Danny Rose Nights Out
#21
(04-05-2019, 07:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Quite a few posters seem to have missed the point Rose was making, by concentrating on a throw away remark.

Let's be straight about this when Rose compares the financial punishment that countries have received for fans racism with what he might spend on a night out, he is not being literal, he is voicing an opinion that these punishments have traditionally been very lenient and is using exaggeration as a technique to demonstrate.

I really doubt at the time he made the comment he was making a literal comparison between the cost of a night out for a professional footballer and the fines imposed on countries for the racism of their fans.

That this is what people wanted to highlight from the comments Rose made is a bit sad to be honest.

This exactly. It's unfortunate but it seems to be the case that every time a footballer (of whatever colour) expresses a distain for the sport he is playing, fans seem to be unable to deal with it. Rose seems more irritated with the politics of football than the game itself and I have no doubt he is absolutely right. If the authorities were serious about tackling this issue, they'd do more. As a middle aged white man, I have no right to proclaim any knowledge of this whatsoever, but I imagine if you were abused again and again and perceived nothing was being done to tackle the root cause, then you'd be pissed off too. 

I also think to say the black footballers who played for us in the 1970s were "classy" because of their silence is to show ignorance of context. There was little to no platform for players of the likes of Regis, Batson or Cunningham to air their concerns. Regis was clearly devastated by the reaction he received from the terraces and became determined to work harder to prove the racists wrong. That's not to say he wouldn't have spoken out at the time had he felt comfortable doing so - I'm sure Batson would be more much vocal about his treatment in today's environment than he was in the 1970s/80s.

It's also fruitless trying to relate Rose's situation to someone less privileged in terms of their income. It's like berating kids for not eating food because there are starving people elsewhere in the world. It doesn't register and the inability to relate one's own situation to someone else's does not mean a viewpoint is invalid. Rose feels he works in a world that does not take racism seriously and pays lip service to it. What he does or doesn't earn is irrelevant in this context. The fact that some people feel they are able to determine what Rose should or shouldn't be thinking simply demonstrates how far white privilege extends.
Reply
#22
(04-05-2019, 08:01 PM)pickrollflickgoal Wrote: I couldn't give a toss how much he spends on a night out but like a few have said on here that if he can't wait to see the back of football why doesn't he just fuck off? He doesn't need money, but he wants more money to feather his already heavily feathered nest.

You could argue its tougher to leave a job paying do much. The wage is irrelevant the abuse unacceptable.
Reply
#23
(04-05-2019, 08:05 PM)Cornflake Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 08:01 PM)pickrollflickgoal Wrote: I couldn't give a toss how much he spends on a night out but like a few have said on here that if he can't wait to see the back of football why doesn't he just fuck off? He doesn't need money, but he wants more money to feather his already heavily feathered nest.

You could argue its tougher to leave a job paying do much. The wage is irrelevant the abuse unacceptable.

I quite agree with you for the most part. But coming out with that he couldn't wait to see the back of football only to say he's probably prepared to play for another 6 years I find a bit silly.
Reply
#24
I'm assuming, correct me if I'm wrong, that he's not very frugal. I've never seen him on the Underground nor in any of the Wetherspoons around the smoke.
Reply
#25
He's made it obvious he still loves playing football but feels utterly let down by the game itself ie the still inherent streak of racism prevalent in many football stadiums. His argument may not be the most articulate and coherent, but then he is a footballer not a journalist. If you see a world full of cunts your salary is irrelevant, no matter how much you earn, they are still cunts.
Reply
#26
(04-05-2019, 07:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Quite a few posters seem to have missed the point Rose was making, by concentrating on a throw away remark.

Let's be straight about this when Rose compares the financial punishment that countries have received for fans racism with what he might spend on a night out, he is not being literal, he is voicing an opinion that these punishments have traditionally been very lenient and is using exaggeration as a technique to demonstrate.

I really doubt at the time he made the comment he was making a literal comparison between the cost of a night out for a professional footballer and the fines imposed on countries for the racism of their fans.

That this is what people wanted to highlight from the comments Rose made is a bit sad to be honest.
+1 exactly what I was wanting to say. He didn't mean literally he was just using an example which he wasn't really thinking would be taken word for word.And there's loads of players who don't particularly enjoy the endless flying around the world and pressures of that profession.
Reply
#27
(04-05-2019, 06:13 PM)Atomic Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 04:16 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 04:06 PM)MGalea Wrote: Rose is obviously very angry and his comment about money is not very classy but given the context he can pretty much say whatever he wants.

Quite. The real outrage are the spineless authorities letting clubs/fans get away with disgusting racism instead of doing the correct thing and throwing them out of the tournament.

Rose could have wished death upon every single Montenegro fan and he still wouldn't be in the wrong here.

Absolutely outrageous and ridiculous comment, of course he would. Racism is a bigger crime than mass murder is it? Get a grip.

Racism is mainly about ignorance, murder isn't about ignorance it's a calculated act of ending someone's life, it's evil.

You don't understand that? 

Racism is wrong, no question, but some people make it seem like the biggest crime in the world. It isn't it's just very high in the public conscience, and rightly so, but things shouldn't be taken out of perspective.

Atomic I'm using hyperbole to make a point.

People seem to be more outraged by what Rose has said than the actions of moronic, racist fans. I'm saying even if Rose had said the most offensive thing you could imagine, it still doesn't outweigh the bad behaviour of the Montenegro fans and the spinlessness of UEFA.
Reply
#28
I agreed with what John Barnes said the other day; Rasicm in football will always exist, at some level, until it is addressed at social level.

I'm not sure fining a nation or excluding them from a competition, would actually solve anything.

If you're the sort of idiot to racially abuse a player, are you really bothered if your nation is excluded from a specific competition? I just don't understand the deterrent.

Danny Rose comes across as a cunt. Unintentional or not.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#29
(04-05-2019, 08:04 PM)steviedm Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 07:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Quite a few posters seem to have missed the point Rose was making, by concentrating on a throw away remark.

Let's be straight about this when Rose compares the financial punishment that countries have received for fans racism with what he might spend on a night out, he is not being literal, he is voicing an opinion that these punishments have traditionally been very lenient and is using exaggeration as a technique to demonstrate.

I really doubt at the time he made the comment he was making a literal comparison between the cost of a night out for a professional footballer and the fines imposed on countries for the racism of their fans.

That this is what people wanted to highlight from the comments Rose made is a bit sad to be honest.

This exactly. It's unfortunate but it seems to be the case that every time a footballer (of whatever colour) expresses a distain for the sport he is playing, fans seem to be unable to deal with it. Rose seems more irritated with the politics of football than the game itself and I have no doubt he is absolutely right. If the authorities were serious about tackling this issue, they'd do more. As a middle aged white man, I have no right to proclaim any knowledge of this whatsoever, but I imagine if you were abused again and again and perceived nothing was being done to tackle the root cause, then you'd be pissed off too. 

I also think to say the black footballers who played for us in the 1970s were "classy" because of their silence is to show ignorance of context. There was little to no platform for players of the likes of Regis, Batson or Cunningham to air their concerns. Regis was clearly devastated by the reaction he received from the terraces and became determined to work harder to prove the racists wrong. That's not to say he wouldn't have spoken out at the time had he felt comfortable doing so - I'm sure Batson would be more much vocal about his treatment in today's environment than he was in the 1970s/80s.

It's also fruitless trying to relate Rose's situation to someone less privileged in terms of their income. It's like berating kids for not eating food because there are starving people elsewhere in the world. It doesn't register and the inability to relate one's own situation to someone else's does not mean a viewpoint is invalid. Rose feels he works in a world that does not take racism seriously and pays lip service to it. What he does or doesn't earn is irrelevant in this context. The fact that some people feel they are able to determine what Rose should or shouldn't be thinking simply demonstrates how far white privilege extends.

Bang on. You and Shabb have absolutely nailed it
Reply
#30
(04-06-2019, 12:26 AM)Squid Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 06:13 PM)Atomic Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 04:16 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-05-2019, 04:06 PM)MGalea Wrote: Rose is obviously very angry and his comment about money is not very classy but given the context he can pretty much say whatever he wants.

Quite. The real outrage are the spineless authorities letting clubs/fans get away with disgusting racism instead of doing the correct thing and throwing them out of the tournament.

Rose could have wished death upon every single Montenegro fan and he still wouldn't be in the wrong here.

Absolutely outrageous and ridiculous comment, of course he would. Racism is a bigger crime than mass murder is it? Get a grip.

Racism is mainly about ignorance, murder isn't about ignorance it's a calculated act of ending someone's life, it's evil.

You don't understand that? 

Racism is wrong, no question, but some people make it seem like the biggest crime in the world. It isn't it's just very high in the public conscience, and rightly so, but things shouldn't be taken out of perspective.

Atomic I'm using hyperbole to make a point.

People seem to be more outraged by what Rose has said than the actions of moronic, racist fans. I'm saying even if Rose had said the most offensive thing you could imagine, it still doesn't outweigh the bad behaviour of the Montenegro fans and the spinlessness of UEFA.

Yes it does.

I understand Danny Rose's frustration but there is a correct way to deal with things. You only have to look at our own Cyrille Regis and Darren Moore for examples of how to behave responsibly. People like Rose making silly comments or sinking to equal or worse depths don't help the situation and as you can see from some peoples reactions on here it doesn't endear them to the public. 

I think John Barnes is right racism will always exist in football until it doesn't exist in society. When you have 7.5 billion people on a planet I don't think you can ever completely be rid of it, rather like any crime.

In England, at least, I think things are pretty good. You will always get the odd incident but racism (active racism at least), isn't a MAJOR problem. One of the problems is some people are always actively looking for it and try to create race issues - Darren Moore's sacking a case in point. One moment people are saying you shouldn't see the colour of someone's skin then the next minute when a black man is sacked from his position those same people soon see the colour of the skin and create a race issue. 

They / we can't have it both ways.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: