Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-02-2022, 09:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (05-02-2022, 07:48 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Question is would he have arrested a slide?
Easy to say not but we will never know
I backed him to get us in the top 6, even in all the games bar PNE at home we created chances, even that Milwall game we should have been 2 up after 10 minutes, win that and he would have kept his job and who knows then?
Bruce came in and we created next to nothing and started shipping goals, he made us worse and not for the want of trying, just the facts
Also Dikes injury must have killed Val, convinced the owners he was the missing piece to the jigsaw and then breaks down on his full debut, couldn’t script it
The bloke drove me mad with his stubbornness but one glance at us now tells me I’d rather he have stayed in charge, not hindsight either, nailed my colors to the mast the day we wrongly gave up on him
Cuzer
A really interesting xGD graphic of our season with a rolling average:
I wonder if something significant happened after game week 29?
oooo xGD, a new twist on the useless xG... nicely done bringing another pointless stat into play... what was that blip around week 15?? Also, what the fecking 'ell is a game week? This is football, not some American game, FFS
Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(05-02-2022, 07:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: wbamitch Wrote:Dumbo Wrote:Short memories. The football under Val was fucking terrible for months. We were dropping rapidly and would have dropped to 9th if teams with games in hand won.
Bruce has come in and done equally as wank. He’s a very lucky man to be kept on next season but doesn’t mean we were wrong to sack Val.
Two awful managers in an awful fucking season.
Spot on. We were heading in one direction, I'm almost certain we wouldn't have got playoffs with Val. Saying we were in the top 6 the day he left as an argument against Bruce is just lazy. The one thing I'll give him credit for is the defence which Bruce has managed to mess up without solving anything going forward. Quite why he's staying on I don't know but it doesn't change the fact that VI was a poor appointment. I question why we have the break clause in Bruce's contract, what would the results have to have been like for us to activate it??? What will always bug me, about Ismael's tenure, is that we didn't go all out to provide the striker his system demands. Instead, choosing to gamble on playing three wide players as forwards. I think the loud communal groan when we saw the newly arrived Dike pull up with a hamstring, was the death knell of our promotion hopes. I would still have liked to have seen Ismael's team with Carroll up front for a while.
I think Val was the wrong man at the wrong time, but we really would be no worse off had we given him another month but with a no.9 in his team. Of course, we could always have fired him after that but I'd bet we would not be lower than where we currently stand. People on opposite sides of this argument are digging in but we will really never know. Val bought in Hugil.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
05-03-2022, 08:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-03-2022, 08:49 AM by Fido.)
Val's style of football had a shelf-life that was akin to leaving an open bottle of milk in the sun.
It may well be the case we'd have ended up a similar postion, who knows, but if your sole tactic is to have someone like Mowatt box-kicking like Ben Youngs in the vain hope that the forwards will challenge for the back over the top (bear in mind we're talking Grant/Robinson/Diangana/Hugill) then it's all going to turn sour at one point and the curdling started when teams decided to sit deep after about game four.
Ends.
Posts: 9,608
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-02-2022, 09:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: A really interesting xGD graphic of our season with a rolling average:
I wonder if something significant happened after game week 29?
Thats a brilliant graphic. What sites that, mate?
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(05-03-2022, 08:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (05-02-2022, 07:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: wbamitch Wrote:Dumbo Wrote:Short memories. The football under Val was fucking terrible for months. We were dropping rapidly and would have dropped to 9th if teams with games in hand won.
Bruce has come in and done equally as wank. He’s a very lucky man to be kept on next season but doesn’t mean we were wrong to sack Val.
Two awful managers in an awful fucking season.
Spot on. We were heading in one direction, I'm almost certain we wouldn't have got playoffs with Val. Saying we were in the top 6 the day he left as an argument against Bruce is just lazy. The one thing I'll give him credit for is the defence which Bruce has managed to mess up without solving anything going forward. Quite why he's staying on I don't know but it doesn't change the fact that VI was a poor appointment. I question why we have the break clause in Bruce's contract, what would the results have to have been like for us to activate it??? What will always bug me, about Ismael's tenure, is that we didn't go all out to provide the striker his system demands. Instead, choosing to gamble on playing three wide players as forwards. I think the loud communal groan when we saw the newly arrived Dike pull up with a hamstring, was the death knell of our promotion hopes. I would still have liked to have seen Ismael's team with Carroll up front for a while.
I think Val was the wrong man at the wrong time, but we really would be no worse off had we given him another month but with a no.9 in his team. Of course, we could always have fired him after that but I'd bet we would not be lower than where we currently stand. People on opposite sides of this argument are digging in but we will really never know. Val bought in Hugil. You really think? It was common knowledge he wanted Dike in August. It's all history now and I don't have a dog in this fight but we will never know what might have been had Ismael been given a proper no.9.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(05-03-2022, 08:48 AM)Fido Wrote: Val's style of football had a shelf-life that was akin to leaving an open bottle of milk in the sun.
It may well be the case we'd have ended up a similar postion, who knows, but if your sole tactic is to have someone like Mowatt box-kicking like Ben Youngs in the vain hope that the forwards will challenge for the back over the top (bear in mind we're talking Grant/Robinson/Diangana/Hugill) then it's all going to turn sour at one point and the curdling started when teams decided to sit deep after about game four.
Ends. No room for sense here mate; I thought we'd now agreed that the football was fine and that it was the failure to convert the huge number of quality chances created each game that cost us?
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
It’s common knowledge that he wasn’t interested in keeping possession, so quite ironic that we had 61% or whatever it is as our average. There’s a quote from him somewhere whereby his claim was to want 0% possession in their own half whilst managing Barnsley.
We were given possession as the simplest way to counteract ValBall and it worked. 9th when others played their games in hand and that’s where we may finish.
I can see the argument I that we may as well have given Val the season given how it panned out, but that’s hindsight.
Bruce failing to turn it round doesn’t make Val any less of a failure, especially given the midfield he left us with.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
05-03-2022, 12:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-03-2022, 12:43 PM by clem4england.)
(05-02-2022, 07:48 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Question is would he have arrested a slide?
Easy to say not but we will never know
I backed him to get us in the top 6, even in all the games bar PNE at home we created chances, even that Milwall game we should have been 2 up after 10 minutes, win that and he would have kept his job and who knows then?
Bruce came in and we created next to nothing and started shipping goals, he made us worse and not for the want of trying, just the facts
Also Dikes injury must have killed Val, convinced the owners he was the missing piece to the jigsaw and then breaks down on his full debut, couldn’t script it
The bloke drove me mad with his stubbornness but one glance at us now tells me I’d rather he have stayed in charge, not hindsight either, nailed my colors to the mast the day we wrongly gave up on him
Cuzer Arrested the slide that began in September? I think so as he didn't have ample chance before he left.
(05-03-2022, 12:41 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: It’s common knowledge that he wasn’t interested in keeping possession, so quite ironic that we had 61% or whatever it is as our average. There’s a quote from him somewhere whereby his claim was to want 0% possession in their own half whilst managing Barnsley.
We were given possession as the simplest way to counteract ValBall and it worked. 9th when others played their games in hand and that’s where we may finish.
I can see the argument I that we may as well have given Val the season given how it panned out, but that’s hindsight.
Bruce failing to turn it round doesn’t make Val any less of a failure, especially given the midfield he left us with. Which is why he was such a poor choice. Unless we wanted to become the new Barnsley, in which case we shouldn't have extended any contracts and signed league one players. Poor man's Buckley.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-03-2022, 08:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (05-02-2022, 07:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: wbamitch Wrote:Dumbo Wrote:Short memories. The football under Val was fucking terrible for months. We were dropping rapidly and would have dropped to 9th if teams with games in hand won.
Bruce has come in and done equally as wank. He’s a very lucky man to be kept on next season but doesn’t mean we were wrong to sack Val.
Two awful managers in an awful fucking season.
Spot on. We were heading in one direction, I'm almost certain we wouldn't have got playoffs with Val. Saying we were in the top 6 the day he left as an argument against Bruce is just lazy. The one thing I'll give him credit for is the defence which Bruce has managed to mess up without solving anything going forward. Quite why he's staying on I don't know but it doesn't change the fact that VI was a poor appointment. I question why we have the break clause in Bruce's contract, what would the results have to have been like for us to activate it??? What will always bug me, about Ismael's tenure, is that we didn't go all out to provide the striker his system demands. Instead, choosing to gamble on playing three wide players as forwards. I think the loud communal groan when we saw the newly arrived Dike pull up with a hamstring, was the death knell of our promotion hopes. I would still have liked to have seen Ismael's team with Carroll up front for a while.
I think Val was the wrong man at the wrong time, but we really would be no worse off had we given him another month but with a no.9 in his team. Of course, we could always have fired him after that but I'd bet we would not be lower than where we currently stand. People on opposite sides of this argument are digging in but we will really never know. Val bought in Hugil.
The only two players Val brought in we’re Clarke and Mowatt
The rest were provided shall we say….
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(05-03-2022, 12:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (05-03-2022, 08:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (05-02-2022, 07:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: wbamitch Wrote:Dumbo Wrote:Short memories. The football under Val was fucking terrible for months. We were dropping rapidly and would have dropped to 9th if teams with games in hand won.
Bruce has come in and done equally as wank. He’s a very lucky man to be kept on next season but doesn’t mean we were wrong to sack Val.
Two awful managers in an awful fucking season.
Spot on. We were heading in one direction, I'm almost certain we wouldn't have got playoffs with Val. Saying we were in the top 6 the day he left as an argument against Bruce is just lazy. The one thing I'll give him credit for is the defence which Bruce has managed to mess up without solving anything going forward. Quite why he's staying on I don't know but it doesn't change the fact that VI was a poor appointment. I question why we have the break clause in Bruce's contract, what would the results have to have been like for us to activate it??? What will always bug me, about Ismael's tenure, is that we didn't go all out to provide the striker his system demands. Instead, choosing to gamble on playing three wide players as forwards. I think the loud communal groan when we saw the newly arrived Dike pull up with a hamstring, was the death knell of our promotion hopes. I would still have liked to have seen Ismael's team with Carroll up front for a while.
I think Val was the wrong man at the wrong time, but we really would be no worse off had we given him another month but with a no.9 in his team. Of course, we could always have fired him after that but I'd bet we would not be lower than where we currently stand. People on opposite sides of this argument are digging in but we will really never know. Val bought in Hugil.
The only two players Val brought in we’re Clarke and Mowatt
The rest were provided shall we say….
Cuzer
So Hugil was bought in, whilst he was manager, yet against his will?
Wasn't as tough as he made out then by the sounds of it.
|