Posts: 863
Threads: 29
Joined: Mar 2022
Agree with everything Duffers has said in this thread.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
I think southgate gets out thought when it matters most and doesn't have the bollocks to go with attacking ability what we have ..just my onions.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Southgate has given youth a chance and I respect him for that.
He just needs some luck and we could win a tourny.
I cannot think of any stand out manager who could do a better job atm.
IMO the whole international football scene has lost it's sparkle over the last few years - maybe its me?
Remember Italy were struggling and then turned it completely around and now they are struggling again.
Fine lines I think its called.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(06-05-2022, 11:56 AM)Duffers Wrote: (06-05-2022, 11:44 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-05-2022, 11:38 AM)Duffers Wrote: (06-05-2022, 11:34 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (06-05-2022, 11:31 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: 02-06 was a shambles. How did we not win a tournament with the talent we had.
Because there were better teams!
Because they were a bunch of talented individuals and who didn’t like each other and were incapable of playing as a team.
That side, especially by 2006 when WAG culture took over, were largely hateful.
What on earth does this mean? You don't even know any of them! That's what I mean about not getting this idea with likeability. It's not just in terms of England either, I don't get it when people talk about Albion players being likeable.
As long as people perform on the pitch and I don't hear anything John Terry-esque about them, the rest is none of my business.
I’d say like ability is important, for example look at our current squad. The view around here largely that they are a bunch of workshy primadonnas who show little respect for the club or its fans. Does this not make it harder to get behind them? Mistakes are much less easily forgiven and patience is much thinner…
Whilst I don’t know any of the 2006 squad personally there were plenty of reports and stories about the squad and the players within. John Terry was already showing himself to be a nasty piece of work, Ashley Cole was in the middle of an ugly and protracted move between Arsenal and Chelsea, Rooney was embroiled in various scandals, players were falling out with each other privately… By all accounts that squad was a desperately unhappy one, too many players were only looking out for their own interests which tied in to the whole WAG side show. One player even brought his agent to a team meeting and stood up to ask why his client wasn’t taking corners.
Nobody would care about any of the above (John Terry's alleged racism aside), if the players were performing on the pitch.
Not one word was said about any of the Albion players temperaments when they were doing well in the first half of the Bilic season. Despite Rooney's scumbag behaviour towards Mrs Rooney, when he was getting a tune out of Derby, people were still saying they wouldn't mind him managing us.
The other issue is that half of the England team shenanigans nobody would know or care about were it not for the obsession of the tabloid press. Southgate and co have clearly done well keeping the tabloids at bay and thinking about the image they want the team to portray. That, I think is the fabled "likeability".
Posts: 8,089
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
06-06-2022, 09:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2022, 09:40 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Personally I quite like Gareth Southgate. I think he's more intelligent than your average 'football man', and this shows in his interviews. His comments and appraisal of not only the fixtures but several issues surrounding the game (be it BLM, fan behaviour, inclusivity etc.) are always measured and heartfelt, and as a figurehead there is no question that he has far more integrity than some of his predecessors.
A good mate of mine who works in press/PR has met him a few times, and says he's a smashing bloke. And I think perhaps his biggest success has been carrying those attributes over to a national side featuring for whom had somehow stopped seeming to matter to the same, usual, boring, underperforming characters. I think he's not only restored the pride in playing for England again, but succeeded in stripping away the peripheral disciplinary issues that seemed almost perennially to trip us up going into big tournaments. There is seldom much scandal to write about anymore.
I think where it starts to fall down is that we can be too conservative. That showed on Saturday, and it showed at times in the last tournament (despite how well we did). I don't think he can entirely be blamed, because for me the squad isn't actually as brilliant as many of our lot like to make out; and if your back line features the likes of Maguire, Stones, Mings etc. you're hardly likely to throw caution to the wind in exposing them when - regrettably at times - it does look like if Kane doesn't turn up neither does our attacking threat, beyond of course Sterling (who the game was crying out for on Saturday).
In terms of him managing the side I'm happy enough. He's brought us as close to honours as I can remember in my lifetime, and no matter how 'easy' the run to get there may have been that's still quite an achievement. I think it by far outweighs any negatives we saw during that tournament, and giving him the benefit of doubt this is a stupid week really to play internationals when so many players are burnt out after a long season. Whilst I don't necessarily subscribe to the 'Southgate haters' comments from our most faithful that naturally seek to exonerate him from any criticism whenever any comes - all football managers get it wrong sometimes - I think you also have to take that into context with the fact that the expectation levels for England have and will always be far higher than is reasonable. Be it because of the club adulation for the 'superstars' playing, the elongated periods between matches, general jingoism at large or whatever. International coaches have always had it. They always will. Not worth crying over when someone takes a pop at a coach you admire.
Back to Southgate, overall he's done a great job looking at the records. But his true measure as a manager can't really be judged until he's managed elsewhere, because like a clutch of a few other international managers his career is arse-about-face compared to how one achieved the job traditionally. I think there are question marks over in-game management, but again these are outweighed by his achievements which do show a clear willingness and aptitude in preparing for games. One or two of which in the summer he won by playing and sticking to the long game(s); in spite of how many of the armchair experts would have done otherwise. I think if he had just one or two more 'world class' players in the mix we wouldn't even be having this debate, but that's not something he can control.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(06-06-2022, 09:29 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Personally I quite like Gareth Southgate. I think he's more intelligent than your average 'football man', and this shows in his interviews. His comments and appraisal of not only the fixtures but several issues surrounding the game (be it BLM, fan behaviour, inclusivity etc.) are always measured and heartfelt, and as a figurehead there is no question that he has far more integrity than some of his predecessors.
A good mate of mine who works in press/PR has met him a few times, and says he's a smashing bloke. And I think perhaps his biggest success has been carrying those attributes over to a national side featuring for whom had somehow stopped seeming to matter to the same, usual, boring, underperforming characters. I think he's not only restored the pride in playing for England again, but succeeded in stripping away the peripheral disciplinary issues that seemed almost perennially to trip us up going into big tournaments. There is seldom much scandal to write about anymore.
I think where it starts to fall down is that we can be too conservative. That showed on Saturday, and it showed at times in the last tournament (despite how well we did). I don't think he can entirely be blamed, because for me the squad isn't actually as brilliant as many of our lot like to make out; and if your back line features the likes of Maguire, Stones, Mings etc. you're hardly likely to throw caution to the wind in exposing them when - regrettably at times - it does look like if Kane doesn't turn up neither does our attacking threat, beyond of course Sterling (who the game was crying out for on Saturday).
In terms of him managing the side I'm happy enough. He's brought us as close to honours as I can remember in my lifetime, and no matter how 'easy' the run to get there may have been that's still quite an achievement. I think it by far outweighs any negatives we saw during that tournament, and giving him the benefit of doubt this is a stupid week really to play internationals when so many players are burnt out after a long season. Whilst I don't necessarily subscribe to the 'Southgate haters' comments from our most faithful that naturally seek to exonerate him from any criticism whenever any comes - all football managers get it wrong sometimes - I think you also have to take that into context with the fact that the expectation levels for England have and will always be far higher than is reasonable. Be it because of the club adulation for the 'superstars' playing, the elongated periods between matches, general jingoism at large or whatever. International coaches have always had it. They always will. Not worth crying over when someone takes a pop at a coach you admire.
Back to Southgate, overall he's done a great job looking at the records. But his true measure as a manager can't really be judged until he's managed elsewhere, because like a clutch of a few other international managers his career is arse-about-face compared to how one achieved the job traditionally. I think there are question marks over in-game management, but again these are outweighed by his achievements which do show a clear willingness and aptitude in preparing for games. One or two of which in the summer he won by playing and sticking to the long game(s); in spite of how many of the armchair experts would have done otherwise. I think if he had just one or two more 'world class' players in the mix we wouldn't even be having this debate, but that's not something he can control.
An excellent post, some great points raised. Especially around Southgate’s “handbrake” for a long time our weakest area has been centre backs so it makes sense to have a system that protects them.
Interestingly as great as I think he’s been for England I don’t think he’d be cut out to be an elite club manager. Some are just better suited to the international game.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(06-05-2022, 06:32 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I think southgate gets out thought when it matters most and doesn't have the bollocks to go with attacking ability what we have ..just my onions.
I also think Southgate lacks the bollocks to drop the attack bomb with say 20 mins to go to win the game as it seems he would rather stay the course and see out the game in a calculated manner.
However, dropping the attack bomb in club football would different to international football as mentioned on the fred.
I'm not knocking Southgate, just a mere opinion.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(06-06-2022, 10:25 AM)Duffers Wrote: (06-06-2022, 09:29 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Personally I quite like Gareth Southgate. I think he's more intelligent than your average 'football man', and this shows in his interviews. His comments and appraisal of not only the fixtures but several issues surrounding the game (be it BLM, fan behaviour, inclusivity etc.) are always measured and heartfelt, and as a figurehead there is no question that he has far more integrity than some of his predecessors.
A good mate of mine who works in press/PR has met him a few times, and says he's a smashing bloke. And I think perhaps his biggest success has been carrying those attributes over to a national side featuring for whom had somehow stopped seeming to matter to the same, usual, boring, underperforming characters. I think he's not only restored the pride in playing for England again, but succeeded in stripping away the peripheral disciplinary issues that seemed almost perennially to trip us up going into big tournaments. There is seldom much scandal to write about anymore.
I think where it starts to fall down is that we can be too conservative. That showed on Saturday, and it showed at times in the last tournament (despite how well we did). I don't think he can entirely be blamed, because for me the squad isn't actually as brilliant as many of our lot like to make out; and if your back line features the likes of Maguire, Stones, Mings etc. you're hardly likely to throw caution to the wind in exposing them when - regrettably at times - it does look like if Kane doesn't turn up neither does our attacking threat, beyond of course Sterling (who the game was crying out for on Saturday).
In terms of him managing the side I'm happy enough. He's brought us as close to honours as I can remember in my lifetime, and no matter how 'easy' the run to get there may have been that's still quite an achievement. I think it by far outweighs any negatives we saw during that tournament, and giving him the benefit of doubt this is a stupid week really to play internationals when so many players are burnt out after a long season. Whilst I don't necessarily subscribe to the 'Southgate haters' comments from our most faithful that naturally seek to exonerate him from any criticism whenever any comes - all football managers get it wrong sometimes - I think you also have to take that into context with the fact that the expectation levels for England have and will always be far higher than is reasonable. Be it because of the club adulation for the 'superstars' playing, the elongated periods between matches, general jingoism at large or whatever. International coaches have always had it. They always will. Not worth crying over when someone takes a pop at a coach you admire.
Back to Southgate, overall he's done a great job looking at the records. But his true measure as a manager can't really be judged until he's managed elsewhere, because like a clutch of a few other international managers his career is arse-about-face compared to how one achieved the job traditionally. I think there are question marks over in-game management, but again these are outweighed by his achievements which do show a clear willingness and aptitude in preparing for games. One or two of which in the summer he won by playing and sticking to the long game(s); in spite of how many of the armchair experts would have done otherwise. I think if he had just one or two more 'world class' players in the mix we wouldn't even be having this debate, but that's not something he can control.
An excellent post, some great points raised. Especially around Southgate’s “handbrake” for a long time our weakest area has been centre backs so it makes sense to have a system that protects them.
Interestingly as great as I think he’s been for England I don’t think he’d be cut out to be an elite club manager. Some are just better suited to the international game.
Agree with Hawks and Duffers here.
He's an international manager, club football is a different beast.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(06-06-2022, 02:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (06-06-2022, 10:25 AM)Duffers Wrote: (06-06-2022, 09:29 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Personally I quite like Gareth Southgate. I think he's more intelligent than your average 'football man', and this shows in his interviews. His comments and appraisal of not only the fixtures but several issues surrounding the game (be it BLM, fan behaviour, inclusivity etc.) are always measured and heartfelt, and as a figurehead there is no question that he has far more integrity than some of his predecessors.
A good mate of mine who works in press/PR has met him a few times, and says he's a smashing bloke. And I think perhaps his biggest success has been carrying those attributes over to a national side featuring for whom had somehow stopped seeming to matter to the same, usual, boring, underperforming characters. I think he's not only restored the pride in playing for England again, but succeeded in stripping away the peripheral disciplinary issues that seemed almost perennially to trip us up going into big tournaments. There is seldom much scandal to write about anymore.
I think where it starts to fall down is that we can be too conservative. That showed on Saturday, and it showed at times in the last tournament (despite how well we did). I don't think he can entirely be blamed, because for me the squad isn't actually as brilliant as many of our lot like to make out; and if your back line features the likes of Maguire, Stones, Mings etc. you're hardly likely to throw caution to the wind in exposing them when - regrettably at times - it does look like if Kane doesn't turn up neither does our attacking threat, beyond of course Sterling (who the game was crying out for on Saturday).
In terms of him managing the side I'm happy enough. He's brought us as close to honours as I can remember in my lifetime, and no matter how 'easy' the run to get there may have been that's still quite an achievement. I think it by far outweighs any negatives we saw during that tournament, and giving him the benefit of doubt this is a stupid week really to play internationals when so many players are burnt out after a long season. Whilst I don't necessarily subscribe to the 'Southgate haters' comments from our most faithful that naturally seek to exonerate him from any criticism whenever any comes - all football managers get it wrong sometimes - I think you also have to take that into context with the fact that the expectation levels for England have and will always be far higher than is reasonable. Be it because of the club adulation for the 'superstars' playing, the elongated periods between matches, general jingoism at large or whatever. International coaches have always had it. They always will. Not worth crying over when someone takes a pop at a coach you admire.
Back to Southgate, overall he's done a great job looking at the records. But his true measure as a manager can't really be judged until he's managed elsewhere, because like a clutch of a few other international managers his career is arse-about-face compared to how one achieved the job traditionally. I think there are question marks over in-game management, but again these are outweighed by his achievements which do show a clear willingness and aptitude in preparing for games. One or two of which in the summer he won by playing and sticking to the long game(s); in spite of how many of the armchair experts would have done otherwise. I think if he had just one or two more 'world class' players in the mix we wouldn't even be having this debate, but that's not something he can control.
An excellent post, some great points raised. Especially around Southgate’s “handbrake” for a long time our weakest area has been centre backs so it makes sense to have a system that protects them.
Interestingly as great as I think he’s been for England I don’t think he’d be cut out to be an elite club manager. Some are just better suited to the international game.
Agree with Hawks and Duffers here.
He's an international manager, club football is a different beast.
I agree to a certain extent but it will be interesting to see how his international experience helps him post England. He's undoubtedly a better manager now than when he got the gig. He might actually suit a continental club rather than a PL club.
|