Posts: 9,640
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: Where were the passionate defenders when there were endless "Fuck off Val" threads eh?
Oh yeah, they were joining in
Don’t recall ever saying F off to any manager even ones I didn’t rate. If the players are as poor as some have argued or similarly that Val needed three or four transfer windows then why is Bruce getting so much stick for three months at the club without any opportunity to change the squad?
Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.
Bruce hasn’t done as well as he could have I’m sure he will admit that himself but surely we can see what happens until Christmas before we start calling for his head in a steamer. Either we are a mess or we aren’t after all.
Big Sam is and always has been more dynamic and flexible than Bruce. I was fully behind him and would have been chuffed to see him stay and continue the rebuild.
Bruce has never been dynamic. He's always been mr steady, and he never adapted as the game progressed. His glory days at Blues are a long time ago now.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
For the last three weeks or so we've effectively been out of play-off contention realistically. These games, for me, were free hits to give some youth players a chance. Not a broad brush approach, just giving some a chance to play two or three in nothing games. Now we actually have some proper nothing games if he doesn't try this then it shows he has little to bring to the table, IMVHO. I really don't care if we get stuffed either and his selection of the current shit is vindicated; some players need to know they have a future here or we'll have another Sam Field scenario where a talented player who has a strong connection with the club gets fugged off and goes somewhere else.
Posts: 13,572
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-25-2022, 03:57 PM)Fido Wrote: For the last three weeks or so we've effectively been out of play-off contention realistically. These games, for me, were free hits to give some youth players a chance. Not a broad brush approach, just giving some a chance to play two or three in nothing games. Now we actually have some proper nothing games if he doesn't try this then it shows he has little to bring to the table, IMVHO. I really don't care if we get stuffed either and his selection of the current shit is vindicated; some players need to know they have a future here or we'll have another Sam Field scenario where a talented player who has a strong connection with the club gets fugged off and goes somewhere else.
Furlong got himself suspended for Cov, Bruce knows about Ingram as he's namedropped him. Does he play him against Cov? No, he plays left-footed Adam Reach out there instead for some reason.
Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
04-25-2022, 04:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2022, 04:21 PM by Sliced.)
(04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: Where were the passionate defenders when there were endless "Fuck off Val" threads eh?
Oh yeah, they were joining in
Don’t recall ever saying F off to any manager even ones I didn’t rate. If the players are as poor as some have argued or similarly that Val needed three or four transfer windows then why is Bruce getting so much stick for three months at the club without any opportunity to change the squad?
Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.
Bruce hasn’t done as well as he could have I’m sure he will admit that himself but surely we can see what happens until Christmas before we start calling for his head in a steamer. Either we are a mess or we aren’t after all.
It was a general post, but just like you personally never said F off to any manager you didn't like, I never said that Val needed 3 or 4 transfer windows. In fact I've never seen this argument; only people claiming that it was made.
Also Bruce isn't getting stick off me for not being exciting enough, it's because he's been crap so far. Which seems to be the same with the majority of fans given that the majority have turned in the past few weeks.
Just look back at threads from a few weeks ago vs now to see how the tide has turned. Bruce's performances are the reason for the justified criticism.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-25-2022, 04:18 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: Where were the passionate defenders when there were endless "Fuck off Val" threads eh?
Oh yeah, they were joining in
Don’t recall ever saying F off to any manager even ones I didn’t rate. If the players are as poor as some have argued or similarly that Val needed three or four transfer windows then why is Bruce getting so much stick for three months at the club without any opportunity to change the squad?
Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.
Bruce hasn’t done as well as he could have I’m sure he will admit that himself but surely we can see what happens until Christmas before we start calling for his head in a steamer. Either we are a mess or we aren’t after all.
It was a general post, but just like you personally never said F off to any manager you didn't like, I never said that Val needed 3 or 4 transfer windows. In fact I've never seen this argument; only people claiming that it was made.
Also Bruce isn't getting stick off me for not being exciting enough, it's because he's been crap so far. Which seems to be the same with the majority of fans given that the majority have turned in the past few weeks.
I think quite a few were arguing for him to be given two or three transfer windows. In comparison Bruce hasn’t had any.
Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
04-25-2022, 05:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2022, 05:20 PM by Sliced.)
(04-25-2022, 04:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-25-2022, 04:18 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-25-2022, 03:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: Where were the passionate defenders when there were endless "Fuck off Val" threads eh?
Oh yeah, they were joining in
Don’t recall ever saying F off to any manager even ones I didn’t rate. If the players are as poor as some have argued or similarly that Val needed three or four transfer windows then why is Bruce getting so much stick for three months at the club without any opportunity to change the squad?
Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.
Bruce hasn’t done as well as he could have I’m sure he will admit that himself but surely we can see what happens until Christmas before we start calling for his head in a steamer. Either we are a mess or we aren’t after all.
It was a general post, but just like you personally never said F off to any manager you didn't like, I never said that Val needed 3 or 4 transfer windows. In fact I've never seen this argument; only people claiming that it was made.
Also Bruce isn't getting stick off me for not being exciting enough, it's because he's been crap so far. Which seems to be the same with the majority of fans given that the majority have turned in the past few weeks.
I think quite a few were arguing for him to be given two or three transfer windows. In comparison Bruce hasn’t had any.
He had two, I've literally never seen this argument. If Bruce is put in the same position as Val whereby he had to replace our best players with free transfers then I'd wager he'd rather not have a window.
Whether a transfer window is beneficial or not is massively dependent on budget. I would have expected an experienced manager like Bruce to be able to improve upon a previously sacked manager; but we got worse.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Derek LOVES making up arguments for the other side of the debate to him.
Posts: 1,403
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
From the mans own mouth - I assume other posters are simply echoing Val's words
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...west-brom/
"Generally (with the squad) I am not where I want to be – it’s clear,” the boss said. “But it can’t be from the start you have everything you want.
“ It’s a process, you need two or three transfer windows."
“Now we come to the second window and we will see what we can do, how many players we can pick."
“The important thing is getting the right player."
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Yes, every manager wants 3 or 4 windows to make the squad their own. No one does it after 1 or 2. He didn't say he needs them to get promoted, or to do anything, just until he gets the squad how he likes. I'm sure most managers have said something similar.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Spandaubaggie Wrote:Big Daddy Cool Wrote:Terry did well for Villa didn't he? What's the issue? Or are we just looking for any excuse to have a go at Bruce now..
There's a morose bunch on here who just want to vent at Bruce as being the sole focus for the mess we are in just because he is here now. There's daily threads all finding a new way of saying how shit he is, and Christ it's depressing.
Not happy that Ishmael has been sacked, the board condemned for handing out idiotic contracts and the players reviled as being the worst in a generation, they can't get their fill of negativity and have turned their attention to him as he hasn't made a silk purse out of a sow's ear in 3 months, without any players he can bring in.
It's utterly grim on here at the minute, almost matching the Albion Facebook feed where we can see the beautiful specimens spewing all things negative to get likes of their learned friends. I'm just glad I don't know the miserable feckers. The thing is Spandau, our form is cause for concern and Bruce's previous transfer dealings don't have me filled with confidence. (Although he did sign McGinn so there is some hope).
FWIW, I didn't originally want Bruce but on reflection I thought his wealth of experience might actually be ideal in our situation. Unfortunately, having seen most of his games in charge, I don't know what our plan is. We have wing backs that rarely cross the ball. We have a giant aerial threat we never use to the best. No one plays within flick on reach of Carroll?
I've seen players getting way worse, Townsend, Bartley, Mowatt off the top of my head.
I've seen no one that can beat the first defender with a corner kick. Likewise free kicks.
I've seen players that constantly give up upon going a goal down dropped, then recalled.
I've seen players have good games in their position being moved to positions where they have poor games, Reach, TGH. I've seen players have good games then get dropped for players that have been given numerous chances and wasted them. (Molumby and TGH, dropped after their best games).
I've heard Bruce say he is going to give certain players a chance, then not do it. (Kipre, Fellows, he's talked up Ingram).
I saw Coventry out think us in midfield, than again at corner kicks by leaving 3 players up, while we made no attempt to counter.
All these issues flow out without having to think too hard. I am probably one of the most patient on here and rarely join the clamour for wanting a manager out. I thought Moore should have been backed and pressed to tame the Graeme Jones influence. I thought Big Sam showed enough to get backed with a proper budget to stay on. I thought Val was the wrong man at the wrong time but having given him the gig, I reckon the club ought to have backed him against the player power unrest having finally got him a centre forward at last. I didn't want Slav sacked although in hindsight, I was wrong.
All I want to see is a manager that knows his shape and his best team, along with some sign of progress. We actually have seen the opposite. Even now, I'm not for booting Bruce out. But I would hope the club have asked him what his ideas are and why we are suddenly so inept at both ends of the field and what he is going to do about it? Only if the answers to that make sense would he then be entrusted with another season.
I dunno if that enlists me in the morose bunch or if I'm making everything grim and depressing but the evidence above is undeniable and is giving me a huge cause for concern.
|