04-20-2022, 08:10 PM
Clarke O'Shea Kipre/Ajayi IMO would be a decent enough back 3
|
Bartley
|
|
04-20-2022, 08:10 PM
Clarke O'Shea Kipre/Ajayi IMO would be a decent enough back 3
04-20-2022, 11:27 PM
(04-20-2022, 02:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: People go on about how Ajayi is like an "attacking defender" that can't defend. Yet, Ajayi has more blocks than any other player per 90 mins this season. He's also had more successful tackles than Bartley this season by a considerable distance. He's been dribbled past less too (like this is a surpise to anyone). Isn't this just where metrics find their limitation? They can measure success in blocks, tackles, aerial duels, passes etc. What they can't do is measure the number of times a player is in the wrong place or ball watching and therefore fails to make any sort of intervention. Bartley starts in the right place but lacks pace or sharpness. Ajayi is frequently in the wrong place, but his pace helps him out. Difficult to choose between them for concentration, they're both poor. I'm surprised that Kipre scores so poorly because there seem to be fewer calamities when he's playing. Clarke is also frequently guilty of ballwatching, but has a tenacity which the other two lack. Playing a three is cheap and lazy. There's no organisation, just a lot of bodies marking zonally. No-one seems to take responsibility for shape, for picking up individual players or blocking runs - when it goes wrong it goes badly wrong. It leaves us with full backs trying to be wing backs and a player short further up the field. I hate it. Bruce should have made these players work harder at the system he wanted to play. His misguided faith in Ajayi and Bartley and his weakness in dealing with the players have left us in this mess. Reading on West Brom News recently that Ajayi might attract transfer interest from Premier League clubs was almost the high spot of the season. I wish! You mention Ajayi making decent challenges. He's solid when facing the play. I've hardly ever seen him block a cross from the bye-line. Stands back, waves a spindly leg, usually gets nutmegged, so Bartley or Clarke can be blamed when the unmarked opponent scores.
04-21-2022, 07:42 AM
Just for some context.
In the first half of this season we conceded 17 goals in 23 games. A good record, possibly the best in the league to that date. This despite constant changes to the back 3 due to injuries. Both Bartley and Ajayi played their part in that record. They are not bad players at this level and are far from the biggest problem with the playing staff. I would be quite happy if they were both here next season. But given the number of capable central defenders we have in the squad, i wouldn't be devastated if either moved on to free up resources to bring in fresh faces. The latter point could apply to almost anyone in the squad.
04-21-2022, 07:51 AM
(04-21-2022, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Just for some context. Even playing under Slav's more expansive style they still weren't that bad (45 conceded in 46 games, I think we had the third best defence, yet it's looked back on as being really bad times defence wise). Their trouble is they have no luck, and never have had. Every single mistake that one of them makes seems to lead to us conceding. As I said before a decent midfield and they look and do seem to perform better. Midfield is our biggest problem by miles.
04-21-2022, 07:58 AM
I think a midfield devoid of creativity is the issue.
Get the midfield right and next season could be much better.
04-21-2022, 08:10 AM
(04-21-2022, 07:58 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think a midfield devoid of creativity is the issue. It's not just creativity though, first half of the season we were unable to convert chances and there's nobody in the squad who's good at sitting in midfield to screen the defence and break up play (before anyone says Livermore he's at best passable at this level, he's not good at it).
04-22-2022, 08:09 AM
04-22-2022, 08:35 AM
Clean out required… he has currency and needs to go
04-22-2022, 08:52 AM
Bartley is a poor defender he is a poor version of Mings who is shite himself
"I will give it 6 months" - Duffers about GB News (16th June 2021) Channel is going strong
04-22-2022, 09:53 AM
Our main problem under Val was our shots to goals ratio. We tried to address that with the Dike signing but his early injury scuppered that. We do have absolutely no creative quality from midfield which in hindsight wasn't a problem with Val in charge as his style didn't play through midfield. I was no fan of Val's style but given the resources at his disposal it was about as good as we'd get. I didn't complain when he was sacked but I have to admit it's looking very much like the wrong decision at the moment. I don't think any of us believe we would be any worse off with him still in charge than we are now.
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|