Fans baying for blood
#21
(04-19-2022, 12:36 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 11:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.

It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!

(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)

This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and  (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.

People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time. 

I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"

So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.

Except this is a highly paid professional.

You would think Mozza would be the first person Bruce would speak to, to get at least an overview and gist of what the position was at the club and in the dressing room.  Maybe it was.
If he had spoken to mozza he would had the motivation taken out of him on his first training session.
Reply
#22
What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .
Reply
#23
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.
Reply
#24
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Bartley, Townsend and Furlong were poor before Bruce was appointed and Robinson has been awful all season.

I don't understand how people can talk about how shit our players are yet blame Bruce who hasn't had a chance to bring not even one player in. Lets keep changing managers every six months, its worked well for Sunderland! We'll appoint another new manager who can give these players another chance, they'll perform poorly and then we'll want another new manager. Rinse and repeat. It's almost like we have a shit owner who is clueless, a shit recruitment team who've left us with a poor squad of aging unmotivated overpaid players and a manager at the start of the season who failed to address the teams weaknesses and brought in a load of dross and got rid of any creativity.
Reply
#25
We had the best defence in the league when Val left and Bartley, Townsend and Furlong were basically playing every single week.

Robinson had contributed to 13 goals (5 goals, 8 assists) in 27 appearances, basically once every other game.

Since Bruce has come here he's contributed to 2 goals (0 assists) in 13 appearances. Once every 6-7 games.

All 4 have gotten worse since Bruce was appointed, unsurprisingly .
Reply
#26
(04-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My issue with Bruce is I've simply seen nothing from him to suggest it'll improve in any way if he stays.

Last night's team selection can only be described as either lazy or moronic.

Exactly. But we wanted a change, We got a change and nothing matter has we slipped down the league 

"Do not Engage with me or something"
"I will give it 6 months" - Duffers about GB News (16th June 2021) Channel is going strong 
Reply
#27
I think I agree with the OP. Been reflecting on this a lot. At different times this season I think I’ve vented my spleen towards Val, the players, Bruce, back to the players and now Bruce again. I’m a 41 year old bloke and I think I, and we, need to grow up and act like adults. The players and management are just the most visible sign of the malaise in which the club sits. It’s almost like we’ve decided it’s too hard to turn our ire on the cretins running the club so we just turn up at the ground and boo or come on here and argue amongst one another, all while the ownership and those employed on decent money to run the club successfully get away scott-free. We need coordinated action to drive change but frankly I think most of us on here (me included) are either too disillusioned or too thick to challenge those responsible so we’ll just keep screaming abuse at whichever manager we have for whatever 6 - 18 month period.
Reply
#28
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

You can't have it both ways, if Bruce is such a great experienced manager then why have we ended up mid table in a very very poor Championship when we were in the Play Offs when he joined?

The transfer windows are fixed we all knew he wouldn't get new personal (though we did sign Carroll). He actually made us worse. The idea that the players, some of who have had international level careers have been somehow turned into league one level because of 6 months Val ball is laughable.

I watched a game last night and the previous 13 where I still couldn't tell you want role some of the players are being asked to play and add to that not playing in-form players vs out of form players and we have the sum total of Bruce so far.
Reply
#29
(04-19-2022, 02:14 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2022, 02:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: What makes people think that if Bruce brings his own players in that there is going to be an improvement.At Villa he had a squad including Grealish and Mcginn among many others and he still couldn’t get them up and as soon as Smith came in Villa improved.Why did they improve?The simple answer was that Smith could coach and improve players and was tactically better.This squad of players we have is far from perfect and we all know we lack a creative midfielder but I’ve got to say the performances of some since Bruce came in has deteriorated to rock bottom.Furlong,Townsend,Bartley and Robinson are just a few who although people don’t like to admit it are playing nothing like they have done in the past.The fact that there are still fans out there who want Bruce for next season is very worrying and I can only put it down to a lack of knowledge .

Lack of knowledge! A rash statement that is a dizzying mix of arrogance and ignorance. This is about opinions and whilst you look for the negative, let's also say he's managed to beat the top 2 with these wasters. Also, maybe he should be allowed the chance to get a creative midfielder or any midfielder. He found a bloke called McGinn at Villa who is doing OK you know.

If Bruce is such a buffoon he's managed to carve quite a managerial career, with all his previous clubs of a good standing. If he's yesterday's man then so be it, but give him a chance if he wants it.

Bruce has had 3 months to suss it out and 20 years experience at a good level before that. He hasn't blagged it- he's not applied to be a manager in a Burger King.

Of course, Bruce might be past it, but he deserves at least what his previous incumbent had, which is a window to chop and change. 

Your post epitomises exactly what my thread is about. It's imbecilic the scapegoating of him and trying to get on a football pedestal doesn't serve you well. You haven't the patience to start a new paragraph let alone give a manager time.

But seriously Spandau ,for the good of the club do you honestly think it would be a good idea to leave Bruce in charge and then we sack him after 12 games of next season and appoint a new manager who has no pre season to get ideas across.That’s the type of madness that will send us further down.The best time for a new manager to come in is at the end of this season with a full pre season to get everything in place.What you keep mentioning is to give Bruce a go and if it doesn’t work out then bin him after so many games,is that not we have done in four of the last six seasons.It’s football suicide.
Reply
#30
I'm not really seeing too many fans baying for blood, what I do see is lots of fans voicing concerns that Bruce has so far shown very little to suggest that he's the right man for the job, & feel that it would be in the best interests of the club if we execise the contract break clause at the end of this season, & find a better option.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: