create a fiduciary problem.

The EFL should have rules to stop this kind of thing though.

I disagree.  Every decision made by a board of directors should be made in the best interests of the company. What possible benefit was it to the company for it to tie up cash with a loan at low interest to Lai?  Why make it?    And to compound the issue, when Lai failed to repay the loan they lent him some more, which was even riskier.  And unsecured too - when the risk of repayment of the loan had risen. By advancing the money to Lai which could instead have been used to invest in the squad, the loan deprived the company of the ability to strengthen the squad.  So how did making this loan possibly enable the directors to demonstrate that they were acting in the best interests of the company by agreeing to make it?

If the post on twitter is correct in that a dividend will be paid to enable Lai to repay the loan, then questions need to be asked.

If the post in question was the one from Lepowski, then it's worth very little. The guy is a whopper.


Oh dear.  

It looks like a dividend will be paid to enable the loan to be “repaid”.   So effectively, writing off the loan, but technically not, as there’s nothing illegal in declaring a dividend. But this goes against Lai wanting the club to be self sufficient, if he is taking money out of the club. 

I feared he’d declare a dividend to repay the JP loan.  Now it looks as though he will be doing just that to repay the loan to one of his other companies. 

For those who don’t understand accounting….. the club will be £5m worse off as a result.  For example purposes , let’s say in March 2021 the club club had £25m in it’s bank account. The club then lent £5m to one of Lai’s other companies and so the club’s bank balance decreased by £5m to £20m

If a £5m dividend is paid, then the bank balance drops again by £5m to £15m and then increases by £5m when the loan is repaid taking it back to £20m.

So, in the balance sheet, the bank balance has dropped by £5m (£25m to £20m) and the loan outstanding in the balance sheet cleared. But the club now has £20m in the bank compared to £25m in March 2021.  

https://www.westbromnews.co.uk/2022/07/0...de-public/

'Lai' reportedly paid £175m-£200m for the Club (Bravo!) when he/they were flush and has borrowed £5m following the most difficult period in world history since the 2nd world war. 

Nothing to see here.....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: