Johnstone…
#31
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:16 AM)wba13 Wrote: For Christ’s sake he’s gone, no matter what some of you think he got us to the premiership and was outstanding in the premiership. Also has yet to concede a goal for England after an outstanding debut. For me it’s good luck to him

This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.

It's fine to celebrate against your own team if it's the team you supported as a boy.

I've read some nonsense on this board in my time, but this is up there.
Reply
#32
(06-22-2022, 09:44 AM)Sliced Wrote: It's fine to celebrate against your own team if it's the team you supported as a boy.

I've read some nonsense on this board in my time, but this is up there.

Not sure I agree with that. He's 'supposed' to represent us - that's what he's paid for. It would be fine to not celebrate a goal against them, I suppose.

Whichever way, at best it comes across as undiplomatic - at worst it comes across as childish and crass.

If I was a kid, and he was my hero, I'd be somewhere between gutted and confused.

But, I'm an adult and so ultimately, I couldn't give a flying - which in fairness, is obviously how he thinks about us!

At least we all know where we stand Smile
Reply
#33
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:16 AM)wba13 Wrote: For Christ’s sake he’s gone, no matter what some of you think he got us to the premiership and was outstanding in the premiership. Also has yet to concede a goal for England after an outstanding debut. For me it’s good luck to him

This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.
As crap statements go, you have just won the crappiest of crap statements, in the history of crap statements. Well done.

Of course I celebrate when Albion win, but I'm not paid and employed by the opposition am I? 

You can continue your love in with Johnstone, if you like, that's fine, your opinion, but wind your neck in when calling my posts crap please.
Reply
#34
(06-22-2022, 10:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:16 AM)wba13 Wrote: For Christ’s sake he’s gone, no matter what some of you think he got us to the premiership and was outstanding in the premiership. Also has yet to concede a goal for England after an outstanding debut. For me it’s good luck to him

This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.
As crap statements go, you have just won the crappiest of crap statements, in the history of crap statements. Well done.

Of course I celebrate when Albion win, but I'm not paid and employed by the opposition am I? 

You can continue your love in with Johnstone, if you like, that's fine, your opinion, but wind your neck in when calling my posts crap please.

+1

He got a petulant red card and threw his toys out the pram when the stand in player played well and the coach decided to give him a run out knowing full well SJ had no intention of being here next season.

He should have been packed off to the reserves that day and told he hoped Southgate dropped by for an U23 game but he'd no longer be required at first team training or anywhere near the club on match days.
Reply
#35
Johnstone was alright.

A shaky start albeit in a team that decided it wasn't going to bother defending and he was stuck behind Bartley and Hegazi which wouldn't fill anyone with any confidence. Better under Bilic as the defence improved slightly. The main concern is that he lacked the ability to really command his area, which for me is the number one priority for any keeper, he was however a brilliant shot stopper and had his best season for us in the PL where he had lots of shots to save. Started last season well playing a new role in VI's system and looked good, probably the best we've been as a defensive unit in his four seasons here. Showed his petulant side and was rightly given the cold shoulder by the manager. I couldn't care less about what he did or didn't do on Twitter, it's not like he was throwing them in against us on purpose.

A lot of chatter on here about a keeper who was neither here nor there, not great, not awful and not half the player Ben Foster was. I wish him well, I'm sure he will do fine.
Reply
#36
(06-22-2022, 09:58 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 09:44 AM)Sliced Wrote: It's fine to celebrate against your own team if it's the team you supported as a boy.

I've read some nonsense on this board in my time, but this is up there.

Not sure I agree with that. He's 'supposed' to represent us - that's what he's paid for. It would be fine to not celebrate a goal against them, I suppose.

Whichever way, at best it comes across as undiplomatic - at worst it comes across as childish and crass.

If I was a kid, and he was my hero, I'd be somewhere between gutted and confused.

But, I'm an adult and so ultimately, I couldn't give a flying - which in fairness, is obviously how he thinks about us!

At least we all know where we stand  Smile

Sarcasm mon. I completely agree with you.

Under no circumstances should one of our players be celebrating a goal for the opposition.
Reply
#37
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:16 AM)wba13 Wrote: For Christ’s sake he’s gone, no matter what some of you think he got us to the premiership and was outstanding in the premiership. Also has yet to concede a goal for England after an outstanding debut. For me it’s good luck to him

This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.
So Stevie G celebrates when the Scousers knock the fifth in against The Seals?
Reply
#38
(06-22-2022, 10:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Johnstone was alright.

A shaky start albeit in a team that decided it wasn't going to bother defending and he was stuck behind Bartley and Hegazi which wouldn't fill anyone with any confidence. Better under Bilic as the defence improved slightly. The main concern is that he lacked the ability to really command his area, which for me is the number one priority for any keeper, he was however a brilliant shot stopper and had his best season for us in the PL where he had lots of shots to save. Started last season well playing a new role in VI's system and looked good, probably the best we've been as a defensive unit in his four seasons here. Showed his petulant side and was rightly given the cold shoulder by the manager. I couldn't care less about what he did or didn't do on Twitter, it's not like he was throwing them in against us on purpose.

A lot of chatter on here about a keeper who was neither here nor there, not great, not awful and not half the player Ben Foster was. I wish him well, I'm sure he will do fine.

I suppose when a player goes it's only right we appraise what he contributed. That's normal enough.

As I said there are some full of viciousness when more balanced posters are just a bit meh. 

The 'unforgivable' about pressing a like on Twitter with the Preston goal is the most one-eyed OTT statement in the whole chatter. He didn't bomb any homes, rape children, or even as much as let a goal in.

Johnstone was stupid to do it, clearly angry and demotivated, but no more- he played well enough when he got back in but the whole situation with him was mismanaged this past year. As has been said we should have let him go when we could have got a fee.

Anyhow, whilst Button looks capable, I would hope we can get better.

We have done well with keepers in the past 20 years or so, with Hoult and Foster probably the best we've had. Johnstone was very good, but not quite at that standard. 

I can't say I wish him well, but don't wish him bad either. He'll have to up his game though if he wants to go to Qatar. His inclusion in the squad would at least make things mildly interesting for us.
Reply
#39
(06-22-2022, 10:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:16 AM)wba13 Wrote: For Christ’s sake he’s gone, no matter what some of you think he got us to the premiership and was outstanding in the premiership. Also has yet to concede a goal for England after an outstanding debut. For me it’s good luck to him

This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.
As crap statements go, you have just won the crappiest of crap statements, in the history of crap statements. Well done.

Of course I celebrate when Albion win, but I'm not paid and employed by the opposition am I? 

You can continue your love in with Johnstone, if you like, that's fine, your opinion, but wind your neck in when calling my posts crap please.
Well my friend it takes one to know one, just because your hatred of a player who did us proud is stupid and pathetic,why bother saying anything. I have no love in for Johnstone but the hatred he has picked up from some of our own Pathetic fans is beyond crazy. I still say that if he hadn’t replaced fans fav Foster and came from Villa he would have been seen in a different light.  Angel
Reply
#40
(06-22-2022, 12:39 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 10:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:43 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-22-2022, 08:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-21-2022, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: This in bucketloads- there's some right vicious sneery feckers on here who seem to lose their marbles over players who they take a dislike to.

He was a cracking keeper a couple of years ago and the politics of the Val regime seemed to dispirit the club, with him notable. 

He never wore a demeanour likely to make him a firm fan favourite, but the vitriol towards him is pathetic.
Nothing more sneery or spiteful than celebrating a goal against your own team after refusing to take the bench for the game.
Being shit is fine, but some things are unforgiveable. Hope he fails miserably.
What a crap statement, so he celebrated a win for the team he has supported all his life. You celebrate when the Albion win.
His position is that he plays for us and it was his job. He wasn’t playing because of an idiot coach who had his favourite’s so he supported his team. Cannot see a problem with it.
As crap statements go, you have just won the crappiest of crap statements, in the history of crap statements. Well done.

Of course I celebrate when Albion win, but I'm not paid and employed by the opposition am I? 

You can continue your love in with Johnstone, if you like, that's fine, your opinion, but wind your neck in when calling my posts crap please.
Well my friend it takes one to know one, just because your hatred of a player who did us proud is stupid and pathetic,why bother saying anything. I have no love in for Johnstone but the hatred he has picked up from some of our own Pathetic fans is beyond crazy. I still say that if he hadn’t replaced fans fav Foster and came from Villa he would have been seen in a different light.  Angel
I don't hate him, my friend, I simple disagree with his actions towards the club, the fans and his team mates. And, IMO, it was nothing to do with this mythical "love" for Preston, it was a reaction to being dropped, plain and simple. I didn't even refer to Johnstone as "pathetic" "stupid" or "crap", I merely called him out on this instance. You made it a wider and more personal argument, for some bizarre reason.

It was you who attacked my post, in a disrespectful and personal way, which is ironic really as you seem to think ex-players should be defended and adored, regardless, yet life long fans are deserving of your spite and vitriol, when voicing a valid opinion on a public forum.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)