Beergate
#91
What was your strategy then, let's hear it? Lock up 30 kids in a room with no staff? Not do anything to spread out the rate of infection to relieve pressure on stretched services?

After the first lockdown it was never ever about kids being off school for 5 days a week, it was the complete disregard for any form of flexible learning for schools to enable kids to learn from home as implemented in other countries because the only option for the government was getting the kids in school which fell flat on its arse. No contingency, no commandeering of larger spaces, no separate provision of learning for primary and secondary students, no modular examinations. It isn't about agreeing on the principle because I also wanted as many kids as practically possible to have in-person learning, it was actually about what was realistic within the required national constraints and what you and I both wanted to happen was never realistic as we found out - ultimately the pursuit of what you wanted by a government with horseblinders on ended up exacerbating the situation. The difference is you - like the feckless government - were never prepared to accept what they wanted was going to fail whereas I had been screaming about contingency. The idiots wouldn't even install air filtration in classrooms despite me regularly emailing my dickhead of a Tory MP about it for months to no reply.
Reply
#92
Like I say, we'll never agree about the principle of kids not being in school.

100,000 missing kids is testament enough to that.
Reply
#93
It's like you didn't even read what I wrote. Unbelievable.
Reply
#94
I did read it. The government didn’t do enough to keep kids in school. That is what I believe.
Reply
#95
So just out of interest, seeing as there were over 250 NHS staff that died from covid, how many teachers do you think that it would have been reasonable to risk. Or alternatively what would you have done to protect the teachers, or are you of the view that they weren't at risk?

And once you have squared that circle, how do you think the sickness levels would have been managed?
Reply
#96
(05-16-2022, 08:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I did read it. The government didn’t do enough to keep kids in school. That is what I believe.

The government couldn't keep kids in school because they were listening to people like you who refused to acknowledge the realities of what were actually happening and refusing to implement any contingency measures to encourage a proportion and mitigate disruption to the rest.

How do you keep all the kids in school when all the staff are off sick? You can't keep 30 people locked in a room with no teachers.
Reply
#97
(05-16-2022, 08:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So just out of interest, seeing as there were over 250 NHS staff that died from covid, how many teachers do you think that it would have been reasonable to risk. Or alternatively what would you have done to protect the teachers, or are you of the view that they weren't at risk?

And once you have squared that circle, how do you think the sickness levels would have been managed?

150 patients die (died) needlessly in the NHS everyday before, during and after Covid. How many patients is it reasonable to risk everyday or alternatively what would you do to protect patients? 

The outcomes for hundreds of thousands of kids are clearly a huge risk too.

My point is life is all about risk management and mitigation. You cannot eliminate risk completely. How's that going in China? 

The government should have done far more to ensure schools remained open, and at least ensured they'd not closed for a second time.
Reply
#98
(05-17-2022, 09:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-16-2022, 08:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So just out of interest, seeing as there were over 250 NHS staff that died from covid, how many teachers do you think that it would have been reasonable to risk. Or alternatively what would you have done to protect the teachers, or are you of the view that they weren't at risk?

And once you have squared that circle, how do you think the sickness levels would have been managed?

150 patients die (died) needlessly in the NHS everyday before, during and after Covid. How many patients is it reasonable to risk everyday or alternatively what would you do to protect patients? 

The outcomes for hundreds of thousands of kids are clearly a huge risk too.

My point is life is all about risk management and mitigation. You cannot eliminate risk completely. How's that going in China? 

The government should have done far more to ensure schools remained open, and at least ensured they'd not closed for a second time.

You also cannot have children in school if all the staff are off with Covid, did you forget about that?
Reply
#99
So your logic is that without any controls or protections in place Teachers should go into schools where the virus was circulating because people die unnecessarily in other walks of life.

I’ll ask again, how would you have protected them? Or are you saying they didn’t need protection.
Reply
(05-17-2022, 09:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So your logic is that without any controls or protections in place Teachers should go into schools where the virus was circulating because people die unnecessarily in other walks of life.

I’ll ask again, how would you have protected them? Or are you saying they didn’t need protection.

No, that's not my logic. 

My logic is that those risks could have been identified, managed and mitigated. Just as I wish the NHS (peace be upon it) would do rather than killing 150 people needlessly everyday and usually attempting to cover up its failures.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)