A manager needs time
#11
(04-06-2019, 04:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 03:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: in his first managerial position to learn the ropes, to learn what works and what doesn't, to make mistakes and find methods of correcting them......followed by an attempt to not repeat them.

This is not the time. Shan has done fantastically to stop the rot and maybe he will become a fantastic manager, but this is not the time for him to learn. 

I said at the time sacking Moore was absolutely ridiculous in the circumstances, those circumstances included capabilities of the personnel behind the scenes trying to appoint a new manager; and that at the time if someone didn't hit the ground running we could slide down the table. Luckily Jimmy Shan put us in a position where we probably don't have to worry about the latter. 

Anyone coming in now is in a fantastic position to settle in before the playoffs. All is not lost at this point but we're doing our absolute best to screw things up as much as possible. I said sacking Big Dave would reduce our chances of promotion, and so far there's nothing to indicate I was wrong. However a swift good appointment could still save us.

Given our chance of promotion with Big Dave was zero, I’m not sure how we’ve made it worse.

Just because we’ve lost 1 game after winning 3 doesn’t mean getting rid of Moore was the wrong move, it wasn’t. The mistake is the ongoing complacency of our board in thinking our squad is either good enough or hungry enough for a return to the top flight regardless of who is in charge. 

We have some excellent players capable of playing at a higher level, but we have little or no hunger, desire or passion amongst them, and unfortunately the attitude from the top of our club does little to inspire or enforce a change.

I can’t remember the last time we played well, or looked like we wanted to even win a game.

That last sentence is so prescient.  You can count the good performances in the last 2 years on one hand. This group have had such an easy ride
Reply
#12
(04-06-2019, 05:10 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 03:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: in his first managerial position to learn the ropes, to learn what works and what doesn't, to make mistakes and find methods of correcting them......followed by an attempt to not repeat them.

This is not the time. Shan has done fantastically to stop the rot and maybe he will become a fantastic manager, but this is not the time for him to learn. 

I said at the time sacking Moore was absolutely ridiculous in the circumstances, those circumstances included capabilities of the personnel behind the scenes trying to appoint a new manager; and that at the time if someone didn't hit the ground running we could slide down the table. Luckily Jimmy Shan put us in a position where we probably don't have to worry about the latter. 

Anyone coming in now is in a fantastic position to settle in before the playoffs. All is not lost at this point but we're doing our absolute best to screw things up as much as possible. I said sacking Big Dave would reduce our chances of promotion, and so far there's nothing to indicate I was wrong. However a swift good appointment could still save us.

Given our chance of promotion with Big Dave was zero, I’m not sure how we’ve made it worse.

Just because we’ve lost 1 game after winning 3 doesn’t mean getting rid of Moore was the wrong move, it wasn’t. The mistake is the ongoing complacency of our board in thinking our squad is either good enough or hungry enough for a return to the top flight regardless of who is in charge. 

We have some excellent players capable of playing at a higher level, but we have little or no hunger, desire or passion amongst them, and unfortunately the attitude from the top of our club does little to inspire or enforce a change.

I can’t remember the last time we played well, or looked like we wanted to even win a game.

That last sentence is so prescient.  You can count the good performances in the last 2 years on one hand. This group have had such an easy ride

Spot on Manc and SW4.

We very rarely convince even winning by 2 or 3 goals. Whole squad needs a total rebuild. More youth, more energy, more drive and more pace needed in every position.
Reply
#13
(04-06-2019, 05:10 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 03:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: in his first managerial position to learn the ropes, to learn what works and what doesn't, to make mistakes and find methods of correcting them......followed by an attempt to not repeat them.

This is not the time. Shan has done fantastically to stop the rot and maybe he will become a fantastic manager, but this is not the time for him to learn. 

I said at the time sacking Moore was absolutely ridiculous in the circumstances, those circumstances included capabilities of the personnel behind the scenes trying to appoint a new manager; and that at the time if someone didn't hit the ground running we could slide down the table. Luckily Jimmy Shan put us in a position where we probably don't have to worry about the latter. 

Anyone coming in now is in a fantastic position to settle in before the playoffs. All is not lost at this point but we're doing our absolute best to screw things up as much as possible. I said sacking Big Dave would reduce our chances of promotion, and so far there's nothing to indicate I was wrong. However a swift good appointment could still save us.

Given our chance of promotion with Big Dave was zero, I’m not sure how we’ve made it worse.

Just because we’ve lost 1 game after winning 3 doesn’t mean getting rid of Moore was the wrong move, it wasn’t. The mistake is the ongoing complacency of our board in thinking our squad is either good enough or hungry enough for a return to the top flight regardless of who is in charge. 

We have some excellent players capable of playing at a higher level, but we have little or no hunger, desire or passion amongst them, and unfortunately the attitude from the top of our club does little to inspire or enforce a change.

I can’t remember the last time we played well, or looked like we wanted to even win a game.

That last sentence is so prescient.  You can count the good performances in the last 2 years on one hand. This group have had such an easy ride

Certainly had a easy ride today. The never fancied from kick off and our quality only showed for 15 min spell just before thief first goal ironically.
Millwall showed fantastic drive and desire along with decent forward passing and we were lucky to come away only losing by two.
Just not good enough and really rudderless as a club.
Reply
#14
If anybody thought that this core group of players who underperformed so spectacularly and got us relagated last season was suddenly going to stroll this division really needs to take their head for a wobble. We WERE a one man team earlier this season with Barnes we attacked at pace and scored goals for fun since he left we have looked like what we are at this moment in time an average midtable chump team.
Reply
#15
(04-06-2019, 05:50 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: If anybody thought that this core group of players who underperformed so spectacularly and got us relagated last season was suddenly going to stroll this division really needs to take their head for a wobble. We WERE a one man team earlier this season with Barnes we attacked at pace and scored goals for fun since he left we have looked like what we are at this moment in time an average midtable chump team.

Jezza and Jenkins will love that last bit !  
It’s where, now the money has been hollowed out, they feel most comfortable with - little expectation or ambition but making a bit of cash from the daft fans who turn up regardless.
Echoing the Nineties?
Reply
#16
(04-06-2019, 04:40 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:25 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:22 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:17 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 04:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Given our chance of promotion with Big Dave was zero, I’m not sure how we’ve made it worse.

Absolute bollocks

I mean the form and performances building up to the Ipswich game really did look like a side that was heading up.....

Yeah those two games before the Ipswich one are a perfect representation of everything that's happened this season, let's just conveniently ignore the games before then. 

Of course a team in 4th that have beaten literally every other one of the top 6 with Moore in charge have ZERO chance of promotion with Moore in charge.

Zero......fucking hell......

Words fail me

Basically we should get absolutely anyone in because it can't be less than the "Zero chance" we had under Moore. It's a similar logic to following up Pulis with Pardew. How can you not see this is complete and utter bollocks!?

I agree Sliced.

I don't necessarily believe we would go up under Darren Moore, but I don't think our chances were enhanced by his sacking , And given the timing of the dismissal and where we were in the league at that time, it made no sense.

If a change needed to be made, and i'm far from convinced it did, the time to do it was at the end of the season.

I haven’t said I believe our chances were enhanced, I don’t believe they were made worse... because they weren’t.

Moore demonstrated he didn’t have the tactical nous or the strength to get us promoted. Lovely bloke, but he was never going to promote us.
Reply
#17
(04-06-2019, 06:27 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 05:50 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: If anybody thought that this core group of players who underperformed so spectacularly and got us relagated last season was suddenly going to stroll this division really needs to take their head for a wobble. We WERE a one man team earlier this season with Barnes we attacked at pace and scored goals for fun since he left we have looked like what we are at this moment in time an average midtable chump team.

Jezza and Jenkins will love that last bit !  
It’s where, now the money has been hollowed out, they feel most comfortable with - little expectation or ambition but making a bit of cash from the daft fans who turn up regardless.
Echoing the Nineties?

Lack of ambition and unwillingness to invest properly alas is in the Albion Dna, I was brought up on that sublime 78/79 side and imvho with the right investment and a modicome of ambition that side could have improved and we could have won trophies and built a long term density, instead they saw £ signs when utd offered £1.5mill for Robbo then refused to spend it on the team and defaulted to skin flint mode appointed a cheap option in Saunders then the dark years descended very quickly after that, I really hope history is not about to repeat itself. The only man who has showed anything like the ambition to take us forward was Thompson but he was never able to afford to plow millions in.
Reply
#18
(04-06-2019, 03:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: in his first managerial position to learn the ropes, to learn what works and what doesn't, to make mistakes and find methods of correcting them......followed by an attempt to not repeat them.

This is not the time. Shan has done fantastically to stop the rot and maybe he will become a fantastic manager, but this is not the time for him to learn. 

I said at the time sacking Moore was absolutely ridiculous in the circumstances, those circumstances included capabilities of the personnel behind the scenes trying to appoint a new manager; and that at the time if someone didn't hit the ground running we could slide down the table. Luckily Jimmy Shan put us in a position where we probably don't have to worry about the latter. 

Anyone coming in now is in a fantastic position to settle in before the playoffs. All is not lost at this point but we're doing our absolute best to screw things up as much as possible. I said sacking Big Dave would reduce our chances of promotion, and so far there's nothing to indicate I was wrong. However a swift good appointment could still save us.

A new manager does not learn the ropes in the premier league or a championship promotion fight, they learn it in the lower leagues where there's little at stake.  Yet again our Board have been left wanting. 

There were concerns about Moore in October so any Technical Director worth his salt should have a new man lined up in the event. Dowling = clueless.
Reply
#19
(04-06-2019, 08:13 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-06-2019, 03:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: in his first managerial position to learn the ropes, to learn what works and what doesn't, to make mistakes and find methods of correcting them......followed by an attempt to not repeat them.

This is not the time. Shan has done fantastically to stop the rot and maybe he will become a fantastic manager, but this is not the time for him to learn. 

I said at the time sacking Moore was absolutely ridiculous in the circumstances, those circumstances included capabilities of the personnel behind the scenes trying to appoint a new manager; and that at the time if someone didn't hit the ground running we could slide down the table. Luckily Jimmy Shan put us in a position where we probably don't have to worry about the latter. 

Anyone coming in now is in a fantastic position to settle in before the playoffs. All is not lost at this point but we're doing our absolute best to screw things up as much as possible. I said sacking Big Dave would reduce our chances of promotion, and so far there's nothing to indicate I was wrong. However a swift good appointment could still save us.

A new manager does not learn the ropes in the premier league or a championship promotion fight, they learn it in the lower leagues where there's little at stake.  Yet again our Board have been left wanting. 

There were concerns about Moore in October so any Technical Director worth his salt should have a new man lined up in the event. Dowling = clueless.
+1  With repetitive errors Darren was putting is head in the noose and nobody in the management team did a thing to help.
They just sat back watched and waited. Dowling is a thief - he has taken money and signed nobody. No wonder Jenkins
appointed him. The people running our club don't care about anything related to football - it's just a financial game to them.
Reply
#20
(04-06-2019, 07:21 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I haven’t said I believe our chances were enhanced, I don’t believe they were made worse... because they weren’t.

Moore demonstrated he didn’t have the tactical nous or the strength to get us promoted. Lovely bloke, but he was never going to promote us.

Cracking argument. Water tight. 

So you think when we were sat in 4th under the same manager all season that got us to 4th, and with that manager that beat at some point every one of the current top 6 our chances of promotion was zero? And now the chance of promotion is still zero?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)