Back 4
#11
Seems he's come out and said he's looking at a 4 next season, explains the omission of Clarke yesterday as well I'm sure

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#12
(05-01-2022, 10:28 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(05-01-2022, 10:08 AM)aj21 Wrote: The biggest problem this season has been with playing 5 at the back, we don’t have wing backs and without them you cannot play that formation. The rebuild has to be based on a back four

I also think defensive organisation at set pieces and in open play is more difficult with a "fluid" three than a "proper" pair. Megson made it work, Val did for a while, but it was a disaster for Darren Moore.

Wile/Robertson, McAuley/Olsson - what's not to like about a proper CB pairing?

The Reading commentator was very complimentary towards our 2 centre halves yesterday, having said that, they weren't particularly stretched but still managed to let them get 2 or 3 decent headers, from which they might have done better.
Reply
#13
(05-01-2022, 09:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-01-2022, 06:27 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-30-2022, 07:18 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Suits Furlong and Townsend more. But worries me that we end up with a flat 6 when the wide players naturally get drawn back. 

To play a 4, you need to go with Liverpools approach, 3 forwards high up the pitch and leave em there. Hope we're brave enough.

Back 4 is the proper way to play. Only if you have especially talented players can you get any benefit from 3 CBs. It's a fashion which comes and goes but never stays. Ismael's system with 3 ordinary centre backs trying to play football on the overlap and two ordinary full backs trying to be wing backs has crippled our prospects this season.

If Valball had worked out and we'd won promotion, of course I would have been happy, but I would still think it a thoroughly depressing and deplorable way to play football.

If we are to persist with the back 3 next season we need to be bolder in our selection back there. 

I’d like to see one of Townsend or Furlong dropping in to provide the outlet. 

Would be tempted to try Ashworth, Townsend, O’Shea, Ajayi, Phillips as a back 5 against Barnsley.

If we’re persisting with Livermore in front we can then have TGH and Molumby ahead of him.

I think that midfield combonation wouldn't be good enough for a team chasing promotion.
No goalscorers and very little in the way of creation from what i have seen.

If we do revert to a back 4, it's the part of the squad we need to concentrate on. We need to be looking for a back up/ replacement for Livermore and a midfielder who possesses a goal threat, either by scoring or creating, ideally both.
I don't recall ever seeing Swift play, but his numbers in terms of goals scored and created are what we need.
And if we are to revert to 4 at the back, we need a quality wide player, Diangana could be that player, but would be a risk to assume he will regain his form.
Reply
#14
(05-01-2022, 10:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-01-2022, 09:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-01-2022, 06:27 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-30-2022, 07:18 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Suits Furlong and Townsend more. But worries me that we end up with a flat 6 when the wide players naturally get drawn back. 

To play a 4, you need to go with Liverpools approach, 3 forwards high up the pitch and leave em there. Hope we're brave enough.

Back 4 is the proper way to play. Only if you have especially talented players can you get any benefit from 3 CBs. It's a fashion which comes and goes but never stays. Ismael's system with 3 ordinary centre backs trying to play football on the overlap and two ordinary full backs trying to be wing backs has crippled our prospects this season.

If Valball had worked out and we'd won promotion, of course I would have been happy, but I would still think it a thoroughly depressing and deplorable way to play football.

If we are to persist with the back 3 next season we need to be bolder in our selection back there. 

I’d like to see one of Townsend or Furlong dropping in to provide the outlet. 

Would be tempted to try Ashworth, Townsend, O’Shea, Ajayi, Phillips as a back 5 against Barnsley.

If we’re persisting with Livermore in front we can then have TGH and Molumby ahead of him.

I think that midfield combonation wouldn't be good enough for a team chasing promotion.
No goalscorers and very little in the way of creation from what i have seen.

If we do revert to a back 4, it's the part of the squad we need to concentrate on. We need to be looking for a back up/ replacement for Livermore and a midfielder who possesses a goal threat, either by scoring or creating, ideally both.
I don't recall ever seeing Swift play, but his numbers in terms of goals scored and created are what we need.
And if we are to revert to 4 at the back, we need a quality wide player, Diangana could be that player, but would be a risk to assume he will regain his form.

Button
Furlong O’Shea Ajai Townsend 
Hayden Rothwell
Wallace Diangana Grant
Dike
Reply
#15
Definitely 4 at the back for me ,let them do what they're supposed to do and defend ,taking into account there will be a D/M the let the other 5 have the ball a much as possible and leave them to that at the ither end of the pitch.
Reply
#16
(05-01-2022, 11:55 AM)YoYoBaggie Wrote: Definitely  4 at the back for me ,let them do what they're supposed to do and defend ,taking into account there will be a D/M the  let the other 5 have the ball a much as possible and leave them to that at the ither end of the pitch.

Its far to easy to defend against when you have a flat back 4 and a holder. You get no-one breaking lines from deep. This only works if you have 3 forward close together and you play solely on the break, and very direct. Our fans won't allow this. 

We need to have more productivity from our fullbacks as its one of if not the most important position on the pitch, where players get the most time on the ball.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: