Johnstone…
#41
I know nowt about being a keeper, but his reluctance to get off his line and dominate at least the six yard box was a weakness. This contributes to the back four not being sure who is going to do what, and their combined lack of confidence in each other often showed up.  A couple of the misunderstandings were laughable and belonged on a parks pitch. 

Ray Clemence was world class at Liverpool because he had a great well organised team in front of him.  He went to Spurs and had a lot more work to do because the defence was less competent.  Personally I thought his faults were compensated for by a brilliant defence in front of him at Liverpool and exposed at Tottenham.

Gordon Banks was brilliant at Leicester.  He moved to Stoke and was still brilliant,  regardless of the defence in front of him. I watched him at Villa Park and he took every ball that came into the area  without breaking sweat.  He just knew where to be and at 6ft 1in he was the ideal size.   I think Tony Hateley was the target man prior to his move to Chelsea. 

One argument is that SJ is a great shot stopper.  The other is that if he got to the ball first he wouldn't need to stop the shot.  The other argument is that if you have a dodgy defence in front of you, you've got more shots to stop and even a crap keeper will stop some, and some of those saves will be brilliant.   So take your pick.  You'll all be right to an extent.
Reply
#42
(06-22-2022, 12:59 PM)Offside Wrote: I know nowt about being a keeper, but his reluctance to get off his line and dominate at least the six yard box was a weakness. This contributes to the back four not being sure who is going to do what, and their combined lack of confidence in each other often showed up.  A couple of the misunderstandings were laughable and belonged on a parks pitch. 

Ray Clemence was world class at Liverpool because he had a great well organised team in front of him.  He went to Spurs and had a lot more work to do because the defence was less competent.  Personally I thought his faults were compensated for by a brilliant defence in front of him at Liverpool and exposed at Tottenham.

Gordon Banks was brilliant at Leicester.  He moved to Stoke and was still brilliant,  regardless of the defence in front of him. I watched him at Villa Park and he took every ball that came into the area  without breaking sweat.  He just knew where to be and at 6ft 1in he was the ideal size.   I think Tony Hateley was the target man prior to his move to Chelsea. 

One argument is that SJ is a great shot stopper.  The other is that if he got to the ball first he wouldn't need to stop the shot.  The other argument is that if you have a dodgy defence in front of you, you've got more shots to stop and even a crap keeper will stop some, and some of those saves will be brilliant.   So take your pick.  You'll all be right to an extent.
That's a nice intelligent post and from a far higher place than those trying to pick holes in his character.

He is a very decent keeper, you don't get to the England squad easily, and he is certainly far better than we have at the club currently. A motivated Johnstone would be an asset to us.

Sadly now we have to find someone else to fill his gloves- as I said I would hope we have that man lined up. Button is a good stand-in and nothing more.
Reply
#43
Johnstone's behaviour at being dropped was horrendous and has rightly blotted his reputation with most Albion fans. Likewise pretending he was going to sign a new contract.

Up until then, I thought he was an excellent shot-stopper who would sometimes be given an unfair time by some fans, because he wasn't quite as good as our greatest ever goalkeeper.

An earlier poster mentioned Hegazi being not easy to play behind, I would swop Hegazi for any of our current CBs. In a heartbeat.
Reply
#44
(06-22-2022, 01:31 PM)Squid Wrote: Johnstone's behaviour at being dropped was horrendous and has rightly blotted his reputation with most Albion fans. Likewise pretending he was going to sign a new contract.

Up until then, I thought he was an excellent shot-stopper who would sometimes be given an unfair time by some fans, because he wasn't quite as good as our greatest ever goalkeeper.

An earlier poster mentioned Hegazi being not easy to play behind, I would swop Hegazi for any of our current CBs. In a heartbeat.

Likewise McAuley.
Reply
#45
Good job Bomber didn't show any love for his home town on 24 April 1976!
Reply
#46
(06-22-2022, 01:31 PM)Squid Wrote: Johnstone's behaviour at being dropped was horrendous and has rightly blotted his reputation with most Albion fans. Likewise pretending he was going to sign a new contract.

Up until then, I thought he was an excellent shot-stopper who would sometimes be given an unfair time by some fans, because he wasn't quite as good as our greatest ever goalkeeper.

An earlier poster mentioned Hegazi being not easy to play behind, I would swop Hegazi for any of our current CBs. In a heartbeat.

Hegazi was imo, very over rated.

Another who flattered to deceive quite often. Decent enough, and yeah, would probably get ahead of our current lot, but wasn't as good as some before him, Olsson, Gmac, Evans etc. Dawson was better than him imo.
Reply
#47
Hegazi may not have been as good as Evans, McAuley and Olsson but he is light years ahead of Bartley, Ajayi and Kipre.
Reply
#48
Better, but not by much imo.
Reply
#49
(06-22-2022, 04:39 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Better, but not by much imo.

Hegazi always tried, never hid, even when partnered with an utterly disinterested Evans. That puts him above Bartley and Ajayi for starters. I remember watching him in the Under 23s against Swansea and he put as much effort into it as he did a first-team match, as some child he nearly snapped in half found out.

Most of our defenders will have a mistake in them, that's why they are with us, but I'll forgive that if they always put the effort in.
Reply
#50
Hegazi is like Bobby Moore when compared to the donkey that is Bartley.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: