Bringing the kids through- the illusion
#1
I've never been greatly into watching our kids, reserves etc. To me it's all about the first team.

I am pleased though that we have a really highly respected academy, which is one of the best in the country. I know this to be true as I have a friend who is very senior in the youth football world in the Midlands. He really rates what we do as a club.

However, there is a fallacy that it's all about giving the kids a go. As many football commentators have said regards this including Joe Masi and Chris Lepkowski in the past few months, the players aged 18-19 or so who go out on loan generally play at League 2/Conference standard. Therefore the step up to Championship level is huge.

Thinking we can throw 4-5 in and berating the manager for not doing it is ridiculous. The 6-0 mauling v Arsenal at home in the League Cup is a demonstration of what happens when you throw several inexperienced kids in.

I think the emergence of TGH this season plus the knocking on the door by the likes of Fellows and Ashworth is a pretty decent return on the youth this season. I hope they all play a part, and I too, was sad to see Sam Field go- if only we held on to him.

For a long while in the 90s particularly our youth set up was woeful, but let's just see how they get on and stop thinking they are an answer to our first team woes. I trust the senior coaching team to work out who is able and who is not.

It's also worth adding the levels of assessment and data on players now is mind-bogglingly staggering. We have all this date at our fingertips too.

So let's not worry when these young players go either. After all being a bright young thing at 18 is no indicator of future success. The likes of Dhandi, and Brown have yet to have us ruing their moving. 

We've got issues at the club far bigger than our youth set up, and bringing in kids still getting to terms with a razor generally isn't the answer. There's lots of good players to be got elsewhere.
Reply
#2
One of the lads in my daughter’s year at school plays for our academy. His parents have nothing but praise for it (his Dad is a Man Yoo fan and the kid himself is a Dingle, so there’s no affiliation really). Said the other day O’Shea and Moulumby just turned up and began kicking about with the under 11s. Which I thought was a nice touch.
Reply
#3
(05-10-2022, 03:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: One of the lads in my daughter’s year at school plays for our academy. His parents have nothing but praise for it (his Dad is a Man Yoo fan and the kid himself is a Dingle, so there’s no affiliation really). Said the other day O’Shea and Moulumby just turned up and began kicking about with the under 11s. Which I thought was a nice touch.

Would be a first for Molumby.
Reply
#4
(05-10-2022, 03:19 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I've never been greatly into watching our kids, reserves etc. To me it's all about the first team.

I am pleased though that we have a really highly respected academy, which is one of the best in the country. I know this to be true as I have a friend who is very senior in the youth football world in the Midlands. He really rates what we do as a club.

However, there is a fallacy that it's all about giving the kids a go. As many football commentators have said regards this including Joe Masi and Chris Lepkowski in the past few months, the players aged 18-19 or so who go out on loan generally play at League 2/Conference standard. Therefore the step up to Championship level is huge.

Thinking we can throw 4-5 in and berating the manager for not doing it is ridiculous. The 6-0 mauling v Arsenal at home in the League Cup is a demonstration of what happens when you throw several inexperienced kids in.

I think the emergence of TGH this season plus the knocking on the door by the likes of Fellows and Ashworth is a pretty decent return on the youth this season. I hope they all play a part, and I too, was sad to see Sam Field go- if only we held on to him.

For a long while in the 90s particularly our youth set up was woeful, but let's just see how they get on and stop thinking they are an answer to our first team woes. I trust the senior coaching team to work out who is able and who is not.

It's also worth adding the levels of assessment and data on players now is mind-bogglingly staggering. We have all this date at our fingertips too.

So let's not worry when these young players go either. After all being a bright young thing at 18 is no indicator of future success. The likes of Dhandi, and Brown have yet to have us ruing their moving. 

We've got issues at the club far bigger than our youth set up, and bringing in kids still getting to terms with a razor generally isn't the answer. There's lots of good players to be got elsewhere.

So what's your point, caller?
Reply
#5
(05-10-2022, 03:31 PM)Fido Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 03:19 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I've never been greatly into watching our kids, reserves etc. To me it's all about the first team.

I am pleased though that we have a really highly respected academy, which is one of the best in the country. I know this to be true as I have a friend who is very senior in the youth football world in the Midlands. He really rates what we do as a club.

However, there is a fallacy that it's all about giving the kids a go. As many football commentators have said regards this including Joe Masi and Chris Lepkowski in the past few months, the players aged 18-19 or so who go out on loan generally play at League 2/Conference standard. Therefore the step up to Championship level is huge.

Thinking we can throw 4-5 in and berating the manager for not doing it is ridiculous. The 6-0 mauling v Arsenal at home in the League Cup is a demonstration of what happens when you throw several inexperienced kids in.

I think the emergence of TGH this season plus the knocking on the door by the likes of Fellows and Ashworth is a pretty decent return on the youth this season. I hope they all play a part, and I too, was sad to see Sam Field go- if only we held on to him.

For a long while in the 90s particularly our youth set up was woeful, but let's just see how they get on and stop thinking they are an answer to our first team woes. I trust the senior coaching team to work out who is able and who is not.

It's also worth adding the levels of assessment and data on players now is mind-bogglingly staggering. We have all this date at our fingertips too.

So let's not worry when these young players go either. After all being a bright young thing at 18 is no indicator of future success. The likes of Dhandi, and Brown have yet to have us ruing their moving. 

We've got issues at the club far bigger than our youth set up, and bringing in kids still getting to terms with a razor generally isn't the answer. There's lots of good players to be got elsewhere.

So what's your point, caller?

Give yoof a chance sparingly Fido. We've generally done well past few years and have called more right than wrong. It's a pisser though what happened with Ferguson.
Reply
#6
It's great that we've been able to bring some through to the first team. It's also gratifying to see the likes of Kane Wilson and Jack Fitzwater become first team footballers elsewhere, because even if they didn't get into our first team, the academy have taught them welll enough so that they have the drive and attitude to make it as professional footballers and that's no small thing.
Reply
#7
Its all about balance. Using the Arsenal game to try and say the kids aren't ready is a terrible example. In fact that game shows just what you shouldn't do with kids!!
 
You should never put 9 kids out against a full strength top 4 prem side. It was lambs to the slaugher. You need to drip feed the ones that show promise into the side when surrounded by more experience. Ease them into the side and support them. 

The talented ones don't necessarily need loans if they have the right mentality they can flourish and step up. Ferguson never had a loan or if he did it was a month in non league. TGH didnt. Saido didn't. Took his chance in a league cup match and flourished.

Look at Derbys kids this season. 4 or 5 very good kids who never had a loan but were thrown in and did really well. Djed Spence at Forest played 63 games for Boro never had a loan before breaking into there side. Iregbonum is now starting for Villa and hasn't had a loan since they nicked him from us. 

We have to get better at intergrating them properly and in fairness we've done ok this season. Fellows is a good player as is Taylor and Ashworth. I personally would keep them all involved with us next season and bring them on but I really have my concerns over Bruce doing this personally.

In terms of losing the better players well thats a different subject. The loop holes in favour of big clubs cherry picking and us not being able to tie players down until they are 17 will continue until sanctions are put in place to stop it. The tapping up will continue and we will continue to lose the most high profile promising ones.

FWIW i think we have lost a very good player in Cleary but time will tell I guess. I saw him live a fair bit last season and he looked very good.
Reply
#8
very well argued

Bruce seems very reluctant to give our young players a chance in what were fixtures with nothing hanging on them, which is worrying as
we are hardly in a position to buy our way out of this division
Reply
#9
(05-10-2022, 03:29 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 03:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: One of the lads in my daughter’s year at school plays for our academy. His parents have nothing but praise for it (his Dad is a Man Yoo fan and the kid himself is a Dingle, so there’s no affiliation really). Said the other day O’Shea and Moulumby just turned up and began kicking about with the under 11s. Which I thought was a nice touch.

Would be a first for Molumby.

Big Grin
Reply
#10
(05-10-2022, 04:55 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: very well argued

Bruce seems very reluctant to give our young players a chance in what were fixtures with nothing hanging on them, which is worrying as
we are hardly in a position to buy our way out of this division

Yep. I said after the Forest defeat we have a real opportunity. The only positive left for the season was that it presented us with a perfect chance to start a few kids and we didn't do it. Ashwotth came on against Reading only because Townsend got injured. The starting line up against an already relegated Barnsley, who themselves played half their U23 side, told you everything you need to know about Bruce and youth team prospects.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: