U.K. Public Transport
#31
Err, no. First of all - as I have already alluded to - the extent of greater provision of subsidies through cost efficiencies gained from optimising the operation of the railways would likely cover some of the required subsidy and would be able to be redistributed accordingly, I do not know the national extent of which but based on repeated cost efficiencies and greater provision of services from vertically integrated rail sectors and the use of open-access operators there are very likely to be financial gains for the Treasury that can be used to support subsidies.

Secondly, if tax is required to go up it can be targeted so that the majority isn't affected to support subsidies. Whether that be greater tax on first class tickets, domestic air travel and the already highly subsidised road users. Personally I think a progressive carbon tax would be a great use case, target highly polluting transport sectors and subsidise less polluting one to distribute demand and the best part is that the poor and less affluent would be unlikely to be affected as high earning individuals have a much higher carbon footprint.

You just don't want to pay more tax, I think you might struggle to persuade young workers with marginal rates at over 40% - and even 50% if they do a masters course - at £27k though to care what constitutes "fairness" from your perspective.
Reply
#32
(04-25-2022, 01:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You just don't want to pay more tax

I want everyone to pay less tax.
Reply
#33
Great, then you can argue for the end of subsidising motorists, then we can reduce the annual cost to the Exchequer to the tune of at least £50bn per annum
Reply
#34
I have no problem with road pricing, provided that BIK, VED, VAT on fuel and Fuel Duty are abolished. It's a logical step with the electrification of vehicle fleet, and entirely voluntary.
Reply
#35
Road pricing is a means of assessing the level of tax payable, it has nothing to do with subsidies to motorists. You can pay vehicle tax via road pricing and still subsidise motorists. So that doesn't address my point.
Reply
#36
Your point seems to be raising as much revenue from people as possible.
Reply
#37
My point is that if you're going to argue against rail subsidies then you'd need to argue against greater, parallel subsidies lest you look like a hypocrite. You can recoup the costs of cars and lorries on the Exchequer through dramatically increasing existing vehicle and fuel tax, don't even need to replace it. Then, if you go down that route, everything goes to pot on the roads because there's a reason that subsidy is there.

There's a reason Gladstone didn't remove income tax as Chancellor, taxation is a means to enable fiscal responsibility and provide greater opportunities for equality which are the fundamentals of liberalism. Access to better and more affordable public transport is a part of that. Dutch people aren't drowning in tax, are they? In fact they generally have more money to spend. Hell, even the countries with really high tax burdens like the Nordic countries have greater levels of disposable income that they can choose to do with as they please compared to us and they have better public service provisions.
Reply
#38
(04-23-2022, 10:12 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-23-2022, 09:58 AM)Sotv Wrote: Can someone explain what point is for the thick brexiteers amongst us please?
It would seem that it’s a well know labour politician wasted far more cash than a right leaning poster and member of the public did on a train ticket.
No doubt those who know best will be able to put me right with convoluted / patronising explanations and insults.

That train travel is stupidly expensive and needlessly convoluted in this country.

Do you deny this?

Why bother with all the different prices and discounts if you buy early etc - its the same distance of travel. Just have 1 price for each class of ticket for the same journey. Still allow people to book a seat in advance and of course limit numbers on each train for popular times. why should travellers who have to travel at short notice have to pay more?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: