Fans baying for blood
#31
(04-19-2022, 03:01 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

You can't have it both ways, if Bruce is such a great experienced manager then why have we ended up mid table in a very very poor Championship when we were in the Play Offs when he joined?

The transfer windows are fixed we all knew he wouldn't get new personal (though we did sign Carroll).  He actually made us worse.  The idea that the players, some of who have had international level careers have been somehow turned into league one level because of 6 months Val ball is laughable. 

I watched a game last night and the previous 13 where I still couldn't tell you want role some of the players are being asked to play and add to that not playing in-form players vs out of form players and we have the sum total of Bruce so far.

Good post.

Apart from the last couple of games he was here we were nearly always hard to break down under Val. I fully accept there were problems with lack of goals and people not enjoying the playing style but we generally had a solid base to build on and a fit Dike may have seen us stabilise in the top 6. Now we seem to have problems all over the pitch and not just in an attacking sense.
Reply
#32
(04-19-2022, 02:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: We had the best defence in the league when Val left and Bartley, Townsend and Furlong were basically playing every single week.

Robinson had contributed to 13 goals (5 goals, 8 assists) in 27 appearances, basically once every other game.

Since Bruce has come here he's contributed to 2 goals (0 assists) in 13 appearances. Once every 6-7 games.

All 4 have gotten worse since Bruce was appointed, unsurprisingly .

But Townsend and Furlong were meant to be wingbacks under Val that were very involved in our attacking play. They both offered very little. Furlong has been crap for most of his career here so not sure why that's Bruce's fault. Robinson was so bad under Val that many of us were hoping a new manager would make him better. Nope he's still crap.

(04-19-2022, 03:20 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 03:01 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

You can't have it both ways, if Bruce is such a great experienced manager then why have we ended up mid table in a very very poor Championship when we were in the Play Offs when he joined?

The transfer windows are fixed we all knew he wouldn't get new personal (though we did sign Carroll).  He actually made us worse.  The idea that the players, some of who have had international level careers have been somehow turned into league one level because of 6 months Val ball is laughable. 

I watched a game last night and the previous 13 where I still couldn't tell you want role some of the players are being asked to play and add to that not playing in-form players vs out of form players and we have the sum total of Bruce so far.

Good post.

Apart from the last couple of games he was here we were nearly always hard to break down under Val. I fully accept there were problems with lack of goals and people not enjoying the playing style but we generally had a solid base to build on and a fit Dike may have seen us stabilise in the top 6. Now we seem to have problems all over the pitch and not just in an attacking sense.

We were one of the worst form sides in the league under Val. Nothing to suggest we were going anywhere but sliding down the table.
Reply
#33
(04-19-2022, 03:01 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

You can't have it both ways, if Bruce is such a great experienced manager then why have we ended up mid table in a very very poor Championship when we were in the Play Offs when he joined?

The transfer windows are fixed we all knew he wouldn't get new personal (though we did sign Carroll).  He actually made us worse.  The idea that the players, some of who have had international level careers have been somehow turned into league one level because of 6 months Val ball is laughable. 

I watched a game last night and the previous 13 where I still couldn't tell you want role some of the players are being asked to play and add to that not playing in-form players vs out of form players and we have the sum total of Bruce so far.

Some people don’t get it. We were in the playoffs after 19 games of bottom 6 form. Another couple of weeks of Val we’d have been out of the top six if the trajectory had been the same. All Bruce has done is keep the status quo after the initial 10 game great start.

Creative use of stats have been on overdrive here of late.

As I said, Bruce has underwhelmed so far, but he has to be given half a chance.
Reply
#34
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

But seriously Spandau ,for the good of the club do you honestly think it would be a good idea to leave Bruce in charge and then we sack him after 12 games of next season and appoint a new manager who has no pre season to get ideas across.That’s the type of madness that will send us further down.The best time for a new manager to come in is at the end of this season with a full pre season to get everything in place.What you keep mentioning is to give Bruce a go and if it doesn’t work out then bin him after so many games,is that not we have done in four of the last six seasons.It’s football suicide.
Reply
#35
(04-19-2022, 03:51 PM)Huggybear Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

But seriously Spandau ,for the good of the club do you honestly think it would be a good idea to leave Bruce in charge and then we sack him after 12 games of next season and appoint a new manager who has no pre season to get ideas across.That’s the type of madness that will send us further down.The best time for a new manager to come in is at the end of this season with a full pre season to get everything in place.What you keep mentioning is to give Bruce a go and if it doesn’t work out then bin him after so many games,is that not we have done in four of the last six seasons.It’s football suicide.

Who’s to say he’ll be sacked. Perhaps he might have 5/6 decent new faces and surprise the doubters appalled that he hasn’t made a silk purse out of a two year old sow’s ear.
Reply
#36
I was all for giving Bruce at the first 12 match’s of next season
But last night’s team selection when after everything still gave us a chance
Of making the playoffs was in my eyes a surrender of his duties

I believe his initial brief was to make the playoffs he’s failed spectacularly
He must go.
Reply
#37
(04-19-2022, 03:13 PM)Psalm23 Wrote: I'm not really seeing too many fans baying for blood, what I do see is lots of fans voicing concerns that Bruce has so far shown very little to suggest that he's the right man for the job, & feel that it would be in the best interests of the club if we execise the contract break clause at the end of this season, & find a better option.

Exactly. I respect Bruce's past achievements and from all I've heard, believe he's a nice person, but from the evidence of my own eyes, he has failed to improve us on any level. I don't think we're the right club for him and I don't think he's the right manager for us.
Reply
#38
(04-19-2022, 04:41 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 03:13 PM)Psalm23 Wrote: I'm not really seeing too many fans baying for blood, what I do see is lots of fans voicing concerns that Bruce has so far shown very little to suggest that he's the right man for the job, & feel that it would be in the best interests of the club if we execise the contract break clause at the end of this season, & find a better option.

Exactly. I respect Bruce's past achievements and from all I've heard, believe he's a nice person, but from the evidence of my own eyes, he has failed to improve us on any level. I don't think we're the right club for him and I don't think he's the right manager for us.

Quite right, *any* new manager coming in will see the weaknesses of the squad and wheel and deal to bring in new faces, Bruce doesn't have the monopoly on this. We look unfit, unorganised and quite frankly unmanaged at times in the past few months. This absolutely stops at his door, if the players didn't respond to his wishes he should have left them on the sidelines until they did.

We have Dyke coming in as in effect a new signing, that will help which ever manager is in charge. But as has been stated above if Bruce didn't start well after a summer of his stamp being put on the squad then he'd be gone anyway and we'd be in November with the same problems we had when he joined.

Fresh manager, in May, new identify, old wood gone, some new faces and better use of the loan system plus continued progression of the like of O'shea and TGH and I think we are in an okay shape for a renewed push next season.

If Bruce is still here come kick off in August, there is no way our 3 season tickets are being renewed, I'll pick and chose the Saturday games on an adhoc basis and I'm sure many others will be the same.
Reply
#39
Got to go. This can’t continue.
Reply
#40
(04-19-2022, 12:43 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Except that other than for the opening sentence this is all conjecture, not fact. I fully agree though that what we’ve seen makes it plausible, but that’s still not proof that proper due diligence wasn’t followed. You could just as easily argue that despite Bruce conducting some form of analysis beforehand the squad itself is so corrupt that it is past salvaging.

You're right, it's complete conjecture.

But...If there was due diligence, well that doesn't reflect well on Bruce either. He should have tempered his expectations, expressed less shock at some of the displays and not talked about how he was just getting to know the players quite as much. None of us have met the players, but we all knew how they would behave - because we've watched them! Let's face it, none of us were surprised by any changes in form or attitude...

But even aside from that, maybe even a cogent strategy to address our very obvious weaknesses observed in the games before he arrived would have been useful. Instead, we got squads, formations and player positions that have already been tried and failed - usually for footballing reasons that we could all see. This was an unnecessary waste of games when we couldn't afford it.

FWIW, I don't think the squad is corrupt - they're just not very good and maybe, never were. Yes, almost all of them had good games, but not one of them was ever consistently above even average, much less able to sustain a run of great performances. For x sake, by the end, we were pinning all our hopes on the 'mercurial' talents of M Philips coming back and a striker who has only played the best part of an hour for us!

If that's all we have to cling to, we're obviously not very good. In fact, the only good players we have had in the last few seasons either belonged to someone else or didn't want to play for us! Thinking about it, maybe that should have been a clue of what was to come...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: