Caleb Taylor
#11
The medium/long term is ever in the way of the short term. Bruce has a max 10 game rolling horizon, so will go tried, tired, and tested every time. the yoof have slim chances and will leave, meaning their medium long term development with us will never happen: for that reason we need a manager that is and thinks in youthful terms. otherwise we'll keep on bashing the post Pulis plan
Reply
#12
(05-04-2022, 12:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:53 AM)mickeypearce Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:46 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:39 AM)mickeypearce Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 10:53 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Probably not involved with the first team due to the amount of central defenders we have, allied to the in-situ manager going for experience all the time, hence using ill-suited but experienced players to cover.

I would love to see a fair few of our U23s get game time next season. We actually have a decent bunch for the first time in forever.

We won't know this until they have had a run of games, a lot of people were saying this a few years ago about the likes of Leko, Edwards, Field and Harper.

The bit you've highlighted is obviously my own opinion.

It was also my own opinion that Leko and Harper were absolute dogshit, having watched them over a prolonged period. Field was steady but had no pace. Edwards was ok and showed a little promise.

What I have found out, from watching the reserves, is that my opinion seems to differ greatly from the professionals in the game  Big Grin . Differing from the biffs on here comes as standard  Smile

You may well be right Ray, i don't see enough of them to pass judgement, all i know is we have had many false dawns over the years of our youth being championed on here and yet not making the grade. Ironically the most successful in recent times in terms of moving on to a higher level (Ferguson) never got a mention on here.

Ferguson was a player I liked from the off. Just not my style to start proclaiming the coming of the next messiah. He was played as a centre half though, or a right-sided centre half, so his height was against him, which is when you then have doubts. Bilic moving him to out-and-out full back negated the height issue whilst also allowing his natural talent to be applied even more effectively.

In general we have an occasional (potential) goodie come through but the vast majority of them have never looked anywhere near good enough to me, which is why our reserves were bottom of the league for a number of seasons.

Names get mentioned on here all the time. Normally it's players I don't rate. Sometimes it's players further down the chain who I have never heard of!  Smile

Don't recall TGH being particularly heralded before his breakthrough.
Reply
#13
(05-04-2022, 12:33 PM)Babel Wrote: The medium/long term is ever in the way of the short term. Bruce has a max 10 game rolling horizon, so will go tried, tired, and tested every time. the yoof have slim chances and will leave, meaning their medium long term development with us will never happen: for that reason we need a manager that is and thinks in youthful terms. otherwise we'll keep on bashing the post Pulis plan

Plus everyone (us especially) has to be on board with it. Blooding 3 or 4 kids and keeping them in is risky. They WILL make mistakes. Mistakes that may cost us points. If people start getting on their backs you soon have another Scott Darton situation. FFS there was a guy near me at the Cov game getting on TGH's back when he was having a poor game. Thats the sort of thing that needs to stop if youngsters are to play to their potential.
Reply
#14
(05-04-2022, 10:39 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: He’s always looked assured and composed for the u23s, I’ve felt the best player in that pack…the old cliché ‘next cab off the rank…’ and all that BS. 

However he’s never been involved really in the first team when there been opportunities to play the younger players. 

Am I completely wrong about this lad or are there other factors?

Go back and see my posts from the games I saw earlier this season. For his age he's a brilliant talent. 6'6, strong, athletic and a really good organiser and communicator.

He should have started at Reading. Instead fucking Bartley came back in. Why did Bruce need to see Bartley start ffs?

I'm guessing he'll be loaned out next season to Div 1 to gwt some experience as we won't be able to shift on the crap that we have.
Reply
#15
I have never been overly impressed. Lacks mobility, tends to stand too square on when defending, and has a terrible turning circle, which makes Bartley look like a house fly.

He is however Brucey's kind of CB. Big, strong, attacks what's in front of him well. But if we are going to ever change the way we play we need CB's with mobility, agility and better technique on the ball. Taylor is very much a Ham & Eggs kind of CB, to Quote Crouchy, quoting Pulis.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
A lot of it is happenstance. I remember O’Shea coming on for his league debut December ‘19, I think Brentford, as I was in the Richardson Suite. We had an injury crisis and maybe Bartley went off during the second half.

After that O’Shea didn’t really look back.

With Taylor I think it’s a big preseason. I can see Bartley going and Clarke will go. That leaves Semi, Dara, Taylor, Kipre (I mean he’s been no where so likely going too). We’d need another CB at least.

I guess this gives Taylor his chance…

(05-04-2022, 01:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have never been overly impressed. Lacks mobility, tends to stand too square on when defending, and has a terrible turning circle, which makes Bartley look like a house fly.

He is however Brucey's kind of CB. Big, strong, attacks what's in front of him well. But if we are going to ever change the way we play we need CB's with mobility, agility and better technique on the ball. Taylor is very much a Ham & Eggs kind of CB, to Quote Crouchy, quoting Pulis.

That doesn’t exactly chime with what I’ve seen but everyone’s opinion is valid. 

He’s more mobile than Bartley but his he a Rio Ferdinand no. What he is definitely is a leader, talker and organiser. He’s strong and has excellent positional sense. Good point on square on, think that’s fair, but that goes for many CBs and can be coached. He’s not pacy I’ll give you that one.
Reply
#17
(05-04-2022, 01:00 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 12:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:53 AM)mickeypearce Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:46 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 11:39 AM)mickeypearce Wrote: We won't know this until they have had a run of games, a lot of people were saying this a few years ago about the likes of Leko, Edwards, Field and Harper.

The bit you've highlighted is obviously my own opinion.

It was also my own opinion that Leko and Harper were absolute dogshit, having watched them over a prolonged period. Field was steady but had no pace. Edwards was ok and showed a little promise.

What I have found out, from watching the reserves, is that my opinion seems to differ greatly from the professionals in the game  Big Grin . Differing from the biffs on here comes as standard  Smile

You may well be right Ray, i don't see enough of them to pass judgement, all i know is we have had many false dawns over the years of our youth being championed on here and yet not making the grade. Ironically the most successful in recent times in terms of moving on to a higher level (Ferguson) never got a mention on here.

Ferguson was a player I liked from the off. Just not my style to start proclaiming the coming of the next messiah. He was played as a centre half though, or a right-sided centre half, so his height was against him, which is when you then have doubts. Bilic moving him to out-and-out full back negated the height issue whilst also allowing his natural talent to be applied even more effectively.

In general we have an occasional (potential) goodie come through but the vast majority of them have never looked anywhere near good enough to me, which is why our reserves were bottom of the league for a number of seasons.

Names get mentioned on here all the time. Normally it's players I don't rate. Sometimes it's players further down the chain who I have never heard of!  Smile

Don't recall TGH being particularly heralded before his breakthrough.

Somebody did specifically ask for opinions on TGH at the start of this season. I don't think there were that many replies! My reply was that I'd only seen him come on as sub (and score) against Everton in the FA Youth Cup a few seasons prior. Only really saw him for the reserves this season (where he played left wing back but was impressive with a few others). I was surprised he, and not Ingram, was picked to play right wing back when he made his debut though. Both on a par at the time in my opinion but Ingram was the right wing back for the reserves, so seemed the logical choice.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: